Best Meal Replacement Shakes of 2025

"I’ve tried the unflavored, chocolate, and vanilla spiced chai flavors. The health benefits are incredible, providing energy and keeping me full for hours. However, the texture is quite thick—definitely different from the dairy-based shakes I grew up with! I recommend mixing it with more liquid to avoid a lumpy shake. The unflavored variant had a bitter taste for me, which I couldn't mask, leading me to throw it away. The chocolate flavor was much better, though it still had a faint aftertaste. The vanilla spiced chai, on the other hand, has become my favorite—it's delicious and I look forward to my breakfast shake every day!"

"I initially had concerns about the taste, but I chose the vanilla flavor after reading positive reviews. I found the texture to be a bit grainy, but it didn’t bother me. I mix it with goat milk and cocoa powder, which makes it enjoyable. When I use almond milk, I feel less full, so I prefer goat milk for longer satiety. After a few days, my stomach adjusted well and I noticed increased energy and even some weight loss! I love how it fits into my routine, providing additional fiber without the need for a blender!"

"Today was my first experience with Ka'chava, and I opted for the vanilla flavor. I often skip lunch, and with my low iron levels, I needed something to help me through the day. I blended a half serving with full fat coconut milk, and the flavor reminded me of vanilla cake batter—not overly sweet, just right for my taste. Despite a few dry pockets, I enjoyed it immensely and felt satisfied afterwards. Even my picky toddler loved it, and I noticed a significant change in his behavior post-drink!"

"I truly find this product delicious! It has made a noticeable difference in my energy levels throughout the day. I feel full without any crashes. Although the price is a concern, for someone who prioritizes health and nutrition, I believe it is worth it."

"As someone sensitive to sugar, I loved the chocolate flavor and was excited to try the vanilla and coconut acai. However, I've noticed that after drinking the coconut acai, I start sweating, which indicates a blood sugar spike for me. While the vanilla isn't as problematic, I’m cautious about the amount of sugar despite the label stating only 7 grams. I’m eager to try the new chocolate formula to see how it compares!"

“I've been using the SlimFast Meal Replacement Powder in Original French Vanilla, and it’s been a fantastic part of my weight management routine. The taste is excellent and mixes well with water or milk, making a smooth shake. It's incredibly convenient for busy mornings, and nutritionally, it’s well-balanced, keeping me full until my next meal. I've noticed steady weight loss since starting this product, which is easy to follow and flexible. I highly recommend it for its great taste and nutritional benefits.”

“When I tried the chocolate flavor, I noticed some mixed reviews, but I found it to be quite good by adding Mexican Vanilla Blend and ice. It keeps me full for hours, especially with chia seeds. After a few attempts, I found the right combination to make it taste amazing. It’s a filling option that really works for me!”

“I love the chocolate flavor, as it tastes very natural. Although I found the vanilla to be a bit too intense, this product has been great for hunger control and weight loss. I trust this product and appreciate the support it provides in my weight management journey.”

"I have a difficult time getting my protein and fiber throughout the day. Luckily, these drinks offer a flavor I enjoy that doesn’t sit heavy on my stomach. They’re filling, the perfect serving size, and easy to store."

"This shake tastes great and isn't overly sweet, even though it’s low in sugar. It keeps me full for hours, and I’ve already lost 7lbs in just one week!"

"I highly recommend this protein drink. The smooth and flavorful taste makes me feel satisfied at lunch, helping me meet a significant portion of my daily protein intake."

"I love the flavors and the results! I've lost 44 lbs and continue to get slimmer. I drink two a day and feel great, without any hunger."

"My boyfriend and I are huge fans! The chocolate flavor reminds us of chocolate milk and it's very filling. I've lost about 7 pounds so far!"

"I've been using the Chocolate Royale powder for decades. The flavor and quality are consistently great, but I'm disappointed with the new packaging."

"I've been enjoying the Soylent Creamy Chocolate Meal Replacement Shake for breakfast almost every day for the past six months. The taste is amazing—my son even calls it ‘chocolate milk’! It’s smooth and creamy with all the nutrients I need to kick off my day. I’ve found ordering from Amazon to be incredibly reliable, always receiving fresh bottles. For the price, the convenience and quality are unbeatable. As someone who is neurodivergent, having a safe, easy meal option makes a significant difference in my routine."

"My girlfriend absolutely adores the rich, creamy taste of Soylent Chocolate! It’s been a game-changer for her health, offering complete nutrition in a tasty, convenient way. It really helps her stay focused on her health goals, especially when life gets busy. I highly recommend it for anyone seeking a delicious and nutritious meal replacement!"

"Despite the price, I keep returning to Soylent as my top choice for meal replacement. These shakes work perfectly for breakfast or lunch when my stomach is acting up but I still feel hungry. I enjoy nearly every flavor except the original/unflavored. They have a satisfying consistency and, most importantly, keep me feeling full for a long time. However, occasionally when I order a multi-flavor box, I receive some bottles that expire soon. Regardless, I’ve never encountered a bad texture or off taste. I truly love Soylent!"

"I've been using Soylent for 15 days on a 95% Soylent-only diet. It's a great meal replacement that offers everything my body needs. The taste is bland but manageable, and it allows me to monitor my caloric intake easily. I've lost 10 pounds in just two weeks!"

"For me, Soylent is a miracle! I used to struggle to find time to eat enough throughout the day. Now, it’s so simple—no preparation needed. At first, I found the original flavor hard to stomach, but after adding chocolate Nesquick, I adjusted. I now prefer the Cacao flavor, which tastes just like chocolate milk!"

"I usually drink 4 bottles a day and feel that my appreciation for food has heightened. Everything tastes richer and more flavorful. I did experience some salt cravings initially, but adding a pinch of salt to my Soylent helped. Running out of Soylent is my biggest fear—it's hard to switch back to regular food!"

"I don't usually have time for breakfast, so these shakes have been a lifesaver for me. They provide about an hour and a half of good energy without any bloating or aftertaste. I've tried many meal replacement shakes, and Orgain's Creamy Chocolate Fudge is by far the best. After my jiujitsu training, I drink one about 30 minutes before class, and I feel energized!"

"As someone with a sucralose allergy, I love that these shakes have ZERO artificial sweeteners. The chocolate flavor tastes like drinking smooth chocolate milk, and it's not too sweet or chalky. I highly recommend enjoying them super cold from the fridge. Although they're on the pricier side, the quality justifies the cost. My health is priceless!"

"My dietician recommended this product, and it has truly been a game changer. I struggle to eat breakfast, but this shake tastes like chocolate and pairs wonderfully with bananas or strawberries. I've been using subscribe and save for nearly a year, but I was disappointed when the price increased significantly. Still, I absolutely love the shake!"

"I couldn't eat solids for two days due to a dental issue, so I decided to try this meal replacement. I used two scoops with whole milk, and while it would mix better in a blender, I was lazy and ended up with some chunky bits. The taste was decent—still a bit 'protein powdery' but not overly chemical. It filled me up enough for the day, and I was able to sleep easily without any stomach rumbles."

"I absolutely love this product! Pro tip: blend it with a handful of frozen fruit and your choice of milk—I personally use soy milk. I'm currently enjoying a strawberries and cream shake every morning, and it’s been fantastic!"

"I decided to try the Triple Berry Vanilla flavor, and I find it keeps me feeling full longer than other shakes, probably because it's made with actual berries rather than artificial flavors. It truly tastes like food because it IS food!"

"I’m on my annual weight loss kick and after hours of searching, I found this meal replacement shake. Only 140 calories and 20g protein per serving! I used water, and it tasted amazing—like pineapple milk! No chalkiness or chunks. 10/10, I’ll definitely buy this brand again!"

"I’ve spent so much on protein shakes that disappointed me. Today, I tried the orange cream, and I was blown away! It tastes just like an ice cream creamsicle and has a rich, creamy texture. I mix it with ice and cashew milk for a thicker shake. My kids love it too—it feels like a dessert! I’m sticking with this brand!"

"I’m honestly surprised by how much I like this shake. I previously did a month-long challenge with Herbalife, and while their shakes were fantastic, they were pricey. I found this one on Prime Day and tried it. Using almond milk and some berries, I created a smoothie that’s simply delicious! I’m a bit annoyed, though—it's now about $20 more than what I paid!"