Best Peanut Butter of 2026

"As a huge peanut butter lover, I’m amazed by how PBfit delivers the classic taste without the guilt. The protein boost is fantastic, and I’m thrilled I can mix it into my shakes or sprinkle on oatmeal for a quick, healthy snack. No added sugar and gluten-free are major pluses for my diet. This has become a staple in my daily routine."

"I used to think I’d have to give up peanut butter for my diet, but this product is a game changer! It tastes just like peanut butter but with most of the fat removed. I enjoy it on crackers or keto bread, and the calorie and nutrition content fit my goals perfectly. Where has this been all my life?"

"Honestly, PBfit is like peanut butter with discipline—all the flavor and protein, but barely any fat. It’s awesome for oats, shakes, or yogurt, and if you nail the powder-to-water ratio, the texture is creamy and delicious. I love how it supports my macros and makes me feel like I’m eating smarter than everyone else!"

"I've been using Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter for a while and I can honestly say it's incredibly smooth, spreads effortlessly, and the taste is perfectly peanutty with just the right hint of sweetness and salt. I really appreciate that there's no oily separation to deal with—I just pop the lid and it’s ready to use. It’s a staple for my breakfasts, snacks, and even smoothies. The big 26.5 oz jar lasts a long time and offers great value—definitely a pantry must-have for me."

"After trying a bunch of natural peanut butters, I can confidently say this one is my absolute favorite. It delivers a thick, creamy consistency just like classic peanut butter, but with cleaner, simple ingredients. I love that I never have to stir it—just open and spread. The flavor is rich and well-balanced, and it’s a hit with my kids too, whether on apple slices or sandwiches. It’s the perfect choice for anyone seeking a tasty, natural option without sacrificing texture."

"This peanut butter is super smooth and really delicious, plus it’s a great deal. My wife and I are both impressed with the creamy texture and strong peanut flavor—it’s quickly become our go-to choice."

"I've been using PB2 for years, and I love that I can get peanut butter flavor without all the fat and calories. It blends easily with water or milk, and I even toss it into my coffee sometimes. Perfect for protein smoothies and keeps me on track with my health goals."

"I was on the hunt for a healthier peanut butter alternative and PB2 fit the bill. It's super convenient for meal preps and I use it almost every day. I really enjoy putting it on apples for a quick, tasty snack—plus, the price is great for the amount you get."

"As someone who can’t trust myself around regular peanut butter, PB2 is a lifesaver. While I noticed that the chocolate version isn’t dramatically different from the original and the peanut butter taste is a bit lighter, it’s still helping me enjoy the flavor I love without the guilt. I find it works best blended into shakes or mixed drinks rather than used as a direct substitute for peanut butter."

"I found the price to be hard to beat and the peanut butter itself holds up well in comparison to major brands like Jif and Skippy. While Jif might have a slight edge in smoothness and roasted aftertaste, this one delivers a strong peanut flavor and a competitive value—especially if you’re looking for something mass produced and reliable. Honestly, it works for everything from toast to more creative uses. The value makes it a winner for me."

"I've tried plenty of peanut butters and this one stands out for its rich, nutty taste and super creamy spread. It’s perfect for sandwiches and baking. The only thing I’ve noticed is it can separate a bit, so a quick stir is needed, and it’s a tad saltier than expected. Still, given the price and quality, I’d definitely buy it again."

"What I love most is that I can get a delicious peanut butter with a strong peanutty flavor delivered right to my door. The taste is similar to Jif, and the price is excellent for what you get. I’d certainly recommend it to anyone who wants a dependable, tasty staple."

"As a parent in a family of five, I rely on this giant 80 oz. jar of SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter to keep our pantry stocked. It's a lifesaver for us—incredible value, fewer grocery trips, and the classic, perfectly creamy taste everyone can agree on. I love knowing we get 7g of protein per serving, making it a great, quick energy boost for the kids and adults alike. If your household goes through peanut butter like we do, this is by far the most convenient and cost-effective way to buy it."

"After the salmonella scare with Jif and a disappointing lack of reimbursement, I switched to Skippy. Honestly, it's the closest in taste and texture to Jif, with a slightly less sweet, more balanced flavor. Plus, the cost savings are major—Skippy's 5-pound tub is half the price of Jif's 4-pound. For the past year, it's been my go-to with absolutely no issues. I strongly recommend Skippy to anyone looking for reliable quality at a great value."

"Skippy peanut butter is a timeless classic for me. The moment I open the jar, it brings back nostalgic memories of childhood snacks. The creamy, easy-to-spread consistency never disappoints, and it holds up in everything from sandwiches to shakes. What I appreciate most is it stays fresh and never separates, unlike some natural brands. No mess, just smooth, dependable peanut butter every time. For me, Skippy truly sets the standard."

"SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter has the perfect smoothness and rich peanut taste that makes it my go-to for toast, sandwiches, and even recipes. The jar size is just right for daily use, and I always find the quality to be consistent. It's a brand I trust and will continue to buy."

"This peanut butter wins over the entire family—from sandwiches to puppy treats, everyone loves it! It's easy to spread, never oily on top, and always delivers that classic, delicious flavor. Plus, it's budget-friendly and perfect for PB&Js, baking, or eating straight from the spoon."

"I used to be loyal to another brand, but after switching, Skippy has become my favorite for its smoothness, lack of oiliness, and reliably fresh taste. It spreads easily and always meets my expectations, making it a five-star staple in our pantry."

"After trying tons of peanut butter brands, I now buy this by the case. The ratio of crunchy peanuts to creamy butter is perfect, and it’s never too sweet or salty. The consistency is spot-on, and I love that the ingredients are clean without being oily. I use it for everything—from cooking to eating it straight off a spoon for a protein boost. It’s a great value, especially when bought in bulk."

"I tried the Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread with Honey for my breakfast oatmeal and sandwiches, and I was amazed by how incredibly creamy and easy to spread it is. The blend of peanut and honey flavors is phenomenal—the honey complements the peanut taste without overpowering it. My nieces and nephews love it too, especially with cookies. There was a bit of oil on top when I first opened it, but it didn’t affect the flavor or texture. It’s now my top pick for peanut butter."

"Honestly, I didn’t expect much, but after tasting this, I nearly finished the whole jar in one go! It’s so smooth and glides like a treat, but it doesn’t taste overly sweet or like dessert. I first bought it for my roommate, who loves honey on peanut butter toast, but I quickly became a fan myself. No oiliness or stirring needed for me, and the flavor is beautifully balanced. I’ll definitely order more."

"As someone who reads labels religiously, I love that this non-GMO honey peanut butter tastes incredibly fresh and natural—almost like I ground the peanuts myself. With just a hint of sweetness and minimal added sugar, it feels way less guilty than dessert. The oil sometimes floats on top, but a quick stir makes it perfectly creamy. Honestly, it never lasts long enough in my house to test the shelf life!"

"I needed a peanut butter with no added sugar due to my diabetes, and this is perfect. It's not just organic, but super easy to stir compared to other natural brands. The consistency is just like mainstream peanut butter once mixed, and the flavor is fantastic."

"I switched to this classic peanut butter to avoid those sugary, palm oil-heavy spreads. What stands out is the deep, authentic peanut taste—just peanuts with a whisper of palm oil for stability. It’s filling, gluten-free, and fits my family’s dietary needs. Sure, the texture isn’t ultra-smooth and it costs a bit more, but the wholesome ingredients and roasted flavor are worth it."

"I've been a fan of Jif for over 60 years, and the 4lb container is a game changer for me. The peanut butter is always fresh, perfectly firm and spreadable, and I love not having to dig into those narrow plastic jars anymore. I just wish they offered all Jif varieties in this larger size—it's that good!"

"These individual cups are a lifesaver for my family's lunches. They keep the peanut butter fresh longer, are super convenient for dipping or spreading on sandwiches, and I appreciate that they're a safe alternative to hazelnut spreads due to allergies in our home. Delicious taste and smooth consistency every time."

"The peanut butter arrived well-sealed, undamaged, and incredibly fresh—not stale like it's been sitting around. It's easy to stir and spread, smells wonderful, and the price is much cheaper than local stores. Definitely great value for the quality."