Best Refill Eyeshadow of 2026

Honeybee Gardens Eyeshadow Single REFILL is a highly pigmented pressed eye shadow made of natural and clean ingredients. With its lasting colors, you can create a naturally subtle look or go for something more daring. Say goodbye to eyeshadow creasing, as this special formula ensures your colors stay put all day long. Feel confident in knowing that this eyeshadow is free of harmful ingredients such as petroleum-based oils, alcohol, talc, fillers, fragrances, preservatives, and chemical dyes. The eco-friendly packaging adds to the appeal, making it perfect for those looking to create a zero waste environment.

Honeybee Gardens Eyeshadow Refill is a highly pigmented pressed eye shadow made of natural and clean ingredients. With colors that offer endless possibilities, you can achieve a naturally subtle look or something more daring. The crease-proof formula ensures that your eyeshadow stays put throughout the day, giving you a fresh makeup look. Feel confident in knowing that you're using only natural and safe ingredients on your eyes, as this eyeshadow is free of harmful substances. The eco-friendly packaging adds to the appeal, making it perfect for creating a zero waste environment.

Trish McEvoy Glaze Eye Shadow Refill comes in a gorgeous light brown shimmer color, with a silky, pigment-rich, long-wearing texture. The eye shadow is available in both classic matte and sophisticated shimmer of Glaze. All Trish McEvoy products are created to help you always look your best, crafted with special ingredients that are all 100% Gluten-free and are not tested on animals. You can apply any shade all over for a sheer wash of color or use lighter shades to highlight the ball and inner corner of the eye or underneath the brow.

This eyeshadow refill features a silky, pigment-rich formula that offers a luminous shimmer finish. It is a great addition to your makeup collection for a flawless and radiant eye look.

The YiGuMy Magnetic Eyeshadow offers a travel-friendly and durable design with its magnetic iron pan system, allowing you to easily swap and customize shades for any look, from smokey eyes to shimmering highlights. Its hypoallergenic, paraben-free formula is gentle on sensitive skin and features a smooth cream-to-powder texture that minimizes fallout. You can pair it with a primer to keep colors vibrant and glitter in place. This palette also delivers professional shimmer and smokey effects, letting you add metallic accents or blend matte shades for depth. Compact and TSA-compliant, it’s perfect for touch-ups on the go.

MAC Eye Shadow-Brule (S) Refill Pan is a highly pigmented powder eye shadow that comes in a 1.5g/0.05oz size. It can be easily transported in the pro palette eye shadow/concealer (insert). The saturated shadow formula is non-creasing and has eight-hour wear time. It is safe for contact-lens wearers and can be used wet or dry.

The Fillwie Matte Eyeshadow offers a soft, warm ivory shade that adds a natural, elegant touch to your eye makeup. Its smooth, silky texture helps you apply and blend the color easily, ensuring a flawless finish that lasts throughout the day. Designed with moisturizing ingredients, this eyeshadow glides on comfortably, making it suitable for all skin types and ages. Plus, the magnetic iron pan lets you customize your palette by mixing shades you actually use, making it perfect for travel and daily convenience. This product is an excellent choice if you want a simple, buildable base eyeshadow with a matte look.

Honeybee Gardens Pressed Powder Eye Shadow Single REFILL is an all-natural, high-performing pressed eyeshadow that applies evenly, blends well, and is crease-proof. It is highly pigmented and has zero fall off. The Ballet shade is a matte soft lavender pink and is featured in the Nude Renaissance Refillable Eye Shadow Palette. This eyeshadow is certified gluten-free, vegan, cruelty-free, and non-GMO. It is free of petroleum-based oils, alcohol, talc, fillers, fragrances, parabens, preservatives, and chemical dyes, and is enriched with botanicals and vitamins.

The Honeybee Gardens 'Skinny Dip' REFILL pack includes 4 highly pigmented, certified vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free single pressed eyeshadows, with a total MSRP of $39.96. This pack does not contain a refillable compact or applicators, and the shadows are featured in the top-selling Skinny Dip Refillable Eye Shadow Palette, sold separately. These long-wearing and clean eyeshadows are perfect for those who want to refill their existing palette or create their own custom palette.

The MAC Powder Kiss Palette offers a smooth, matte finish that helps you achieve a flawless eye look with ease. Its lightweight, soft powder glides on effortlessly, making application simple and comfortable for everyday wear. With a variety of vibrant shades, you can create multiple eye shadow styles, from subtle to bold, perfect for any occasion. Plus, its long-lasting, smudge-resistant formula ensures your eye makeup stays fresh throughout the day, so you don’t have to worry about frequent touch-ups. This palette is a great choice if you want reliable, beautiful eye color that lasts.