Best Matte Eyebrow Pencils of 2025

The Covergirl Brow Filler Pomade offers an ultra-precise beveled tip, allowing you to fill and shape your brows with ease. Its creamy, highly pigmented formula glides on smoothly, ensuring a non-drying soft matte finish that lasts throughout the day. You can blend and soften the color effortlessly with the included paddle-shaped kabuki brush. Plus, this brow pencil features a clean, vegan formula enriched with beneficial ingredients like vitamin E, hyaluronic acid, and squalane, giving your brows the care they deserve while you achieve a polished look.

The Smashbox Brow Tech Matte Pencil in Taupe is the perfect tool to achieve flawless eyebrows. This eyebrow color pencil from Smashbox is designed to give you a natural, matte finish. The Taupe shade is ideal for those with lighter hair colors. With its precise tip, this pencil allows for easy application and helps you create defined and well-shaped brows. The long-lasting formula ensures that your brows stay put all day long, without smudging or fading. The slim design of the pencil makes it convenient to carry in your makeup bag, so you can touch up your brows on the go. Enhance your brows with the Smashbox Brow Tech Matte Pencil for a polished and groomed look.

Eye Brightener Stick Highlighter is a multitasking eyebrow pencil that helps you shape and conceal your brows, highlight your best features, and brighten your waterline. It comes in a duo end pencil with a matte shade and a shimmery shade that is paraben-free, gluten-free, and cruelty-free. The matte shade defines, shapes, and conceals for a clean edge, and the shimmery shade adds a natural lift to your brow and highlights the inner corners of your eyes, making them pop!

The Boobeen Eyebrow Pencil offers three beautiful shades: light brown, dark brown, and taupe, allowing you to choose the perfect match for your hair color. Its unique flat brush design helps you create fine, hair-like strokes, making it easy to outline and define your brows. This versatile tool can also be used as an eyeliner or sleeper pencil, giving you the freedom to achieve a natural look effortlessly. With a waterproof and smudge-proof formula, this pencil ensures your makeup lasts all day, providing a soft, pigmented texture that blends seamlessly.

The Marcelle Nano Retractable Eyebrow Liner, also known as Marcelle Eyebrow Liner, is a must-have for achieving perfectly shaped brows. With its ultra-precise and extra-thin lead, you can easily create a flawless shape with maximum control. The medium coverage and matte finish of this pencil provide a natural look that lasts all day. The built-in brush tip allows you to effortlessly shape and groom your brows for a polished appearance. Plus, Marcelle is a cruelty-free brand, certified by PETA, so you can feel good about using their products. Say goodbye to unruly brows and hello to defined perfection with Marcelle Eyebrow Liner.

The GladGirl Highlighter Pencil is designed to enhance your eyes with ease. You can quickly brighten your brow bone with its translucent shimmer or natural matte finish, adding a beautiful glow. Apply it to your inner eyelids for a fresh, dewy appearance that combats tired-looking eyes. This highlighter pencil is durable enough for daily use, making it perfect for both professional makeup artists and anyone wanting to elevate their beauty routine. Plus, it’s made with vegan and cruelty-free ingredients, ensuring it’s safe for even the most sensitive skin.

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil in Camille/Sand is a dual-ended pencil that helps define eyebrow lines and highlight the brow bone. It features both shimmer and matte finishes and has a powder formula that is non-wax. This pencil is perfect for those who want to create a defined and highlighted brow look. Please note that all products sold by ‘Anastasia Beverly Hills Inc.' on Amazon are authentic and meet their high-ingredient and quality standards.

The Maybelline Fiber Pomade Crayon is designed to give you full, thick eyebrows effortlessly. Its fiber-infused formula adheres to your brow hairs, creating a natural look that enhances your features. You can achieve this desired effect with a simple, mess-free application. For the best results, use short, upward strokes to build thickness and create a more defined shape. With a matte finish, this crayon not only colors but also keeps your brows in place, making it a convenient choice for anyone seeking a polished appearance.

IENVY by KISS Eyebrow Sealer is a waterproof, smudge-free, and fast-drying eyebrow sealer that keeps your brows in place for hours without leaving them feeling waxy or smeared. It delivers a matte and flawless finish, perfect for natural-looking brows or a no make-up make-up look. It is easy to use, dries clear, and does not change the color of your eyebrow product. Made with mild agents and nourishing ingredients ideal for any hair and skin type, it is non-irritating and perfect for thinning eyebrows.

The Maybelline Brow Ultra Slim pencil is designed for achieving perfectly defined eyebrows with ease. Its ultra-slim 1.5mm tip allows you to create fine, hair-like strokes for a natural look. You can apply it effortlessly by drawing light lines along your brow shape. Plus, the built-in spoolie brush helps you blend and groom your brows for a polished finish. With nine shades available, you can find the perfect match for your hair color, ensuring your brows look flawless and defined all day long.