Best Hypoallergenic Eyebrow Pencils of 2025

This eyebrow pencil by Almay comes in 802 Brunette and has a triple tool for perfect brows. The pointed tip defines, the flat edge fills, and the brush tames and blurs brows. It's safe for sensitive eyes and ophthalmologist tested. It's available in two shades.

The Marcelle Nano Retractable Eyebrow Liner, also known as Marcelle Eyebrow Liner, is a must-have for achieving perfectly shaped brows. With its ultra-precise and extra-thin lead, you can easily create a flawless shape with maximum control. The medium coverage and matte finish of this pencil provide a natural look that lasts all day. The built-in brush tip allows you to effortlessly shape and groom your brows for a polished appearance. Plus, Marcelle is a cruelty-free brand, certified by PETA, so you can feel good about using their products. Say goodbye to unruly brows and hello to defined perfection with Marcelle Eyebrow Liner.

The Kosas Brow Pop Nano is designed to help you achieve beautifully defined eyebrows with ease. Its ultra-fine 1mm precision tip allows you to create hair-like strokes, making it simple to fill in sparse areas for a natural look. You’ll appreciate that it doesn’t require sharpening, maintaining its fine tip for consistent application every time. The long-wearing formula ensures your brows stay smudge-proof throughout the day, so you can look your best without constant touch-ups. Plus, it's safe for sensitive skin, giving you peace of mind while enhancing your beauty.

The GladGirl Highlighter Pencil is designed to enhance your eyes with ease. You can quickly brighten your brow bone with its translucent shimmer or natural matte finish, adding a beautiful glow. Apply it to your inner eyelids for a fresh, dewy appearance that combats tired-looking eyes. This highlighter pencil is durable enough for daily use, making it perfect for both professional makeup artists and anyone wanting to elevate their beauty routine. Plus, it’s made with vegan and cruelty-free ingredients, ensuring it’s safe for even the most sensitive skin.

The SAUBZEAN Eyebrow Pen is designed to help you achieve beautifully defined eyebrows that look completely natural. With its four-point micro-fork tips, you can easily outline and fill in your brows, saving you valuable time in your makeup routine. This pen features a long-lasting formula that is waterproof, sweat-proof, and smudge-proof, ensuring your brows stay perfect all day long. Additionally, its high-quality metal applicator provides a smooth application, making it a portable addition to your makeup bag. Whether for daily use or special occasions, this eyebrow pen is a must-have for effortless beauty.

COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil in Soft Brown is a brow filling pencil that has a micro-fine tip to easily fill and define your brow. It has a built-in spoolie to blend in color for natural-looking results. The hypoallergenic formula is safe for sensitive eyes and is easy to use without any sharpening needed. Just swipe the brush over the tip of the pencil and apply to your eyebrows in short strokes from front to back.

The INIKA Organic Brow Pencil in Blonde is a vegan and non-toxic eyebrow color that allows you to achieve perfectly defined arches. The pencil is enriched with organic coconut oil, making the texture soft and creamy so it can effortlessly glide over your eyebrows. It can be used to accentuate or lift the natural shape of your eyebrows, fill in missing hairs, or enhance the color for added definition. The pencil offers grooming alongside extreme color precision with no waxy residue.

The SORMÉ Brow Pencil is designed to help you achieve beautifully defined eyebrows effortlessly. With rich color, you can create natural-looking details that enhance your features. Its waterproof formula ensures that your brows stay put all day, resisting smudges and sweat, so you won’t need constant touch-ups. The built-in spoolie simplifies the application process by allowing you to shape your brows before filling them in. Whether you prefer a bold or natural look, this pencil is a must-have in your makeup kit for perfect brows every time.