Best Organic Eyebrow Pencils of 2025
* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Organic eyebrow pencils are the latest trend in the cosmetics industry, and for good reason. Made with natural ingredients, these pencils are perfect for those who want to achieve a natural look while taking care of their skin. They are free from harmful chemicals and are gentle on the skin, making them ideal for people with sensitive skin. Organic eyebrow pencils come in a variety of shades to match different skin tones and hair colors, ensuring that everyone can find the perfect match. With their easy-to-use design, these pencils make it easy to shape and fill in your eyebrows, giving you a flawless and natural look.
At a Glance: Our Top Picks
#TOP 1
9.8
#TOP 2
9.7
#TOP 3
9.5
Top 5 Organic Eyebrow Pencils
True + Luscious Brow Definer Pencil
The True + Luscious Brow Definer offers a convenient way to achieve beautifully defined brows. With its long-lasting formula, you can enjoy a natural look that stays put throughout the day, resisting sweat and smudges. The innovative 2-in-1 design combines pomade and powder, making it easy to fill and shape your eyebrows with precision. Infused with organic Jamaican Castor Oil, this pencil not only enhances your brows but also conditions them, ensuring they look healthy and vibrant. Plus, with shades designed for all skin tones, finding your perfect match is effortless.
PREXY Organic Eyebrow Pencil, Medium Brown
The PREXY Eyebrow Pencil is your go-to solution for achieving beautifully defined brows. This all-in-one product includes a waterproof pencil and a blending brush, making it easy to fill in sparse areas and create natural-looking arches. With its versatile design, you can choose to draw fine or bold lines, allowing you to customize your eyebrow look to suit any occasion. Made from organic ingredients, this pencil not only ensures a smooth application but also offers long-lasting wear while being gentle on your skin. Enjoy perfect brows without compromising on quality!
INIKA Organic Brow Pencil Brunette
The INIKA Brow Pencil Brunette is designed to help you enhance your eyebrows effortlessly. Its soft and nourishing formula allows you to accentuate your natural brow shape, fill in any sparse areas, and add definition for a polished look. The pencil features plant-based ingredients like Coconut Oil and Vitamin E, ensuring smooth application while caring for your skin. With long-lasting, water-resistant color, you can trust that your brows will stay in place all day without fading. Enjoy the convenience of a product that glides on easily and helps you achieve a beautiful brow look.
Mom's Secret Natural Eyebrow Powder
Mom's Secret Natural Eyebrow Powder is a 100% organic, vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and made-in-the-USA eyebrow powder, which contains certified organic and all-natural ingredients without artificial colors, preservatives, or fragrances. The long-lasting formula offers a soft natural appearance to keep your eyebrows looking great all day.
DIRRAN ORGANIC Deep Taupe Brow Pencil
The DIRRAN Brow Pencil is crafted from 100% organic and natural ingredients, ensuring a safe option for your sensitive skin. You can apply this pencil confidently, knowing it is free from parabens, fragrances, and harmful chemicals. Available in three shades, it allows you to shape your eyebrows to match your skin tone, enhancing your overall look. The inclusion of organic oils and vitamin E ensures a smooth application, making it easy for you to achieve that perfect definition. With a built-in brush, you can effortlessly fill and shape your brows for a natural appearance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the safest eyebrow pencil?
Burt's Bees Eyebrow Pencil This includes the softening jojoba oil, a much-beloved silky ingredient that is safe for almost all skin types—including oily or sensitive.
2. What is the most natural looking eyebrow pencil?
Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyebrow Pencil “They're so easy to work with. The product goes on smoothly, giving you a very natural look that's not overdrawn.”
3. Are eyebrow pencils toxic?
Eyebrow pencils can contain parabens, PEGs, and the other common toxins found in skincare. But they also have their own unique toxins to look out for. These include: Carbon black: linked to cancer and organ system toxicity.
4. What is the best eyebrow pencil to use when you have no eyebrows?
If you have sparse eyebrows, the brow wiz is one of the best eyebrow pencils on the market. One of the main reasons for that is its amazingly thin nib. A thin nib allows for much more realistic hair strokes than a thicker nib.
During our organic eyebrow pencil research, we found 48 organic eyebrow pencil products and shortlisted 5 quality products. We collected and analyzed 9,029 customer reviews through our big data system to write the organic eyebrow pencils list. We found that most customers choose organic eyebrow pencils with an average price of $13.57.
The organic eyebrow pencils are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of organic eyebrow pencils, including True + Luscious, PREXY, INIKA, Mom's Secret, DIRRAN ORGANIC. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 12 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.
Lisa Bechard is a skin therapist with 12 years of working experience in the beauty industry and also an experienced beauty writer who has expertise in skincare, medical aesthetics and cosmetic surgery, and wellness. Her writing skills are excellent and all her content is very persuasive and insightful.