Best Eyebrow Pencils of 2026

"I've tried pricier brow pencils, but this one is unbeatable for the price and performance. The tip is just right for natural definition, and it lasts all day. I always end up coming back to it because it blends well and never looks harsh."

"As someone who's gone through countless brow pencils, this is the best drugstore option I've found. The super fine tip makes precise, hair-like strokes easy, and it actually stays put without smearing. The Ash Brown shade is perfectly neutral with no red undertones—a rare find at this price point."

"I’ve struggled with brow products pulling orange on me, but this pencil in Ash Brown is the perfect cool-toned shade. The pigment is just right and the pencil is solidly made. I’m genuinely impressed and would pay more, but I’m glad it’s such a steal. Wet n Wild outperformed even my high-end favorites."

"After decades of searching, I can confidently say this is the best brow pencil I've ever used. The micro-fine tip lets me create hair-like strokes, and it stays put for at least 24 hours—even through long days and nights. The auburn shade looks truly natural, not too dark or orange. This pencil meets all my needs, and I couldn't be happier. If you want a reliable, long-wearing brow pencil, don't hesitate—it's worth every penny."

"As someone with super light, sparse brows due to Hashimoto's, I'm relieved to have found a pencil in a blonde shade that looks natural and doesn't overpower my face. Most pencils are way too dark, but this one blends beautifully and looks subtle. The fine tip and included brush make it so easy to get a natural effect. Finally, a shade for blondes at a great price!"

"I've tried countless brow pencils, but this has become my go-to for its precision and ease of use. The ultra-thin tip lets me fill in sparse areas without looking overdone, and it glides on smoothly—not too waxy or dry. The color selection is spot on for brunettes, and I love not needing to sharpen it. It's dependable and one of the best drugstore finds for natural brows."

"I've been using the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in Soft Brown for a year, and it’s honestly become my go-to for brows. The shade is perfectly balanced for medium to light brown hair—never too red or ashy—and always leaves my brows looking soft and natural. It’s super user-friendly, even for beginners, and I can’t recommend it enough for anyone wanting effortless, natural brows."

"I gravitate toward trendy makeup brands, but this Maybelline pencil really surprised me. I have a scar in my brow, and nothing fills it as naturally as this does. The chiseled tip lets me create hair-like strokes or fill in quickly, and the color (medium brown) is genuinely true to shade. Plus, the price is unbeatable for the quality. I like that the pencil’s length is comfortable to hold—just the right size. It’s smooth, stays on, and just works."

"I almost gave up on finding a good blonde brow pencil, but this one changed my mind. The blonde shade gives just the right amount of definition without being too dark or too warm, creating fluffy but natural-looking brows. It applies smoothly, fills in sparse areas easily, and finally gives me brows that match my hair. No more weird orange or red tones—just a true ash blonde look."

"I've tried countless brow pencils and this one has become my absolute favorite. The ultra-fine tip lets me fill in sparse areas with amazing precision, and the texture glides on effortlessly without being waxy or dry. The shade for dark brunettes is spot-on—never too warm or ashy. It stays in place all day and I love not having to sharpen it. This is definitely one of the best drugstore brow pencils I've found."

"As someone with very light, sparse eyebrows due to Hashimoto’s, it’s a struggle to find a brow pencil that isn’t too dark or harsh. The blonde shade in this pencil is perfect for me—subtle, natural, and never overdone. I appreciate how it lets me create brows that look real, not drawn on."

"I’ve used this brow pencil for more than a year and it’s the only one I trust. The fine tip gives me just the right definition without making my brows look heavy or fake. I have sensitive skin and this pencil has never caused irritation or breakouts. It blends beautifully for a natural or more dramatic look, depending on my mood, and the color stays true with no weird undertones. My only wish is that you got a bit more product for the price, but nothing else compares for my needs."

"I've tried countless brow pencils, but this one stands out as my absolute favorite. It's both affordable and long-wearing—it stays put until I remove it. I have light brown hair with highlights, and both the hazel and brown shades work perfectly, whether I want a natural or defined look. What I love most is how easily it fills in sparse areas and helps me shape my brows effortlessly. Even after trying high-end brands like MAC and Anastasia, I always come back to this pencil."

"For me, the smooth application and strong color payoff make this brow pencil a staple in my routine. It lasts all day, even when my skin gets oily, and the built-in brush is super handy for blending. I appreciate that it's affordable and gives me natural-looking brows without any hassle."

"I've been using the Rimmel eyebrow pencil for over five years now, and people often compliment how perfect and natural my brows look. It's the only pencil I rely on, and I always recommend it to friends who want a reliable, easy-to-use product."

"This brow pencil is my favorite for everyday use—the color blends beautifully, and the spoolie makes shaping so easy! It’s affordable, simple, and the results look natural and stay put all day."

"I’m impressed by how well this pencil performs for the price. The dual-ended design is super convenient, and the shade matches my brows perfectly. The only minor downside is it doesn’t last as long as I’d like, but for the cost, I’m not complaining!"

"As a dirty blonde, I love that this pencil gives a soft, natural look without making my brows too dark. It’s easy to apply and lasts a long time—plus, the brush blends everything nicely."

"I've tried many brow pencils, but this one is hands down my favorite for everyday use. The formula is incredibly smooth and easy to work with, and the built-in spoolie makes blending a breeze. I love how my brows look naturally defined without any harsh lines, and the pencil stays put all day. For the price, it's honestly unbeatable."

"As I've gotten older, my brows have become thinner and lighter, but this pencil fills them in beautifully without looking fake. I can easily blend for a natural effect, and the price is fantastic. I highly recommend it, especially if you're after a more subtle look."

"I have light brown hair and it's tough to find a good shade match, but this pencil is the best match I've found. It's super easy to use, though I do wish there was a bit more product inside. Still, I'll keep buying it because the color and application are just right."

"This brow pencil is my everyday staple—the coverage is fantastic, easy to build, and the spoolie makes blending a breeze. I love that there are multiple shades, and the price can't be beat. Thank you, Elf, for making such a great product!"

"I was really impressed by how smoothly this pencil applies and how natural the color looks on my brows. The little brush at the end makes shaping simple, and the color stays put all day. For the price, it’s unbeatable—definitely a new favorite in my routine."

"The dual-sided design with the brush is super handy for shaping and blending, and the taupe shade matches my light brown hair perfectly. It lasts all day and looks natural, plus it’s a fantastic value. My only tiny complaint is that it runs out faster than I’d like, but for the cost, I don’t mind restocking."

"After using the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in Soft Brown for a year, I can confidently say it's one of the best drugstore brow products out there. The shade is perfect for medium to light brown hair—not too warm or ashy, and it creates an incredibly natural effect. If you want a brow pencil that's easy for beginners and gives real results, this is a must-try. Highly recommended!"

"I've tried so many trendy brow products, but Maybelline's pencil stands out as a rare combination of affordability and quality. I have a scar in my brow, and this pencil fills it in better than anything else I've used. The chiseled tip is extremely versatile for both detailed and broader strokes, the texture is smooth, and the true medium brown color is spot on. Plus, it's the perfect length for handling. I like it a lot!"

"I usually subscribe to the medium brown shade, but after trying the soft brown, I’m considering switching because the color matches my brows so well. The pencil is affordable, easy to use, and delivers a natural look. I just wish the soft brown was always as budget-friendly as the medium brown. Overall, it’s a dependable, everyday brow pencil that I’m happy with."

"I've repurchased this brow pencil multiple times because it's so precise and natural-looking. The fine tip lets me create both soft and bold strokes, and it really lasts all day. The only thing is, I wish the pencil lasted a bit longer, and you have to be gentle so it doesn’t break."

"For someone with sparse or uneven brows, this pencil is a game changer. The micro tip makes realistic, hair-like strokes easy, and the ash brown shade is spot-on—no weird orange tones. It goes on smooth, blends with the spoolie, and always looks soft and natural. I usually top it with gel just for extra hold, but the pencil alone stays put. Totally my favorite for quick, everyday makeup."

"Compared to other drugstore brow pencils, this one stands out for its thin tip and non-greasy formula. I can make tiny, natural strokes, and the price is fantastic. It lasts longer than others I’ve tried and blends easily for a fuller brow look."