Best Refill Makeup Palettes of 2025

Lisa Bechard Avatar
Lisa Bechard
Last Updated: Jan 10, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Refill makeup palettes are a must-have for any beauty enthusiast who wants to be eco-friendly and save money. These palettes allow you to customize your makeup collection by choosing your favorite shades and putting them all in one convenient palette. Not only are they practical, but they also help reduce waste by allowing you to only purchase the refills instead of the entire product. Refill makeup palettes come in a variety of sizes and shapes, making them perfect for travel or everyday use. With endless possibilities, refill makeup palettes are a great addition to any makeup collection.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - Skin Tones - Capillary Cover #TOP 1
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - Skin Tones - Capillary
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill - Mauve Cover #TOP 2
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill - Mauve
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Narrative Cosmetics 12 Color Palette Cover #TOP 3
Narrative Cosmetics 12 Color Palette
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 7 Refill Makeup Palettes

#TOP 1

Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - Skin Tones - Capillary

ALC-PAL-REFILL-CAPILLARY-CA
Capillary
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - Skin Tones - Capillary Cover
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - Skin Tones - Capillary

The Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans are perfect for customizing your alcohol palettes or restocking a specific color. These highly pigmented refill pans are water, sweat, and transfer-proof, ensuring long-lasting wear. The quick-drying formula allows for instant application, saving you time and preventing smudging. To activate the colors, simply add a few drops of 99% isopropyl rubbing alcohol into the palette cell. You can achieve more opaque application by letting the alcohol soak into the color for a few seconds. The refill pans can be applied with a brush or sponge, giving you flexibility in your makeup routine. When it's time to remove the colors, use isopropyl rubbing alcohol or isopropyl myristate for sensitive skin. The Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans are cruelty-free and vegetarian, making them a great choice for conscious consumers. With these refill pans, you can easily create customized looks and replenish your favorite colors effortlessly.

What We Like
Highly pigmented
Water, sweat, and transfer-proof
Quick-drying formula
#TOP 2

Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill - Mauve

ALC-PAL-REFILL-MAUVE
Mauve
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill - Mauve Cover
Narrative Cosmetics Alcohol Palette Refill Pans - FX Colors - Mauve

The Narrative Cosmetics Refill Pans are ideal for personalizing your alcohol palettes or simply replenishing your favorite shade. Each pan offers vibrant colors that resist water, sweat, and transfer, ensuring your makeup stays intact throughout the day. To use, just add a few drops of 99% isopropyl alcohol to activate the pigments, allowing for a richer application. You can easily apply the colors with a brush or sponge, making it convenient for any makeup routine. When it's time to remove the makeup, simply use alcohol on a tissue for a gentle clean.

What We Like
Highly pigmented colors
Water and sweat resistant
Easy activation with alcohol
Convenient application methods
#TOP 3

Narrative Cosmetics 12 Color Palette

ALC-PAL-EMPTY-12-COLOR
Black
12 Color
Narrative Cosmetics 12 Color Palette Cover
Narrative Cosmetics 12 Color Empty Alcohol Activated Palette for Refills and Custom Palette Creation

The Narrative Cosmetics Palette allows you to create a custom makeup experience tailored to your preferences. With 12 empty slots, you can fill them with your choice of individual refills, giving you complete control over your color selection. The refillable design promotes sustainability and helps you save money by allowing easy replacement of colors as needed. Its compact and organized layout makes it perfect for professionals on the go, ensuring you can bring your favorite shades wherever you travel.

What We Like
Customizable color selection
Sustainable and cost-effective
Travel-friendly design
Organized layout
#TOP 4

SHANY Cream Concealer Palette - Layer 2

SH-6L-02
CONCEALER
SHANY Cream Concealer Palette - Layer 2 Cover
SHANY Cream Concealer/Camouflage Color Correcting Palette - Layer 2 - Refill for the 6 Layer Mini Masterpiece Collection Makeup Set

The SHANY Concealer Palette offers a versatile range of fifteen creamy shades designed to help you achieve a flawless look. With color correctors like lavender to brighten dull skin, peach and yellow to diminish dark circles, and green to neutralize redness, this palette makes addressing imperfections easy. You can seamlessly blend these shades to create a smooth, even complexion. Measuring just 6.5 x 4.5 x 0.5 inches, it’s compact enough to fit in your makeup bag, making it perfect for on-the-go touch-ups. Plus, it’s cruelty-free, so you can feel good about your beauty choices.

What We Like
Versatile color correcting shades
Compact and travel-friendly
Smooth, creamy formula
Cruelty-free product

Trish McEvoy Makeup Wardrobing Compact 2

97853
Black
Compact 2
Trish McEvoy Makeup Wardrobing Compact 2 Cover
Trish McEvoy® Makeup Wardrobing Deluxe Refillable Compact 2

The Trish McEvoy Makeup Compact is designed to elevate your makeup routine. This stylish double-decker compact features two magnetic tiers that allow you to store up to 8 eyeshadow powders and 4 face colors. This means you can easily customize your makeup palette to suit any occasion. With its elegant design, you can carry your essential makeup items wherever you go, making touch-ups a breeze. Plus, the eco-friendly design lets you swap out colors as you please, so you can refresh your look without hassle.

What We Like
Customizable makeup storage
Elegant and portable design
Eco-friendly and refillable
Easy touch-ups on-the-go

NYX Highlight & Contour Pro Palette

HCPP01
Assorted
NYX Highlight & Contour Pro Palette Cover
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Highlight & Contour Pro Palette

The NYX Highlight & Contour Pro Palette is an 8-shade customizable palette that allows you to sculpt, blend and define your best features with creamy colors. With a cruelty-free certification, this contouring palette is perfect for those who love animals. Besides, NYX Professional Makeup offers a full line of face products to complete your makeup look.

What We Like
Customizable 8-shade palette
Cruelty-free certification
Creamy colors are easy to blend and define
#TOP 7

Mehron Paradise Makeup AQ 8 Color Palette

764294582979
Tropical
2 Ounce (Pack of 1)
Mehron Paradise Makeup AQ 8 Color Palette Cover
Mehron Makeup Paradise Makeup AQ 8 Color Tropical Palette | Magnetic Refillable Body Paint & Face Paint Palette | Professional Water Activated Makeup for Costumes, SFX, Halloween, & Cosplay

The Mehron Tropical Makeup Palette is a versatile, water-activated face and body paint set designed for professionals and enthusiasts alike. With its vibrant colors, you can create stunning looks for Halloween, cosplay, or theatrical performances. The palette is vegan and made with gentle ingredients, making it suitable for sensitive skin. Its magnetic design allows you to rearrange and refill the eight color pans, giving you the flexibility to customize your palette for any occasion. Lightweight and travel-friendly, this palette is perfect for artists on the go, ensuring you have everything you need to unleash your creativity.

What We Like
Vibrant color options
Customizable magnetic palette
Vegan and cruelty-free
Suitable for sensitive skin
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How do you refresh a makeup palette?

Use Alcohol To Fix Crushed Powder Speaking of rubbing alcohol, it's also a great way to fix crushed or crumbled powder, whether it's foundation, blush, or eye shadow. Spray or mix a few drops of rubbing alcohol into the powder, then press down firmly with a spoon. Let sit, come back to perfect powder again.

2. What makeup brands let you build your own palette?

10 Brands That Let You Customize Your Own Palettes. Anastasia Beverly Hills.Butter London.Buxom.Inglot.MAC.Make Up For Ever.Makeup Geek.NARS.

3. Can you make your own palette at Sephora?

Reveal your inner artist and create your perfect color mix with Artist Face Color Powders or Artist Color Eye Shadows. Choose your palette size, then customize to your needs by mixing and matching your favorite highlight, sculpt, and blush shades, or eyeshadows.

Editor's Notes

During our refill makeup palette research, we found 48 refill makeup palette products and shortlisted 7 quality products. We collected and analyzed 55,483 customer reviews through our big data system to write the refill makeup palettes list. We found that most customers choose refill makeup palettes with an average price of $12.21.

The refill makeup palettes are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of refill makeup palettes, including Narrative Cosmetics, SHANY, Trish McEvoy, NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP, Mehron. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 73 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Lisa Bechard Avatar

Lisa Bechard is a skin therapist with 12 years of working experience in the beauty industry and also an experienced beauty writer who has expertise in skincare, medical aesthetics and cosmetic surgery, and wellness. Her writing skills are excellent and all her content is very persuasive and insightful.