Best Pie & Pastry Fillings of 2026

"I really appreciate the high quality and thick texture of this pumpkin. It's so much better than the watery store brands, and the price is great when you buy by the case. The taste and color are excellent too."

"This is my go-to for making easy pumpkin chocolate chip cookies. The flavor works perfectly with spice cake mix. Just a heads-up, the company is based in China, not the USA."

"Whenever my dog isn't feeling well, I rely on this pumpkin. He loves it, and it helps his digestion. It's become a staple in our house, especially since it's the most affordable option I've found for stocking up."

"I've been using this pumpkin pie spice in everything from pumpkin smoothies to coffee, and I'm really impressed by the delicious flavor. The price is unbeatable, and I can't wait to add it to pumpkin pies and cheesecake this fall!"

"I use pumpkin pie spice all year, and this Amazon version stands out—it contains extra spices not found in most brands, with no fillers or anti-caking agents. The container was safety sealed, which I appreciate."

"This spice mix is incredibly fresh and flavorful. I used it for a pumpkin spice Bundt cake, and it was the best I've ever made. I'll definitely be buying it again!"

"I was thrilled to find this specific flavor online since local stores don’t carry it. It’s essential for my recipes and the taste is fantastic."

"This is my go-to for making lemon pies. The cook & serve lemon is perfect, easy to use, and delivers great results every time!"

"I depend on this product for my special desserts. It’s not easy to find in stores, but Amazon always has it, and the quality is always great."

"This lemon curd is absolutely delicious—the balance of sweetness and tartness makes it a fantastic addition to my homemade sourdough with blueberries. The silky, lemon meringue pie-like texture is impressive, and it's so adaptable—I love it on toast and bagels. At work, it was a huge hit, and I think the price is very fair for something imported from Italy."

"One of the best lemon curds I've enjoyed! It's got a great sweet-tart balance and the flavor really stands out."

"The lemon curd worked out beautifully in my trifle. The lemon flavor is on the stronger side, so I used smaller amounts to get the right blend."

"I'm always looking for a delicious snack option and this really delivers. I especially love using it in my Ninja Creami for added texture—it makes a huge difference!"

"I have a hard time with products that have a fake sugar aftertaste, but that's not an issue here. Honestly, I now prefer this over regular cheesecake flavor, which is surprising to me. Mixing it with extra creamy Cool Whip and fruit is absolutely amazing, and the best part is it's only about 150 calories per tube!"

"This has been a game changer for my health and fitness journey. I mix it into my oatmeal, overnight oats, Greek yogurt, and smoothies. It tastes just like cheesecake, and you really can't tell it's zero sugar."

"I bought this huge can of pumpkin for my elderly aunt as a thoughtful gift. It was definitely a large size—my cousin was surprised by how much pumpkin it contained! We made two pies and still had plenty left to freeze. The taste was fresh and I think it’s a perfect choice for big gatherings at nursing homes or churches. Definitely worth picking up if you want a lot of pumpkin for a good price."

"I picked this up after my vet suggested pumpkin for my Jack Russell puppies. The problem with their digestion cleared up quickly, and it’s so affordable for the amount you get. It’s become a daily staple for my dogs. As a bonus, I could use it for pies if I wanted. Highly recommend for pet owners!"

"I’ve ordered this three times—the pumpkin itself is great, but I did have some issues with dented cans. Some arrived badly damaged, which made me worry about safety, but when the cans came in good shape, the product was perfect. Lately, my shipments have been arriving just fine, so it seems things have improved. Overall, I’m happy with the quality and value."

"I just poured this lemon filling straight into a graham cracker crust, chilled it, and topped it with whipped cream—absolutely perfect and delicious. The flavor is really lemony and the convenience can't be beat."

"Finding lemon pie filling locally is almost impossible, so I bought two cans online despite the high price. The taste is sweet, tangy, and very fresh. One can arrived dented but was still usable."

"I wouldn’t usually pay this much for lemon pie filling, but my granddaughter wanted to make a lemon dump cake and it’s impossible to find in stores around here. It’s a one-time purchase unless I find it locally for less."

"I love how juicy and perfectly sweet this apple pie filling is. It’s so good, I even put it in my morning oatmeal, pair it with ham for lunch, and sometimes just eat it straight from the can by dinner. Highly recommend for pies and more—it definitely beats the other brands I’ve tried."

"As someone who makes apple croissants at home, I appreciate how chunky and not too sweet this filling is. Great value and super convenient—no need to doctor it up at all."

"I was looking for a pie filling without high fructose corn syrup for a simple cake recipe and this one tasted great. It’s so easy to use and perfect for quick desserts."

"I use this product whenever I bake poppyseed rolls or kolaches—the taste and texture are just right for traditional recipes."

"Having grown up in Chicago, Solo's poppyseed filling brings back memories of family gatherings and homemade cookies. It's the same reliable flavor I remember from childhood, and my friends always ask for the recipe when I make poppyseed cookies."

"It's not easy to find in stores where I live, but being able to buy this product in quantity online is a huge plus for me."