Best Peanut Butter of 2025

"I've been using Skippy for a year now, and I’m sticking with it! After the salmonella outbreak with Jif, I switched brands. Skippy is the closest in taste and texture, and though it’s not as sweet as Jif, it’s still really good. Plus, it’s half the price of Jif, which is a huge bonus! I appreciate that Skippy listens to its customers and offers a dependable product."

"I found this 5-pound jar of Skippy for a great deal! It’s just 22 cents more than the store brand, but the taste is far superior. I even buy it for our local animal shelter since they go through a lot of peanut butter for the dogs. It's important to ensure it’s xylitol-free, and this one is perfect for donations!"

"This peanut butter is creamy and delicious! The 5-pound jar is ideal for big families, allowing us to save money. It’s perfect for quick peanut butter and jelly sandwiches or for keeping on hand as a good source of calories and protein in emergencies. I always have a jar available!"

“This peanut butter is part of my daily breakfast! It's absolutely delicious and priced reasonably. I reorder immediately when I get low. Hope you enjoy it as much as I do.”

“I think these are the cats meow! I love the taste, it doesn’t taste like a Reese's, but it's definitely nice. I enjoy it on toasted bagels and chocolate rice cakes. I liked them so much I bought a case! I keep them hidden from my hubs and grandkids and eat it almost every day.”

“Jif has been my favorite peanut butter since childhood. Finding four large jars at a reasonable price on Amazon is fantastic! The second jar was a bit oilier and thinner, but it still tastes the same, so it's no issue. I’ll be getting mine here from now on!”

"I recently tried SKIPPY Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, and it has quickly become a staple in my pantry. The texture is incredibly smooth, and it spreads easily on toast, crackers, or even straight onto a spoon! What I love most is that it's made with natural ingredients, so there's no need to stir it constantly like some other natural peanut butters. Plus, with 7 grams of protein per serving, it's a great way to add a protein boost to snacks or smoothies. The 40-ounce jar is huge, so it lasts a long time too. I highly recommend it!"

"As someone who tries to avoid processed foods, I decided to give this natural peanut butter a go. I was pleasantly surprised by its spreadable texture and taste. If you don't want lots of added sweeteners or sugar, I suggest trying this brand. It’s the same cost as store shelves and it’s deliverable. I enjoyed it as a dip for pretzels and in my Ramen dish – delicious!"

"This is my first time trying this brand, and I was pleasantly surprised by its freshness. This is quite possibly the best peanut butter that I have ever tasted. It is far superior to Jiff, which I grew up eating. I love how rich, smooth, and creamy this peanut butter is, making it easy to spread. The balance of salty and sweet is just right. I appreciate the 7 grams of protein being a vegetarian, and I highly recommend this 40 oz. jar!"

“I absolutely enjoy Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter! The 40-ounce twin pack is a great deal, and it brings back the taste and quality I remember. My dogs love it too!”

“This peanut butter is simply the best! I appreciate the reasonable price and the fresh smell it has when I open it. Plus, it hardly ever separates, making it easy to use.”

“I find Skippy peanut butter to be super creamy and a fantastic value. It’s my go-to for my daily PB & J sandwiches. I highly recommend it!”

“I absolutely love this peanut butter. It’s not overly sweet or salty and has no unnecessary ingredients.”

“I had high hopes for this peanut butter, but upon opening, I found it had a gritty texture. It seems to be made from peanuts with the skins on, which makes it more bitter. So disappointed, as I was planning to make cookies.”

“I questioned others about this peanut butter because it tasted bad to me. Now, I realize everyone has unique tastes. I love honey, and this peanut butter really complements it. I enjoy the roasted peanut flavor and the smooth texture. This is the only brand we buy now, and I trust it for my family.”

"I've been buying this peanut butter for over 20 years. Please don't stop making it! For those leaving negative reviews, they probably prefer JIF, which is gross. Yes, natural peanut butter is messy, and you need to STIR it. I love the texture; it's not too crunchy and has the best peanut flavor."

"This is my first time ordering this peanut butter, and while it is a bit oily, I find it keeps the peanut butter moist. I just use a knife to stir it back in, and it’s really not a hassle. The flavor is fresh on my sandwich, and I appreciate that it doesn't dry out."

"I opened one of the jars, and honestly, this is garbage peanut butter. I have tried hundreds of brands over the years, and this one is just runny beyond belief. It doesn’t resemble any peanut butter I've had before, and I’m not even sure if I’ll eat it."

“I mostly use peanut butter for oatmeal and sandwiches. I tried the Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread and Honey, and it was incredibly creamy and easily spreadable. The peanut butter-honey flavor was phenomenal, complementing each other perfectly. I loved it in my oatmeal and enjoyed it with cookies too!”

“Honey roasted peanut butter is my favorite! It’s flavorful, smooth, and creamy. I’ll never switch to another kind; it’s perfect on sandwiches, celery, and crackers.”

“This is honestly the best peanut butter I’ve ever tasted. I can eat it straight from the jar by the spoonful!”

"I've always loved Skippy chunky peanut butter; it’s smooth and packed with peanuts. The flavor is rich, and I can use it in cookies and other dishes. Everyone in my family enjoys it, and the 64oz jar is perfect. My son even gets up at night just to nibble on it! It’s usually under $10, and I’ve caught it on sale for as low as $8.87 on Amazon. I've tried others, but I always return to Skippy Chunky."

"I grew up disliking chunky peanut butter, but now it’s all I crave! Maybe it’s a sign of maturity. The deal is fantastic—two giant containers for around $10. Buying this makes me feel like I can afford groceries again, and it brings me happy thoughts, which are important!"

"At 83 years old, I've eaten peanut butter all my life. I used to be a JIF fan, but after hearing about YUKA.COM and its ratings, I switched to Skippy. It tastes just as good as JIF, and I appreciate that it has fewer additives. I’ll stick with Skippy from now on!"

"I love this peanut butter because the only ingredient is dry roasted peanuts. There's no salt, no sugar, and no added oil. Sure, I need to stir it well, and it might not have the thickness of the sugary kinds we grew up with, but the taste makes it worth it. I’m willing to overlook the watery sand-like texture because it tastes great and is free from unnecessary ingredients. I’ll definitely be a repeat buyer!"

"I discovered this peanut butter after struggling to find real options nearby. No additives or sugar here! It's exactly what I wanted—separates like it should and tastes just like peanuts. I'm thrilled with my choice!"

"I wanted to try this product for a while, and now that I have, I’m really impressed. It's plenty chunky and flavorful. While I find the consistency a bit runny, it still works perfectly on a variety of foods. I just wish they offered larger sizes for those of us who enjoy it frequently!"

"I really appreciate the healthier peanut butter option that SKIPPY offers. The creamy texture is just perfect for spreading, and I love that it has no added sugar. It's great for all my snacks and recipes!"

"As someone who watches my sugar intake, this peanut butter spread has been a game-changer for me! The smooth and rich texture makes it a delight, and I love that it's made from high-quality peanuts without any artificial ingredients. I use it in so many ways!"

"Everyone in my household is enjoying this peanut butter without realizing it has no added sugar. It's incredibly creamy, and I appreciate that it doesn't need stirring like some other brands do. A great choice for us!"