Best German Mustard of 2026

"I bought this mustard to enjoy with Weisswurst after seeing it recommended, and it turned out to be absolutely delicious with a sweet, zingy kick. It’s not spicy, but the freshness and perfect pairing with sausage really impressed me."

"After sampling many mustards, this one stands out as my clear favorite because of its ideal horseradish balance and outstanding flavor. It’s neither too thick nor runny, and I find myself reordering it regularly."

"If you like a mustard that’s sweet, savory, and excellent for meats and sausages, this is the one. It’s so tasty, I find myself reaching for it again and again!"

"Having lived in Germany for nearly seven years, I can confirm this is the authentic Düsseldorf mustard—it has a bold, spicy kick without being overpowering. The medium sharpness is just right, making it the classic variety. Buy with confidence, as I did."

"We’re thrilled to have access to this lion brand mustard in the US. It’s our go-to for sauerkraut and sausages, and the quality and taste are excellent. I just wish it was available in the toothpaste tube packaging we enjoyed overseas."

"This mustard is delicious and versatile—it’s a bit like Dijon but not as strong. Perfect for bratwurst or hotdogs. I highly recommend it for anyone who loves good mustard."

"I’m a huge fan of this mustard—the combination of horseradish and tangy flavor is unbeatable. While I wish it came in a glass jar instead of plastic, I simply transfer it myself. If you care about taste, this is top-notch."

"After losing my favorite sweet hot mustard from Publix, I tried this one and it’s even better! The flavor is fantastic, not too spicy, and it’s gluten free. It’s become my go-to for turkey sandwiches. Highly recommend!"

"As an American now living in the UK, I was thrilled to find this mustard available online. It’s got just the right amount of tang and spice. Please restock soon—I need more!"

"I really appreciate the classic, familiar taste this yellow mustard offers—it's perfect on everything from hot dogs to burgers. The smooth texture and easy-squeeze bottle make it a staple in my fridge. While it's a bit tangier than I anticipated, I just use a little less. Overall, it's a reliable and affordable choice for everyday meals and cookouts."

"What stands out to me about 365 Organic Yellow Mustard is its bold, tangy flavor and the fact that it's made from certified organic ingredients. I like knowing it's free from artificial additives and GMOs. Whether I'm making salad dressings or adding it to sandwiches, it always brings a vibrant, rich taste to my dishes. Plus, I feel good about its eco-friendly packaging."

"This organic honey mustard has the ideal balance of sweet and tangy I look for. It's smooth, spreads easily, and I love that it's organic and affordable. For anyone wanting a versatile and high-quality condiment, I definitely recommend this one."

"Whenever I'm craving a taste of home, this mustard is a must-have. The sweet and coarse texture is exactly what I remember from Germany, and it's perfect with Weisswurst and pretzels. I always make sure to stock up since it's difficult to find locally."

"I was thrilled to find this on Amazon because it's the exact sweet mustard I enjoyed with sausages during my trip to Germany. The authentic flavor really stands out, and I keep a jar on hand at all times."

"This is truly the best mustard I've had—no other sweet relish compares. Although it's a little pricey, nothing else matches the taste and quality."

"I never liked mustard, but after trying this authentic German mustard, I’m completely hooked. It’s smooth, mild, and not as tangy as typical American mustard. I’ve been searching for this taste since my trip to Germany, and this is the real deal—it’s absolutely worth the price!"

"This mustard brings me right back to my days in Germany. It’s the exact flavor served with wurst—the perfect heat and mustard balance. If you want genuine German taste, this is it."

"After watching a mustard challenge on TV, I decided to try this. The jar arrived safely, and as soon as I tasted it, I found it to be incredibly smooth, rich, and flavorful. If typical American mustards are a five, this is a solid ten—I highly recommend it!"

"I really appreciate how this mustard delivers a flavorful kick without overwhelming heat. The horseradish-style warmth and tangy vinegar notes make it my go-to for sandwiches, pretzels, and brats. It’s not the kind of spicy that burns, but rather a balanced blend perfect for those who want more flavor than just plain yellow mustard."

"I love using this mustard for German bratwurst and salads, especially during Oktoberfest. While it’s advertised as 'extra hot,' I find the heat more subtle—just enough to enhance the taste without being overpowering like Chinese mustard. It’s become a staple in my kitchen because of its unique taste and versatility."

"If you enjoy a Dijon-style mustard with a noticeable nose-clearing sensation, this is the best I’ve found. It’s excellent on sandwiches and even works as an emulsifier in sauces. For anyone who likes their mustard to have a bit of a punch, this is a fantastic choice."

"As a self-proclaimed mustard enthusiast, this has become my go-to condiment. I love that it doesn't have an overpowering vinegar taste, and it brings just the right amount of subtle kick to brats and juicy cheeseburgers. Highly recommend trying it!"

"I grew up with this classic German mustard and was thrilled to find it available online when I ran out. It arrived quickly, just in time for my potato salad, and brought back childhood memories. The only tiny downside was the expiration date being a bit close, but the flavor and nostalgia make it worthwhile."

"I usually pick this up during my European layovers, but being homebound, I was grateful Amazon had it. It's a delicious product and brought a taste of Germany to my kitchen. The price was higher than local stores, but worth it when you're craving the real deal."

"I couldn't believe how good this Bavarian sweet mustard tasted the first time I tried it—it completely changed what I thought mustard could be. Now, I use it for dipping and on sandwiches all the time. It really adds something special to every meal."

"This mustard instantly takes me back to my time in Germany with the USAF. The flavor is spot-on and brings back great memories. I absolutely love it!"

"I've tried several sweet mustards in the US, but this one comes closest to the ALDI exclusive I was hooked on. The texture is even better, though the flavor isn't an exact match. It's still a fantastic choice for anyone missing authentic Bavarian mustard."

"Having lived in Germany for five years, I can say this mustard has an authentic taste. It's incredible on bratwurst and beef hot dogs with sauerkraut. While it's a bit pricey, I believe the quality justifies the cost."

"I appreciated the quick delivery and secure packaging. The mini beer mug containers are a fun touch and I even use them for overnight oats. The mustard itself is delicious."

"Although I spent years in Germany, I found this mustard tasted more like Grey Poupon than what I expected. It's not quite the traditional flavor I was hoping for."