Best Combination Eye Liners & Shadows of 2026

"I've tried countless eye pencils, but this one really stands out for its smooth, effortless application and creamy formula. It’s perfect for both quick morning looks and more dramatic styles. I love how it makes my eyes appear instantly brighter, and it stays put throughout the day. For the price, it’s a fantastic staple in my makeup routine."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, it's hard to find an eyeliner that glides on gently without causing irritation. This pencil does just that, and I only need one swipe for bold, visible color. It's become my go-to for comfort and easy use!"

"I’m a huge fan of multi-use eye pencils, and this one delivers as both a shadow and liner. The color selection is great, and they perform just as well as more expensive brands. For anyone seeking quality at a budget-friendly price, I highly recommend these!"

"I'm really impressed with how smoothly this eyeshadow applies and how well it stays put all day, even with my contact lenses. The compact design is perfect for travel, and I appreciate the cute packaging. It's easy to blend, doesn't irritate my eyes, and the price is definitely a bonus!"

"For someone with sensitive skin and an eye for non-toxic products, I find this palette to be a great affordable alternative to high-end brands. The shades last a long time, and although it's not EWG approved, the ingredients are mostly clean. I haven’t tried applying them wet, but I love the versatility it offers."

"I picked up the 'nude eyes' palette and was drawn to the beautiful shimmer shades. While the colors look lovely on my eyes, I did notice some glitter fallout, even when using primer. The mid-tone taupe and gunmetal grey shades really stand out, but I wish the lighter colors were more distinct once applied."

"I've tested countless eye pencils, even pricier ones, but this one stands out for its smooth application and versatility. I use it as both an eyeliner and eyeshadow, and the color selection is wonderful. For the price, it's unbeatable. Highly recommended!"

"Finding a pencil that works for sensitive eyes has been a challenge for me. This one applies flawlessly in a single swipe and never irritates my eyes. With my big eyes, it's usually hard to get eyeliner to show up, but this product delivers bold color easily. I'm truly grateful!"

"As someone with fair skin and a preference for shimmery whites, I appreciate how creamy and easy to apply this pencil is. It's great for a soft highlight or quick lid color, though I do wish the packaging was more user-friendly. Still, it's a budget-friendly option I reach for often."

"I've tried so many eye products, but this one truly stands out for its flawless application and impressive staying power. It doesn’t crease or smudge, even on my oily lids, and is comfortable for sensitive eyes. I love how the colors make my blue eyes pop. Absolutely worth repurchasing!"

"As someone with mature skin, I appreciate that this eye stick is effortless to apply and never tugs. The product glides on smoothly and has become my go-to for both eyeliner and eyeshadow."

"I typically avoid splurging on beauty products, but I’m glad I made an exception for this one. The liner and shadow both go on seamlessly and last all day, plus it’s the only product that doesn’t irritate my eyes. I’m definitely buying again and hope for more color options in the future!"

"I've tried a lot of eye products, but this one really stands out for its smooth, effortless application and vibrant color payoff. I especially appreciate that it stays put all day without creasing—finally, an eye stick that works for my oily eyelids! I’ll definitely repurchase."

"As someone with sensitive, watery eyes, I’ve struggled to find eye makeup that doesn’t irritate me. This product is a game-changer—no itchiness and the colors last most of the day. I do wish there were more shade options, but I’m so happy I found something that works for me."

"While I love how smoothly the liner glides on and how well the shadow complements it, I found the liner runs out too fast and breaks easily. The product is a bit pricey for how quickly the liner disappears, so I’m not sure I’ll buy it again."

"I've found this product incredibly easy to apply and it truly lasts all day. The application process is smooth, and I couldn't be happier with how it performs."

"I really appreciate that both ends sharpen easily, and the silver gray shade is perfect for covering my white eyebrow hairs in a natural way. It's been tough to find this color elsewhere, so I'll keep coming back for more as long as it's available!"

"The dual-ended design with black and dark gray shades is super versatile—I use either side as eyeliner or blend it out for a shadow look. I was honestly impressed by the quality, and the included sharpener works great. Plus, it's much more affordable and lasts longer than similar brands I've tried."

"I've tried a lot of high-end eye pencils, but this one truly stands out. It glides on effortlessly and rivals much pricier brands. I use it as both eyeliner and eyeshadow, and the colors are vibrant. The price is unbeatable, and it's become a staple in my routine. Highly recommend!"

"After searching forever for a good metallic eyeliner, I finally found this one and I'm hooked. The silver shade is stunning, super creamy, and easy to apply. Plus, it's extremely budget-friendly. I'm definitely a lifelong customer now."

"As someone with sensitive eyes and fair skin, I appreciate how creamy and gentle this pencil is. It adds just the right amount of shimmer and is great for quick makeup looks. However, I did notice a bit of irritation after a while, so it might not be perfect for everyone. Still, it's a wonderful option for everyday use."

"I absolutely love this product! I start with a brown liner, then apply the liner over it for a softer effect, and finish with the shadow on my lids. It’s easy to use and blends beautifully."

"This eye product has become a favorite for me. It glides on smoothly, unlike other liners I’ve tried that were hard or crumbly. The shadow is also silky and the color is gorgeous."

"While I hoped to be wowed, my experience was mixed. The eyeliner lasted all day and performed well, but the color pairing felt a bit off—the liner and shadow shades didn’t quite match for me, and the shadow needed a few layers to show up fully. I still appreciate the reliable eyeliner side."

"I absolutely love that this is reusable and doesn’t tug at my skin like tape does. It’s been great for creating clean, sharp lines with my eyeshadow and wings—much better than traditional methods!"

"I found this tool works well for fast, attractive eyeliner, and it really changed how I do my makeup. So helpful for getting a precise look!"

"I had some trouble with this product since it was hard to hold steady and use at the same time. It seems like it might take a bit of practice to get it right."