Best Eyebrow Pencil Creams of 2025

The e.l.f. Ultra Precise Brow Pencil is the perfect tool to create natural-looking brows. The super precise tip helps define and fill in gaps that mimic the look of real hair. The micro-slim liner and brush allow you to effortlessly tame and comb brows to create a fuller finish. Its compact design makes it ideal for travel or on-the-go use. Plus, it is cruelty-free, vegan, and free from harmful chemicals like Phthalates, Parabens, Nonylphenol, Ethoxylates, Triclosan, and triclocarban.

The Maybelline Brow Extensions Fiber Pomade Crayon Eyebrow Makeup is a fiber-packed pomade crayon that delivers thick, natural-looking eyebrows instantly, infused with hair-like fibers that adhere to brow hairs for a full, thicker brow look. It thickens as it colors with a natural, matte finish, offering a mess-free application that keeps brows in place. Maybelline provides everything you need, from foundation to lip products, and can be removed easily with Garnier Micellar Water.

Introducing the Maybelline TattooStudio Eyebrow Pencil, the ultimate solution for achieving defined, natural-looking brows that last up to 36 hours. This sharpenable pencil delivers high levels of pigment, ensuring fade-free and waterproof brows. The sweat-resistant and smudge-resistant formula means your brows will stay put all day long. Say goodbye to sparse eyebrows as this longwear brow pencil effortlessly fills them in with ease and perfection. The included spoolie brush allows for easy blending, leaving you with brows that wow. With Maybelline, you can create any look, from flawless foundation to stunning eye makeup and showstopping lips. Say hello to perfectly defined brows with Maybelline Eyebrow Pencil.

Enhance your eyebrows with the NYX Brow Contour Pencil. This dual-ended eyebrow pencil features a built-in eyebrow pencil to shape and fill in your brows, as well as a concealer pencil highlighter to add a touch of brightness to your brow bone or clean up any messy lines. Achieve natural-looking eyebrows and highlight your eyes with the cream highlighter shade and the eyebrow shade. The NYX Brow Contour Pencil is available in various shades to match your natural hair color. Take your eyebrow game to the next level with this cruelty-free eyebrow enhancer from NYX Professional Makeup.

SORME Treatment Cosmetics Eyebrow Pencil is a moisturizing and sturdy eyebrow pencil that provides a brighter, more awake appearance to your eyes. The creamy formula is easy to use and blends well, giving you brighter and more prominent eyebrows in an instant. The pencil is smearproof and hydrating, so it won't get messy. It's naturally hydrating and suits all skin types, as it doesn't contain any harmful ingredients. Additionally, the brand is committed to promoting beauty, creativity, and self-expression, and offers a replacement if it doesn't meet your expectations.

The Generic Eyebrow Set is designed to help you achieve natural-looking brows effortlessly. With its eyebrow cream and pencil, you can fill and define your eyebrows for a fuller appearance. The unique double-headed pencil features a triangular tip for precise application and a brush for easy blending. Enjoy the confidence of long-lasting wear, as this set is waterproof and smudge-proof, ensuring your brows stay in place throughout the day. Additionally, the smooth, paste-like texture makes application a breeze, allowing you to achieve even coverage without any caking.

Get perfect eyebrows with SHEGLAM Dual-Sided Eyebrow Pencils. This 2-in-1 pencil features a waterproof matte cream tip that allows you to create precise lines that mimic the natural grain of your eyebrow hairs. The other end of the pencil offers a luxe liquid that is waterproof, sweat-proof, and oil-resistant, giving you a well-rounded shade. With its long-lasting wear, you can confidently rock your perfect brows all day long, rain or shine. The unique formula and precision tip effortlessly mimic the appearance of real brow hairs, allowing you to achieve naturally defined brows. Plus, it's cruelty-free, so you can feel good about your purchase.

The AFGHOUZ Brow Pencil is designed for precision and ease in shaping your eyebrows. Its creamy formula allows you to create defined, natural-looking brows without any breakage. The dual-ended design features a triangular tip for filling in brows and an eyebrow brush for blending and smoothing. You can enjoy effortless application with its ultra-fine tip, which instantly outlines and fills your brows for a polished finish. Plus, the waterproof formula ensures that your brows stay in place all day, no matter the weather, giving you confidence in your look.

The e.l.f. Brow Pencil is designed to help you shape, fill, and define your eyebrows effortlessly, ensuring a long-lasting look no matter the weather. With its dual-sided feature, you can achieve precise application using the fine tip for filling in sparse areas or creating bold lines. The creamy formula glides on smoothly, making it easy to use. Plus, the spoolie end allows you to groom and shape your brow hairs for a natural finish. Available in six shades, this pencil offers versatility to match your desired look.

The Covergirl Brow Filler Pomade offers an ultra-precise beveled tip, allowing you to fill and shape your brows with ease. Its creamy, highly pigmented formula glides on smoothly, ensuring a non-drying soft matte finish that lasts throughout the day. You can blend and soften the color effortlessly with the included paddle-shaped kabuki brush. Plus, this brow pencil features a clean, vegan formula enriched with beneficial ingredients like vitamin E, hyaluronic acid, and squalane, giving your brows the care they deserve while you achieve a polished look.