Best Eyebrow Pencils of 2025

"These are my favorite eyebrow pencils ever. I always order at least two when I run out! I love using a lighter and a darker shade to create a gradient effect. When I'm short on time, one shade does the trick. They are retractable, the perfect width for detailing, and the colors are very natural. They hold up well even where I have sparse hairs, and they’re affordable! I've tried many others, but these are my top choice!"

"I've been using the ash blonde color for over a year. However, I found that the color depiction is off; it looks more like a sandy blonde on me. It does a great job filling in my very light eyebrows without making them look too dark."

"This NYX brow pencil has been my best ally for years. The fine tip allows for precision, and it creates natural-looking strokes. I love the dual-ended design with the spoolie for blending. The color lasts all day, even in heat, and finding my perfect shade was a huge bonus. It's easy to use, durable, and reasonably priced!"

"I’ve always had very light eyebrows, and I’ve been using Maybelline eyeliner and eyebrow pencils since my early 20s—50 years now! I couldn’t find my usual light brown shade anymore, but I’m thrilled with this new product. It’s easier to apply because the pencil is softer. I’m very active and this eyebrow pencil stays on through sweating, swimming, and even washing my hair. I give Maybelline a 5-star rating for this new product!"

"As a busy mom of two, my mornings need to be quick and simple! This brow pencil really packs a punch! I love how efficient it is for my routine."

"This is my favorite brow pencil! I’ve tested many products and this one never disappoints! It’s affordable and long-lasting—I don’t have to worry about it fading away during the day!"

"I've been using this eyebrow pencil for over 10 years! It's my go-to product and the price is just a little over a dollar. I love it!"

"To my surprise, this product worked better than the previous brand I used. The cost is unbeatable!"

"I love this eyebrow pencil! The color is vibrant, and it's simple to use. I highly recommend it to others, especially beginners!"

"I love how perfectly shaped my brows look! This pencil is so easy to use and very affordable. I've already used it all up!"

"As someone with dark hair but a muted palette, finding the right brow color was difficult. This soft brown shade is just right, unlike others that were too orange or grey. It applies more precisely than similar products!"

"After trying various brow pencils, this one is my absolute favorite! Great color payoff, easy application, and it doesn't break easily. I often switch between medium and soft brown, but both work wonderfully!"

"This has been my go-to product for years! It never disappoints, and I consistently receive compliments on my eyebrows. I love mixing shades for a natural look, especially the ashy tones that don’t have any orange undertones like cheaper brands. E.L.F. really excels!"

"I've always appreciated E.L.F. products, and this one is no exception. As someone with thinning brows, I was thrilled to find the perfect shade match. It holds up incredibly well, lasting through my 12 to 16-hour shifts!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by this eyebrow pencil. It provides a natural finish without looking fake. I chose a shade lighter than my natural brows, and it turned out really good. I have used more expensive brands without better results."

"I have silver eyebrows, and this pencil offers the best coverage at a reasonable price. I will definitely order again!"

"As an Auburn person, I find this the best eyebrow pencil! It's simple to use and stays put!"

"I was impressed with the Dark Brown shade of this pencil. It’s easy to use and provides a natural finish that lasts all day, even in heat or humidity!"

"I’ve completely transformed my brow routine with this 2-in-1 brow pen! I chose the light brown shade to achieve a more natural look, avoiding that overly drawn-on appearance. Its user-friendly design makes it easy to master the application, and I can achieve defined brows in seconds. The longevity is impressive, lasting all day without fading. Plus, it wipes away easily with my regular makeup remover."

"After chemotherapy, I struggled with sparse eyebrows. I found that starting with the single 'hair' end and working my way in gave me the best shape. I love the flick end for adding those hairlike strokes and finishing with the brush for a softer look. It may look a bit shiny on bare skin, but the brush helps blend it out."

"I really appreciate the double-sided design of this brow pen. I fill in my brows with a pencil and use the flick end for hairlike strokes at the front. I wish there was a shade between brown and dark brown, and it would be great if the caps were color-coded for easier identification. Overall, it's a great product and I love the included brow brush!"

"I've tried many eyebrow pencils, and this one is perfect! It slides on smoothly and is easy to use, making my brows look natural. I use the Soft Brown, and it blends perfectly with my darker eyebrows. You won't be disappointed!"

"For years, I've relied on this brown pencil. It fills in my blank spots and doesn't fade throughout the day. I'm very satisfied!"

"I absolutely love how smooth it goes on! The brush on the other end matches the color perfectly. I've been using it for years and it's still my favorite!"

"I have hypothyroidism and struggle with bald spots in my brows. After trying numerous brow products, I found this pencil to be fantastic! It looks natural and saves me time since I don't have to keep redoing it. I'm giving this 5 stars!"

"I was using sharpenable eyeliner pencils, but on a whim, I decided to try this and I'm so happy I did! It applies much easier, and the natural brown color is just right. I won’t go back to regular pencils!"

"I was a die-hard pomade user but wanted a more natural look. This pencil applies so smoothly, the color is perfect, and it lasts all day. I've purchased a second one and I’m definitely not going back!"

"I'm a huge fan of this brand! It goes on smoothly and lasts all day."

"I adore the color Hazel with my golden blonde hair. It's creamy and adheres well to brow hair, although it doesn’t stay on the skin as well for added depth and shape."

"I've been using this eyebrow pencil for many years now. I would definitely encourage others to try it; it's worth every penny."