Best Navy Mascara of 2025

"I don't look good in black anymore. My very fair coloring doesn't suit brown either, so I was thrilled to find this charcoal grey. It’s a perfect dark grey-ish blue that looks subtle and stays on all day without clumping. It’s my new favorite mascara!"

"As someone with sensitive skin and eyes, finding non-irritating products is essential for me. I was delighted to discover this mascara in brown, which is a blend of brown and black—much better than the harsh black I usually find. After pairing it with talc-free eyeshadow, I had no irritation at all, even after a long day!"

"At nearly 78 years old, I’ve tried so many mascaras over the years, but this one is absolutely the best! It goes on smoothly without clumping, and I love the navy color—it’s softer than black for my age. I’m so pleased that I’ll never buy anything else!"

“I absolutely love the color; it’s the blue I was searching for, and it feels light on my lashes!”

“I had concerns before buying, but the Royal Blue is even better than I expected! It's easy to use and lasts all day for me.”

“While I enjoy the color, the wand broke after a few uses, so I’ve switched to disposable wands to keep using it.”

"I've tried many natural mascaras, and this one is definitely my favorite! It's not waterproof, which I don't mind, and it's easy to wash off without hurting my eyes."

"I was really excited to try this mascara, but the wand felt dry and ineffective. I could hardly notice a difference in my lashes, so I won't be purchasing it again."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, I was pleased to find this mascara. It gives my lashes a great lift and doesn't irritate my eyes at all. Plus, I even noticed a pleasant honey scent!"

"I purchased this mascara, but unfortunately, it was dried up when I received it. I reached out to Earth Antidotes, and while they assured me it was stored in a climate-controlled area, I'm still waiting for the replacement they promised."

"The color isn't exactly what I was hoping for; I expected something more electric blue. It's okay, but not quite what I wanted."

"I've had a bad experience with this mascara as it didn't deposit anything on my lashes. It felt dried out, unfortunately."

"I absolutely love makeup and can't stick to just black and brown mascara; I need variety!"

"I'm a fan of the navy color; it’s a bit clumpy but still manageable for me, and I really appreciate that it’s odorless."

"Unfortunately, I found this to be one of the worst mascaras I've ever tried. It doesn't really extend or thicken my lashes. While the navy color is nice, it seems to only add color without any benefit. I guess it might work if I put my regular mascara on first, but that seems unnecessary!"

"I really love how this makes my eyelashes look full! I have sensitive skin, but this mascara hasn’t caused any reactions for me."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, I was thrilled to find this mascara. I've tried many brands, but they all made my eyes water. This one lets me wear it for about 8 hours without irritation. Yes, it does flake off a bit, but I'm just happy to wear mascara again!"

"I rarely write reviews, but this product deserves one. Over the years, I developed a sensitivity to mascaras, leading to discomfort. This mascara not only stayed put, but I even slept in it and woke up looking great. I'm buying a spare because it’s a keeper for me!"

"Since my mid-20s, finding a mascara that didn’t irritate my eyes seemed impossible. I used to rely on Maybelline, but it caused severe reactions. After trying this mascara, I was pleasantly surprised. It worked well for me, even though it doesn't hold a curl like my old favorite. For sensitive eyes, I’d say give it a shot!"

"I've been searching for a navy mascara forever, but this one is electric blue, not navy! The brush isn't ideal, but it does the job without smudging or running."

"As an older woman with sensitive eyes, I've found that Marcelle products are just as effective as expensive brands. This mascara doesn't bleed or clump, but I wish the brush was a bit thinner."

"I really enjoy this mascara! It adds volume to my lashes and is gentle on my eyes. I'll definitely buy it again."

"I really appreciate how well this mascara applies without clumping and makes my lashes look longer and thicker. The navy blue shade is hard to find, but it looks fantastic with my brown eyes. It stays put, and I've had no issues with smudging, which is a huge plus for me."

"As someone with super sensitive eyes, I’m thrilled to find a blue mascara that works for me. It goes on easily, and the flexible brush makes application a breeze. I love how it enhances my lashes without bothering my eyes."

"The formula of this mascara is excellent! It makes my lashes long and voluminous, and the color is just right—not too bright nor too dull. However, I did notice that the wand feels a bit flimsy, but that doesn’t stop me from wanting to purchase it again."

"I've been using this mascara for years and absolutely love it! It stays on beautifully and comes off in tubules with just water. For ease of use, this is the best mascara available."

"At first, I thought this color wouldn’t be noticeable, but after applying a few layers, everyone noticed my lashes! It’s such a fun change from black, and it washes off easily—a definite must-try!"

"My daughter enjoys using this mascara but prefers it over her regular black mascara for a touch of color. She finds it perfect for adding depth, especially in the right light."

"I found it to be not waterproof, and it even failed to resist water. My cheeks turned blue within minutes as my eyes teared up from the cold. The product lasted about three minutes for me."

"I used it for the first time and was disappointed that it was not water resistant. My experience was short-lived, with my cheeks turning blue almost immediately due to the cold."