Best Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow of 2025

"I've been struggling with eczema flare-ups lately, so I was cautious about trying new makeup, especially eyeshadow. However, the gorgeous, natural colors in this palette have been a game changer. They are subtle yet buildable, providing a beautiful, soft look that lasts all day. The formula is smooth and blends effortlessly, giving me a flawless finish. Most importantly, it's gentle on my sensitive skin, with no irritation or flare-ups since I started using it. This palette has quickly become a staple in my makeup routine!"

"I absolutely adore this product! The natural, soft colors are not harmful to my eyes and skin, making it a perfect choice for daily wear. The coconut fragrance adds a lovely touch, too!"

"This palette works beautifully for my blue eyes. The lighter shades are perfect for a daytime look, while the browns are fantastic for eyeliner or brows. I find it to be a great value as it lasts a long time, even for a small palette. The lightest color is perfect for highlighting the eye corners!"

"I absolutely love the colors and the quality of this eyeshadow palette. It's easy to apply, and my husband thinks the colors are pretty!"

"With my super sensitive eyes, this is the only eyeshadow that doesn’t make them water. It lasts all day without caking or leaving a crease line. I highly recommend it!"

"This palette is beautiful and the colors complement my brown eyes and red hair perfectly. It's simple to use and lasts from day to night without any irritation."

"I don't wear much makeup, but I prefer a natural look. This product is perfect for my hazel eyes and applies well with a makeover brush. The color is nicely muted and lasts all day. The ingredients are great. I definitely recommend it!"

"I really like the color palette and the shadow design. It provides a blueprint for applying it to my lid. The result is a soft smokey eye, which transitions nicely from day to night."

"I use Almay eyeshadow due to its ophthalmologist approval for my sensitive eyes. The colors are beautiful and look great on my brown eyes. My only issue was that the eyeshadow arrived a bit chipped, likely from shipping, but I can still use it."

“I was pleasantly surprised by the great colors in this palette. Customer service even reached out to me right after my purchase to ensure everything arrived safely. That’s impressive support! I would definitely buy again.”

“After struggling with eye irritation, I found this hypoallergenic eye shadow palette. It offers lovely color choices, blends effortlessly, and lasts all day without any discomfort.”

“I have extremely sensitive eyes, and this brand has been a game-changer for me. I can wear makeup all day without any irritation, and I love the natural shades!”

"I waited over a month for my order, and when it finally came, I was surprised by its small size, about the size of a quarter. I do like the color, but I can't believe the high price and slow delivery."

"As someone with very sensitive eyes, I chose this eyeshadow. It's long-lasting and perfect for my needs. The color is exactly as shown in the picture."

"The delivery was quick, and the product is just as described. My wife is very satisfied with it."

"I've used many eyeshadows, and I was surprised by how much I love this palette. The light and wonderful scent and buttery application are exceptional. It's long-lasting, and the frosted shadows are rich in color. I really enjoy the scent in makeup!"

"As someone with mature skin, I find this eyeshadow to be of excellent quality. I bought two types for different looks, and it applies smoothly whether I use it dry or wet. It gives my eyes a youthful appearance, and I would highly recommend this palette!"

"I had high hopes for this shadow palette, but unfortunately, the colors were beautiful yet had very little pigment. Even when layered, there was minimal color payoff, and within an hour, most of it had disappeared from my eyelids. I wouldn't recommend this product."

"This is the perfect organic eye shadow for me. I have two-tone green/hazel eyes, and I enjoy wearing soft golds and subtle greens. I ordered the Baeblu eye shadow because it is organic, and I found the colors I've been looking for. The gold shade is more of a honey gold with a peach tint, making it a lovely summer color that complements my eyes beautifully. It applies smoothly with a brush and lasts well throughout the day with just a hint of creasing. Importantly, it doesn't irritate my eyes at all, which is a first! I'm so pleased that I've already ordered two more colors."

"I got this eye shadow because it was verified by EWG, but I found it doesn't apply very well. There's hardly any color payoff at all."

"I have severe allergies to makeup, but this product doesn't bother me at all. It's fantastic!"

"I recently purchased this eye makeup, and it’s a must-have! The neutral palette enhances my eyes beautifully, and I love that it works for sensitive skin too. My granddaughter often sneaks a swipe, and we both adore the shimmer. It’s my go-to eye makeup for everyday use!"

"I bought this palette for my 14-year-old granddaughter who is just starting to explore makeup. She’s absolutely thrilled with it!"

"Having used various PF lines, I must say that this palette offers great colors that blend well and look even better after a few hours. However, I did notice a lot of glitter on my face after application, especially because I wasn’t wearing foundation. For someone over 50 like me, the glitter can be a bit overwhelming. I really enjoyed the purple shade though!"

“I absolutely love this eyeshadow palette. The colors are perfect and it feels silky smooth when I apply it.”

“I found it to be way smaller than I anticipated. However, I’m glad I waited for the price drop to $5.00. The colors are more gray tones rather than the brown I expected, but the product is nice overall. On my pale skin, the bottom two shades look the same, but I’ll keep it since I was hoping for darker browns.”

“I really love Almay products! These shadows don’t make my eyelids break out like others do. After menopause, my skin became sensitive, but thanks to Almay, I can still wear eyeshadows.”

"I've purchased so many eyeshadow sticks and often felt let down. This stick is THE ONE. The shimmer is beautiful, and it lasts without creasing when I use a primer. The color is gorgeous and pigmented. Plus, the stick is sturdy and doesn't break easily during application. I usually don't leave reviews, but I was so impressed that I had to share!"

"I'm not a big makeup user, but I love a light shimmer on my eyes paired with mascara. This color is just perfect for me! I really appreciate the blender on the other end. It's quick and easy to apply, and I absolutely love the look! I'll definitely order again when I need a refill!"

"I was on the hunt for quality makeup, and I decided to try this shadow stick. It goes on smoothly, the pigment is bright, and it stays put all day without smearing or creasing. I used an eyeshadow primer first, and now I'm heading back to Amazon to snag more colors!"