Best Navy Mascara of 2026

"As someone with very sensitive skin and eyes, I’m always on the hunt for makeup that won’t cause irritation. I was pleased to find this mascara in a brown/black shade, which is much more flattering for my pale complexion than standard black. After some trial and error with talc-free eye shadow alongside this mascara, I experienced no itching or discomfort all day. I’m hopeful this will be my new go-to for special occasions."

"I was looking for a navy mascara to add a little interest without being too bold. This one applies easily, doesn’t flake or smudge, and comes off effortlessly with remover. I use it all the time and am really happy with the result."

"I have dry eye syndrome, so most mascaras are off-limits for me. This one is a game-changer: no flaking or crumbling, which means no irritation. I’ve already repurchased, and when it starts to dry out, a tiny drop of toner keeps it going strong."

"I was looking for a real navy blue mascara, and that's exactly what I got—it’s a rich, deep blue that’s hard to find elsewhere. Love the color!"

"If you’re after a genuine navy shade, this delivers, but the formula is very dry and the container is pretty small. It takes a lot of effort to get decent coverage, and even then, the results are underwhelming."

"This blue mascara is a refreshing switch from the usual browns and blacks. It’s a great color and really stands out in my collection."

"I've used this eyeliner for years and it remains my go-to choice. I appreciate how smoothly it applies and the built-in smudger helps me achieve both subtle and dramatic looks. It's dependable, budget-friendly, and I always come back to it."

"For me, this product is a great value that delivers smooth, easy application. Even as a senior, I find it long-lasting and the color is vibrant. I highly recommend it, especially considering the reasonable price."

"I picked this up as an affordable alternative to more expensive brands and was pleased with how user-friendly it is—easy to apply even in a rush. However, I've noticed some smearing by the end of the day, but overall, it's a good buy for the price."

"I've bought this mascara several times and absolutely love the bold blue shade. It makes my lashes stand out, and the fact that it's paraben-free and cruelty-free is a huge plus for me. I wear it almost every day and it lasts all day without smudging."

"The color is gorgeous and reminds me of what I used to wear in the 70s. It goes on light and comfortable, giving my lashes a subtle pop. I like to add a glitter top coat for extra effect and it really makes my eyes stand out."

"I really enjoy the blue color of this mascara, but I did notice the wand broke after a few uses. I used a disposable wand to keep using the product, but it was a bit inconvenient."

"The most important thing for me in a mascara is that it goes on smoothly with no clumps and really makes my lashes appear longer and fuller. This one does just that—actually, it performs as well or better than pricier options I've tried. I especially appreciate the navy blue shade, which is hard to find and looks great with my brown eyes. It stays put all day, even with some moisture, and removes easily with soap and water. The price is also fantastic compared to most drugstore brands."

"I absolutely love the navy color of this mascara! It's difficult to find navy shades in stores, but this one is just right. The formula holds up perfectly throughout the day and then washes off with ease when I want it to. It's subtle but really brings out my green eyes."

"The formula is excellent—it gives my lashes both length and volume. The color is beautiful: not too bold, not too faded. The only slight drawback is the wand feels a bit flimsy, but that's not enough to stop me from buying it again."

"I've tried a lot of mascaras claiming to be tubing, but this one actually delivers. It comes off effortlessly with warm water, doesn’t flake, and feels light all day. I was able to apply multiple coats and separate any clumps before it dried. For the price, it’s hard to beat—highly recommended!"

"I have medical issues that make my lashes thin and fall out, but this is the first mascara to actually give me visible lashes. It removes easily with just water at the end of the day. The quality is impressive."

"This mascara really makes my lashes look longer and thicker without smudging or flaking. For the price, it’s a great deal, and I even prefer it over some high-end brands like Bad Girl Bang."

"I've finally found a natural mascara that doesn't irritate my eyes. After trying others, this one gives my lashes fullness with just one layer and washes off easily with regular cleanser. No clumping or itchiness, and I've been happily using it for months. I highly recommend it!"

"I'm always on the lookout for products rated highly for health, and this mascara scored 100/100 on my Yuka app. It's one of the safest options out there, and while it doesn't curl as much as some others and can smudge a bit on oily skin, knowing it's chemical-free makes me feel great about using it."

"Finding a blue mascara is nearly impossible, so I was thrilled to see this shade. The color is amazing, but I did notice it dried out pretty fast."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, I've found this mascara to be a great fit—it doesn’t irritate, doesn't clump, and the blue shade is lovely for a softer look. Definitely planning to repurchase!"

"I finally found a mascara that complements my blonde hair and blue eyes. The navy color makes my eyes pop and lasts all day. I keep coming back to this product—it’s that good!"

"I was looking for a navy mascara, but this turned out to be more electric blue. While it doesn't smear or run, the brush isn't ideal. Overall, it’s okay, but not exactly what I was hoping for."