Best Cream Eyeshadow of 2025

“I love how quick and easy it is to apply and layer. Julep is now my go-to brand for eyeshadow. The colors are beautiful and natural looking, and I appreciate the built-in blending tool, making it convenient for travel.”

“These eye sticks have completely transformed my makeup routine. They sweep on quickly and blend easily, providing a sheer color that doesn’t settle into lines. I’ve recommended them to all my friends, and I’m even buying some for my 80-year-old mother!”

“I’m really impressed with how effortlessly this glides on. It dries quickly and blends beautifully, providing a luxurious feel. I’ve even worn it overnight, and it still looks great in the morning!”

"I really enjoy this eyeshadow palette. The cream formula blends effortlessly with either my fingertip or a brush, and it doesn't crease like powder shadows do."

"I was drawn to the wild orchids palette, thinking it was the perfect Y2K eye colors. However, when it arrived, I was a bit disappointed. The texture felt more like sticky lip gloss rather than a cream eyeshadow, and the color payoff was lacking."

"I’ve been using cream eyeshadow for over ten years due to my sensitive eyes. When I got the 'Precious Metals' set, I was surprised by the size but once I tried them, I was very pleased! The colors are light, highly pigmented, and they don’t irritate my eyes at all."

"At 74, I've tried many eyeliners, but this one surprised me with its softness, blendability, and great color options. It's my favorite, though it can smudge a bit, which isn't a big issue for me."

"I was a fan of Wet N Wild in the 90s, and when I found this purple eyeshadow pencil, I had to try it. I expected low quality, but it glided on like silk, with rich pigmentation that outperformed pricier brands. I'm thrilled and plan to stock up!"

"Initially, I had low expectations and found it hard to apply, but after dabbing and blending, I discovered how to use it effectively. Now, I love it as both eyeshadow and eyeliner, and it lasts all day. I'm officially converted!"

“I absolutely love this product! The highly pigmented cream formula is a game-changer for me. One swipe gives me vibrant color that lasts all day and night. I've worn it through long workdays and even sweaty workouts, and it stays put without creasing.”

“I recently tried these cream eyeshadows and find them very easy to use. This particular color is so flattering on me. The price was reasonable, and my order arrived in great condition.”

“I like this cream eyeshadow because it has its own small application brush and is long-wearing. The application is smooth, and I appreciate the subtle shine it provides without being too sparkly.”

"I found these eyeshadow sticks to be incredibly easy to work with, and the colors are just amazing. Perfect for a quick look!"

"I took a chance on two colors, Cocktail Party and Honey BB, and I’m thrilled! They layer beautifully, and the application is so smooth. Lasted all day and washed off easily."

"I was skeptical about eyeshadow sticks, but this one is fantastic! It doesn't crease and lasts all day. I’ve even bought it in three shades now!"

"I was looking for a variety of eye shadows on a budget, and this product is perfect for me. The colors match exactly what was shown, and the quality is excellent. The texture is very smooth and soft on my eyelids. Just a heads up, it doesn't last all day, so I have to reapply throughout the day or night."

"As a senior with sensitive skin, I was a bit hesitant when I received these as a gift. However, I've tried five colors so far and they are lovely! The colors are soft and muted, the packaging is as advertised, and I’m very satisfied."

"I’m completely obsessed with these colors! They have a great softness and quality, and they last without smudging. They dry quickly, which is a huge plus for me."

"This eyeliner went on smoothly and stayed put! I struggle with eyeliner application, but this made it easy to create both thick and thin lines. It lasted for hours and came off easily with makeup remover. The color is perfect—a lovely brown, just right. The price is amazing, comparable to high-end brands!"

"I usually love Elf products, but this one is a bit tricky. While the color is beautiful and it applies perfectly, it becomes extremely dry and cracks by the afternoon, which doesn't look great. Plus, it doesn’t wash off easily with water."

"I really like this cream shadow. It applies smoothly and doesn’t smudge, plus it's the perfect neutral shade. No more mess from broken powders in my travel bag! I even use it with a fine brush as eyeliner for added versatility."

"I find this eyeshadow really pretty and sparkly. However, I've noticed it tends to fall off unless I use a primer. The pot is a bit shallow, so I didn't get a lot of shadow, but for the price, it's pretty good."

"I've had to use my fingers to apply this because it's cream-based. Typically, I can use a brush with cream shadows, but that didn't work well here. I like to use it for the corners of my eyes and under the brow—not sure how it performs in the crease area, but I do like it."

"This eyeshadow is perfect for a quick, daily look. I can apply it with either my fingers or a brush, depending on how intense I want the color. I usually wear it alone, but it also looks nice layered over a similar mulberry powder shadow. I've received a lot of compliments on it, and it was very affordable!"

"As someone in my 40s, I wanted an eyeshadow that doesn't crease, and this one delivers! The color is beautiful and it lasts a long time. I’ll definitely be purchasing again to try out other shades!"

"I was inspired by a YouTube tutorial, and I’m so glad I chose this eyeshadow. It’s become my go-to for when I’m short on time. The texture and shine are perfect, and it lasts all day without creasing or fading!"

"The Caramel shade is my favorite for a subtle look. I appreciate how little goes a long way, and it’s very easy to apply. I also like using it alone or layering with other shades for a more complex look."

"I now own several of these eyeshadows, including a couple of darker shades, a shimmery lilac, and a pale green. The shimmer colors have exceeded my expectations. The texture is creamy and soft without being sticky, and once they set, they become immovable. The pigmentation is incredible—the colors with red in the blend can stain the skin, but I find it worth it for the saturation. I highly recommend these, even for the most discerning makeup lovers."

"I have quite a few cream shadows, both high-end and budget-friendly. I consistently reach for my Oulac shadows because they apply smoothly and last all day. My favorite application method is using a flat brush for a single shadow look. They don't crease on me and work well with powder shadows too."

"I bought this eyeshadow for an 80's costume party, and it was creamy with a lot of glitter. While it wasn't as colorful as I expected, adding a similar pink powder shadow underneath made it pop. Overall, it met my needs."