Best Eye Liners of 2026

"I’ve tried a lot of eyeliners, and this one is by far my favorite. The brown shade is gorgeous on my fair skin, and I love how quickly it dries and how simple it is to apply. Even when I've accidentally gotten it in my eyes, it hasn't caused any irritation. While it can come off if I rub my eyes, the wear time is pretty impressive. My only minor gripe is that the cap sometimes gets messy lately, but overall, I’d definitely recommend it."

"For the price, this eyeliner is absolutely impressive. The fine, small brush lets me control the thickness easily, and the pigmentation is strong and bold. I have sensitive eyes, but there’s no irritation at all, and it really stays put throughout the day. The quick-dry formula is a bonus, too."

"I was searching for a good alternative to the KVD tattoo liner because I have oily eyelids and struggle with smudging. This one does smudge a little after a few hours for me, but the application is smooth and the product quality is solid. If you don’t have oily skin, I think it would be an excellent choice."

"I've been using this eyeliner for a few months and I'm genuinely impressed by its long-lasting, truly waterproof formula. The pencil glides on smoothly without tugging, and even through heat and humidity, it doesn't budge all day. I also appreciate the built-in sharpener, which keeps the tip precise. For the price, I think it's a fantastic everyday choice."

"Since my eyes water a lot, a reliable waterproof eyeliner is essential for me. Most liners fade quickly, but this one lasts all day. The sponge tip and built-in sharpener are nice touches, and even though it takes a little extra effort to remove, it works exactly as advertised."

"I've tried plenty of other brands, but I always end up returning to this one. The color is bold and rich, it stays put all day without smudging, and the 2-pack offers great value. The built-in sharpener makes it super convenient, and it's definitely one of the most dependable eyeliners I've used."

"I've been using this eyeliner for several months and I'm genuinely impressed by its long wear and dependable waterproof performance. The pencil applies smoothly without tugging, and the deep black shade makes my eyes stand out whether I want a subtle or dramatic look. The built-in sharpener adds convenience, and the two-pack is a fantastic deal. For the price and results, this is my go-to everyday eyeliner."

"As someone with watery eyes, I need a liner that will stay put—and this one lasts all day without smudging. I appreciate the sponge tip and sharpener, and while it can get a little smudgy by day's end if I dab my eyes, it still outperforms others I've tried. It takes a bit more effort to remove, but that's a small trade-off for the reliable, waterproof formula."

"I've tried other brands but always come back to this eyeliner. The color is bold and rich, it stays in place even during heat or humidity, and the built-in sharpener keeps it precise. The two-pack offers great value, and I use it nearly every day. Truly, it's one of the most reliable eyeliners I've used."

"After using countless liquid eyeliners, I finally found one that checks all my boxes. The pen offers fantastic grip, the formula is just right—not too wet or runny—and it lasts all day without smudging or bleeding. I love the brown shade; it’s a true dark brown, not too warm. I’m definitely trying the black next!"

"This eyeliner immediately won me over with its precision and smooth, skip-free application. The intensely pigmented black is stunning, and the waterproof formula survives even workouts and rainy days. I love how easily it comes off with my regular remover. I’ll keep this in my daily makeup routine for sure."

"I have sensitive skin and this eyeliner has never irritated me. The brush glides smoothly, lets me create thick or thin lines, and stays put all day without smudging. I keep coming back to this one because it just works so well for me!"

"I've put this eyeliner to the test—cried, slept, even went swimming, and it still stayed put! The felt tip gives me sharp, clean lines every time, whether I want something ultra thin or bold. Super easy to use and doesn’t smudge or feather on me. This completely changed my mind about felt tip liners."

"I love how this eyeliner glides on so smoothly and delivers intense, deep color with one swipe. Whether I'm doing a subtle day look or a dramatic cat eye, it always makes my eyes pop and the pigment never fades. I’ll definitely be repurchasing!"

"For me, the application is effortless and the tip is amazing for control, but if my eyes water or get oily, I notice a little smudging at the corners. It’s not a dealbreaker—the ease of use and rich color outweigh that small issue. I just prep my lids and it performs great."

"This has quickly become my go-to liquid eyeliner. It glides on effortlessly and the color is super black, just like I want. It stays put all day without smudging or irritating my eyes. While it does take a little extra effort to remove—water alone won't cut it—I don't mind at all."

"I've tried a lot of liquid liners, but this one from Revlon is a staple in my makeup bag. The felt tip is just the right firmness and makes it so easy to get a sharp wing or a thin line. The pigment is rich and it never flakes or fades, even in humidity. For the price, the quality can't be beat."

"As someone with sensitive, tear-prone eyes, this eyeliner has been a game-changer. The angled felt tip lets me create identical wings on both eyes and the formula never smudges or runs. Even on days when my eyes water, it stays fresh and flawless. Finally, I've found something truly longwearing that doesn't irritate!"

"I work long hours and rely on this eyeliner because it stays put for 12-16 hours without smudging or fading. The deep black color applies smoothly, and I no longer feel the need to buy more expensive brands. For the quality and affordability, it can't be beat."

"After years of trying out different liners, this one has become my holy grail. It's easy to create sharp cat eyes, the formula isn't streaky or sheer, and it feels comfortable—never sticky. I appreciate that it's matte enough for my taste and the true black color always delivers."

"I have oily eyelids and most eyeliners don't last on me, but this one holds up all day—even through sweaty, long nights. The color is intense yet natural, and the value is far better than what I was getting from more expensive brands. I'm definitely sticking with this eyeliner!"

"I've used this eyeliner for months and I'm genuinely impressed by how smoothly it glides on and how truly waterproof and smudge-proof it is. Even after a long, hot day, my liner stays put. The built-in sharpener is super handy and the color is bold and rich. For the price, it's an excellent everyday choice for those needing long wear and reliable performance."

"My eyes water a lot, so finding a waterproof eyeliner that actually lasts all day is huge for me. This one doesn't smudge until I dab my eyes a lot, and it even survives my watery eyes better than most. I also really appreciate the sponge tip and built-in sharpener for convenience. It does take a touch more effort to remove, but that's just proof it works!"

"I've tried several brands, but I always come back to Revlon ColorStay. The liner goes on super smoothly, the black shade is bold, and most importantly, it stays put without smudging or creating raccoon eyes, even in humidity. The two-pack is a great value since I use eyeliner daily. I highly recommend it for dependability."

"I've been using this eyeliner for years and it's truly perfect for daily use. I never have to worry about sharpening, and it delivers a consistent result every time, even when my hands aren't steady. It sets quickly, lasts all day, and even survives my workouts. As a contacts wearer, I appreciate that it doesn't irritate my eyes."

"This eyeliner is my go-to now! It goes on smoothly, feels lightweight, and lasts all day. The value is excellent for the price, and I get asked about it all the time. I'll definitely be ordering more!"

"I like how easy it is to apply, and the soft brown shade adds natural definition. It stays put pretty well, though I do notice some fading on the waterline after several hours. For the price and convenience, it's a solid, fuss-free option for everyday wear."

"I've relied on this eyeliner for years, and it never fails me, even during long overnight shifts as a nurse. The formula stays put with zero smudging for my entire 13-hour shift, and the brush delivers precision once you get used to it."

"After searching for a liquid liner with a brush tip instead of felt, I found this one. It applies effortlessly, the color is rich, and I feel it’s worth every penny. The fine brush makes it easy to achieve clean lines."

"I've worn this every single day since 2009, through sweltering heat, emotional events, and all kinds of climates. This eyeliner has never let me down, and I would rate it six stars if I could. Absolutely the most reliable product in my routine."