Best Washable Mascara of 2025

"I don't typically write reviews, but this mascara truly deserves recognition. I'm very selective about mascara and have tried countless brands, both high-end and budget-friendly. This one is my absolute favorite! The thin and flexible wand allows for even application without clumping, separating my lashes beautifully and making them look long. I highly recommend giving it a try!"

"I've always preferred high-end mascaras like Better Than Sex or Dior, but this one has impressed me so much that I ordered one for my best friend too, and she loves it as well! It keeps my lashes curled and long without flaking or the need for reapplication throughout the day. It's amazing and affordable — a must-try for mascara lovers!"

"I've had a complicated relationship with mascara due to my light blonde lashes. I've tried various brands over the years, and after discovering this one, I was pleasantly surprised. The True Brown color is beautiful, and it doesn't smudge even in humidity. The application is smooth, and it removes easily. I'll definitely be ordering this again!"

"I find that this mascara makes my eyelashes look super long and not clumpy. It goes on easily, doesn't smudge, and wipes off well. I also love its rectangle shape for travel convenience!"

"After trying countless mascaras, I can confidently say that the pink and green bottle is the best I've used!"

"I've been a fan of Maybelline products for as long as I can remember. They never disappoint!"

"This has been my favorite mascara since my teenage years, and I still really like it!"

“I've been using this mascara for years, and it's truly my favorite. Both my daughter and I love it!”

“I am completely in love with this mascara! It transforms my lashes, making them look long and fanned out without clumping. The formula holds the lift all day without smudging. I've tried many mascaras, but this one is a true gem!”

“This mascara lengthens and thickens my lashes so well that people often ask if I'm wearing falsies. As it dries out a bit, it becomes easier to apply and layer.”

"I'm pretty picky about mascara, but this one is PERFECT for me. It lengthens, holds a curl, and doesn't clump. I've repurchased it three times!"

"I decided to try this mascara after seeing it on social media, and I'm really impressed! It adds great volume without clumping, and the formula lasts all day."

"Most mascaras I've tried clump or smudge, but this one goes on smoothly and creates long, full lashes. It's a game changer and very affordable!"

“I have very oily skin, and most mascaras smudge under my eyes, leaving me looking like a panda. This mascara doesn't smudge at all! It transforms my thin, straight lashes into long, thick lashes when I curl them first. I'm so impressed!”

“I’ve used Maybelline Total Temptation my whole life, but I was blown away when I tried this mascara! I didn’t even know my lashes could look this long. It gives my lashes a natural, soft look without clumps. Definitely worth buying!”

“After 30 years of using Lancome Definicils, I decided to try something cheaper. This L’Oreal mascara is fantastic! My lashes look natural and defined, even without curling them first. I just wish I had discovered it sooner!”

"I discovered that water-proof mascara leads to dark circles over time, so I prefer this washable mascara. It gives me a full lift and is easy to remove at night."

"After my favorite Ulta mascara was discontinued, I tried this one based on reviews. It’s the best mascara I've ever used! It separates and lengthens my lashes beautifully, and I don’t need oil to remove it at the end of the day. I hope it’s around for a long time!"

"My eyelashes are short and fine, but this mascara does exactly what it promises. My lashes appear full and remain soft, without that heavy feeling. It's also easy to remove, so I definitely recommend it."

"I've always loved Maybelline products, and this latest mascara refill is consistent with the quality I expect. It applies easily, and because it's not waterproof, it washes off with just soap and water. My lashes look longer and more natural without clumping. However, I'm a bit disappointed that the brush color isn't as shown in the listing; it's a solid dark hue instead. While it doesn't impact performance, I wish it matched the description."

"For 40 years, I've been using this brand. It never clumps and doesn't break my eyelashes. Plus, it's very affordable with great coverage!"

"This mascara is my favorite after trying many others. It stays on all day without clumping and makes my lashes look fantastic. The only downside is that it can be a bit tricky to remove; I often need to go over each eye twice to ensure everything is off."

“I've been using this mascara for 25 years, and it's the best I've found. It washes off easily, doesn't flake, and is buildable. However, I feel a bit gypped since the amount per bottle has decreased over time.”

“This mascara is a godsend for my short, sparse lashes. It makes them look long, dark, and beautiful. I highly recommend it, especially for the reasonable price!”

“I love how after a couple of strokes, my lashes are fully covered. There's no need to worry about false lashes coming off, which is a relief, especially for women like me!”

"I'm really particular about my mascara. I want something that gives my lashes both bold volume and length. After reading reviews, I decided to try this one, and I'm so glad I did. It's probably the best drugstore mascara I've used in years. My lashes looked amazing, and it lasted all day without flaking or smudging."

"I'm not a big makeup person, but I do know a good mascara when I see one! I ordered this after a Jeffree Star recommendation, and I absolutely love it! It lasts all day, doesn't clump, and is very affordable!"

"This mascara has been a game-changer for my thin lashes. It captures every lash beautifully. I'm definitely going to keep purchasing this from now on!"

"I've been using this mascara for years and absolutely love how smoothly it goes on. I tried lash extensions but found them unreliable. This mascara, along with Latisse, gives me a beautiful effect. Plus, the next day delivery was a game changer since stores often run out of this shade!"

"As a long-time user of Maybelline mascara, I think this duo pack is an incredible deal! I’ll definitely order it again."

"Why spend a fortune on designer mascara when this one works just as well, if not better?"