Best Natural Extracts of 2026

"I've made Watkins Vanilla a staple in my kitchen because of its wonderfully rich flavor and consistent quality. It's my top choice for baking, and the pure ingredients give my cookies and cakes a real boost."

"This almond extract makes my desserts taste amazing. I appreciate the clear color and the fair price—it’s exactly what I needed to elevate my recipes."

"I’ve tried a few butter flavorings since Wilton stopped making theirs, and this one smells fantastic and tastes great in my buttercream. For the price, you get a generous amount and excellent quality."

"This vanilla extract is now my go-to because it's budget-friendly and delivers an authentic vanilla flavor. I'm impressed by the quality for the price and would definitely recommend it to others who want a good, simple baking staple."

"I've used up a whole bottle and found it to be a solid pantry staple with a flavor that works well in everything I bake. Plus, it's the most reasonably priced option I've come across."

"While this extract is far better than imitation vanilla and perfect for cookies and brownies, I still prefer McCormick for recipes where vanilla is the star. But for the price, it's a great choice for most baked goods."

"I've tried many vanillas, but this one stands out as the best-tasting and most affordable I've ever used. Even though it's not 100% pure, it actually tastes better than real vanilla to me. Absolutely in love with it!"

"I'm thrilled with this twin pack! The deep, rich Mexican vanilla flavor really elevates everything I bake. The value is unbeatable—over 33 ounces means I never worry about running out during the busy baking season. I use it in cookies, cakes, coffee, and more. Highly recommend for anyone who bakes a lot."

"The scent and flavor are phenomenal! I use it for baking, and a little in my scent pots fills my home with a warm, sweet vanilla aroma. The generous 2-pack is perfect. If you love real vanilla, you need to try this."

"I've always trusted Simply Organic, and discovering their vanilla bean paste was such a treat. The flavor is deep and authentic, and the jar size is just right for how potent it is. It works beautifully in everything from tea to baked goods, and I love that I can control the vanilla strength. If you want true vanilla taste, this is it!"

"I tried this paste for the first time when making banana pudding and whipped cream for a potluck, and it was a hit! The aroma is amazing and the taste really stands out. Even though the jar is small, there’s actually plenty inside, and a little goes a long way. I do wish the packaging was more secure, but overall it was a great buy."

"This vanilla paste has become a staple in my kitchen. I use it in overnight oats, coffee, and even savory dishes like marinades and meatballs. It blends perfectly with other spices and a small amount is enough. The quality and versatility far surpass regular liquid extracts."

"I've tried a lot of sweeteners, but this pure monk fruit powder stands out for its clean taste and lack of additives. I appreciate that there's no erythritol or maltodextrin, and using just a tiny amount sweetens my drinks perfectly. For me, there's no aftertaste at all and it doesn't spike my blood sugar. If you want a genuinely healthy substitute, this is a great pick."

"Switching from stevia to this pure monk fruit was a game changer. I love that there are no fillers or added sugar alcohols—just what I was looking for. A little goes a long way, so even though the bag is small, it lasts for ages. The sweetness is spot on, and I had no weird aftertaste. Yes, it's a bit pricey, but the quality makes it totally worth it."

"I wanted to like this since it’s pure monk fruit, but for me, the taste was just too intense and reminded me of stevia, which I can't tolerate. Even a tiny scoop was overly sweet. It's disappointing since so many people love it, but it didn't work for my taste buds."

"I've tried many vanilla extracts, but McCormick always stands out for its consistent flavor, affordability, and reliable quality. The scent is rich and complex, and the plastic bottle is convenient and durable. No matter what I try, I keep coming back to this brand—it just works every time."

"Whenever I bake, I reach for McCormick because it's a trusted brand with a strong, genuine vanilla aroma that immediately elevates my recipes. Just a teaspoon adds warmth and depth, and I love that it’s potent enough to last a long time. It’s pricier than the imitation stuff, but the quality difference is obvious."

"If you want a good deal on vanilla, this is easily the best price per ounce for real extract. The flavor holds up for everyday baking, and the large bottle is handy around the holidays. While I found an organic brand with a slightly richer taste, McCormick remains my go-to for reliable, budget-friendly vanilla."

"I’m thrilled with this extract! It delivers an authentic, rich ube flavor and a gorgeous purple hue that makes my desserts truly stand out. Even a small amount is enough for great color and taste. It blends into everything from cakes to flans without clumping or separation. I haven’t found anything with such a smooth, natural taste—definitely a kitchen staple for anyone who loves ube!"

"I use this in my coffee and lattes all the time. The flavor is strong, so just a drop or two is plenty. The color is beautiful and really perks up my drinks. I do wish the bottle came with a dropper, since it can get a bit messy and stain things if you’re not careful."

"This extract is exactly what I needed for my purple yam cakes. It’s hard to find in stores, so I was happy to get it delivered quickly. The taste is fantastic and my family loved the desserts I made with it. Great value, since a little goes a long way!"

"As a tea lover trying to avoid sugar and sugar alcohols, I found this monk fruit extract to be a game changer. A few drops made my tea sweet and enjoyable without any odd aftertaste or digestive discomfort. It took a couple of tries to get the sweetness just right, but now I can genuinely enjoy my tea again—just like I did with real sugar."

"I was searching for a pure, healthier sweetener without chemical additives or blends and discovered this monk fruit extract. It has a clean ingredient list and adds just the right amount of sweetness to my herbal teas, with no bitterness. I appreciate knowing exactly what's in it."

"I love that this sweetener is easy to carry for use in coffee or tea when dining out, and it tastes great—just like real sugar but without the chemicals. It's also versatile enough that I use the powdered form for baking. Definitely a better choice than artificial sweeteners!"

"I was skeptical about trying the Amazon brand because I usually stick with name brands or trusted small companies, but I was pleasantly surprised. This almond extract rivals the major brands in both taste and quality, and it’s a great value. I especially love how it enhances my almond cookies. Highly recommend for desserts and pastries."

"This almond extract is a staple in my baking routine. The flavor is rich and natural, and just a little goes a long way. It blends smoothly into cakes, cookies, and even homemade marzipan. The price and quality can’t be beat—I’ll definitely buy again."

"When I swapped out vanilla for this almond extract in my cranberry glazed bundt coffee cake, everyone raved about the new flavor. The almond aroma is outstanding, and it delivers just the right taste in both the cake and the glaze. I highly recommend it for anyone looking to elevate their baked goods."

"I've tried many brands, but this is the only vanilla I want to use now. The flavor is outstanding and it comes in a beautiful glass bottle. I especially love how it elevates my hot chocolate and desserts—it's on another level!"

"As a frequent baker, I can say this vanilla truly makes a difference in every recipe. The rich, deep flavor and aroma really come through, and it’s far superior to any supermarket options. You really do get what you pay for!"

"My wife uses this vanilla in all her baking, and it’s amazing how the flavor stands out, especially in her rice crispy treats. It’s strong but never too much, and a little goes a long way. The quality is consistent, and even though it’s a bit pricey, it lasts a long time."