Best Paraben-Free Eyebrow Pencils of 2025

ZUZU LUXE Brow Pencil is a natural, vegan, and gluten-free eyebrow color that effortlessly sculpts and defines your eyebrows. With its creamy formula, you can easily fill in sparse areas, create beautifully shaped brows, and achieve a natural finish. The secret ingredient, Sea Fennel, provides rich nutrients for healthier-looking brows. Made in the USA, this cruelty-free product is safe for all skin types. Say goodbye to parabens and coal tar derivatives with this paraben-free brow pencil. With ZUZU LUXE Brow Pencil, you can confidently enhance your eyebrows and achieve the perfect brow look every day.

The Mineral Fusion Retractable Brow Pencil is a botanical infused hypoallergenic eyebrow pencil that makes it easy to shape, fill, and define for natural looking eyebrows. The thin spoolie is ideal for shaping and blending color for a more natural look. The velvety, glide-on mineral pigments provide buildable, long-lasting natural color. This pencil is a dual-ended perfect all-in-one brow tool. Mineral Fusion also offers a wide range of products that are made in the USA, free of harsh chemicals, and never tested on animals.

The Claraline Eyebrow Pencil is your go-to for achieving beautifully shaped brows. Its paraben-free formula ensures that you can use it without worrying about harsh preservatives. This pencil offers buildable color, allowing you to create the perfect brow intensity that suits your style. You’ll appreciate its smooth texture, which makes application a breeze, giving you natural-looking results. Plus, this long-lasting formula means your brows will stay defined all day. With Claraline being cruelty-free, you can feel good about your choice in beauty products.

The Chella Brown Eyebrow Pencil in Tantalizing Taupe is the perfect shade for lighter hair and is buildable for a light fill to a cooler brown. Chella's mission is to simplify the eyebrow routine with their "How to Brow in 3 Easy Steps" - Fill, Define, Highlight. Their products are vegan, cruelty-free, paraben-free, gluten-free, and recyclable. The eyebrow pencil has a long-wearing and smooth consistency that allows for easy application and blending for a natural finish. A pro tip from Chella is to gradually darken the brow using the pencil for color.

The Pixi Brow Duo is designed to help you achieve perfect brows that complement your eyes. This dual-ended tool features a waterproof pencil for precise application, allowing you to fill in sparse areas effortlessly. The tinted gel on the other end helps keep your brows in place all day, even if they tend to be unruly. With four shades available, you can easily find a match for your natural brow color. Plus, it’s gentle on the skin, being fragrance-free and paraben-free, making it suitable for everyone.

Enhance your brows and make your eyes pop with the Beauty Junkees Eye Brightener Stick. This multitasking pencil features two shades - a matte shade for defining and concealing, and a shimmery shade for adding a natural lift to your brow and highlighting the inner corners of your eyes. Perfect your brows with the matte shade, and then use the shimmery shade to brighten your waterline and highlight your best features. This duo pencil is paraben-free, gluten-free, and cruelty-free, making it a must-have for any makeup lover. Get perfectly shaped brows and make your eyes shine with the Beauty Junkees Eye Brightener Stick.

The Chella Eyebrow Pencil offers a simple way to achieve precise and natural-looking brows without the hassle of a sharpener. Its long-lasting, smooth formula glides on effortlessly, giving you control over your application. You can easily blend the product for a soft finish. For optimal results, brush your brows upward to see their natural shape and direction, then lightly apply the pencil, gradually building up color as you move from the front to the tail of your brows. This makes it easier for you to create the perfect arch that suits your face.

Brow Me by Makup is an innovative eyebrow sculpting formula that combines the strength of a wax with the drying properties of a gel. Its vegan and paraben-free ingredients make it safe for use and suitable for all skin types. The formula is long-lasting, water and sweat-resistant, providing a clear matte finish. Infused with Vitamin E, it helps shape and control your brows all day long.

The Chella Eyebrow Pencil in Dazzling Dark Brown offers a variety of benefits for achieving the perfect brow look. As a vegan product, it aligns with your ethical choices while being gluten-free and cruelty-free, ensuring no animals were harmed in the process. The absence of parabens makes it a safer option for your skin, giving you peace of mind as you apply it. Furthermore, its long-wearing formula means you can enjoy beautifully defined brows throughout the day without constant touch-ups. The smooth consistency allows for easy application, making it simple for you to achieve a natural or bold look effortlessly.

The JOAH Brow Pencil and Gel is a versatile 2-in-1 product designed to enhance your brows effortlessly. The triangular pencil tip allows you to create precise lines and fill in your brows for a natural look. Meanwhile, the tinted gel volumizes and intensifies your brow color, while keeping everything neatly in place. With its long-lasting vegan formula, you can enjoy smudge-free wear throughout the day. Plus, the lightweight and water-resistant gel ensures your brows stay flawless, no matter the conditions. This product is perfect for achieving that polished brow look you desire.