Best Sandwich Spreads of 2025

"As a mayo enthusiast, I was pleasantly surprised by Blue Plate Mayo. It has a velvety consistency that's very similar to my favorite, Best Foods. The flavor is slightly more savory and eggier, but not overwhelming, making it a great addition to my fridge. For the price of $4-5 a jar, it's definitely worth trying!"

"I stumbled upon this mayo while restocking my pantry. Priced at $3.06, it seemed like a steal compared to Hellmann's. While it has a slightly tangier taste, it reminds me of Kraft mayo. It’s not quite as heavy as other brands, but it strikes a nice balance. I like it enough to keep it on hand!"

"After moving back to Canada from New Orleans, I really missed Blue Plate Mayo. There's simply no substitute for it. This mayo brings a unique flavor that elevates even a basic potato salad. I'm thrilled that I can now enjoy it again!"

"I purchased the caramelized onion jam, artichoke bruschetta, and green asparagus bruschetta from Perfect Choice, and they are honestly really good. The flavors are rich but not overpowering, making them perfect for appetizers or snacks. I particularly enjoyed the caramelized onion jam with baguette, brie cheese, and a touch of apricot jam—it was amazing! These dips are fantastic for trying out different food combinations or simply enjoying on their own. They definitely enhanced my get-togethers. I highly recommend them if you love fun, flavorful pairings!"

"I sent two sets of these as gifts, and both recipients had glowing reports about the delicious contents. They mentioned that the bruschettas were unique and worth trying, and that the onion jam was wonderful. It was a success!"

"I do like this onion jam, but just a heads-up: the taste and smell linger. I've used it on burgers, hot dogs, and pizza, and it improved all of them. Just a little goes a long way. Also, I noticed that even with the lid tightened, the liquid seeped out of the jar when it was accidentally placed on its side."

"This has been a long-time favorite of my mother, so I ordered some for her. Great choice!"

"I’ve always loved Kraft sandwich spread. It's hard to find in stores, but I found it here. Expensive, but worth it to me!"

"I was thrilled to find this because I haven't seen it in stores for years. However, I did pay over $15 for two jars, which feels a bit steep!"

"I've struggled to find this product in my area, and it usually costs over $4.00 a can. Fortunately, the expiration date is fantastic, so I know it will be used before it expires."

"The taste and quality of this product are truly remarkable. I can easily open the can, give it a quick stir, and enjoy it on crackers or sandwiches. It's a time-tested flavor that offers great value for the money."

"At 66 years old, I've been enjoying this for most of my adult life, but this time the product didn't resemble what I expected. It was mostly mushy with oil on top, and even my neighbor's cat refused to eat it. It ended up in the garbage, and it came without the usual paper wrapper which was disappointing."

"I absolutely LOVE this bruschetta! I enjoy it on charcuterie boards or just on a cracker by itself. The flavor is perfect! My only issue was that it leaked during shipment, which was disappointing."

"I really like this product, and I can usually find it cheaper at my grocery store. I bought it for my sister who can't find it where she lives, and she enjoys it too, though you really have to love olives."

"I had a terrible experience! The jar lid was loose, and oil leaked all over my other items in the box. Plus, it's not returnable or replaceable! Honestly, it's the worst product and service ever!"

"I use this spread in my canned chicken salad; just add mayonnaise and Wickles for a perfect chicken salad that my kids love!"

"I first tried this spread on a date, and even though that guy is gone, I still adore it! It's fantastic on burgers!"

"If you haven't tasted this spread yet, you're missing out! It pairs wonderfully with sandwiches."

"This is an excellent spread to add to my sandwiches. It's tangy and hot, adding a bit of zing to my meal, especially on subs. I do have to watch how much I use, as it can give me a little heartburn, but the taste is so good that I don’t mind a few burps here and there."

"I just find this to be yummy! It’s the perfect spread for subs, reminding me of my childhood when every pizza and sub place had it in small plastic containers. It’s sweet and hot, and it makes everything I eat 100% better! I love it plain or with cheese, and it’s also delicious in recipes!"

"I couldn't find this hoagie spread anywhere locally, but I was thrilled to find it on Amazon. The peppers are tasty, making my turkey and Swiss sandwiches better. The consistency is just right—moist but not soggy—and it’s all about the taste rather than heat. If you're looking for something mild, I highly recommend trying this!"

"I never want to go without again. 1000% better than peanut butter!"

"I bought this for snacking, and it's SO good! I'm now addicted to a spoonful almost every afternoon. Not too sweet, and I enjoy the crunchy bits. I highly recommend Lotus CRUNCHY Biscuit Spread!"

"I tried it and LOVED it. Such an amazing sweet treat! However, $11.50 for a small jar is just ridiculous. I found it for $5.36 at Walmart, so I won't buy from here again."

“I find that ordering this by the case is a better deal than buying it individually at the grocery store. Plus, Prime Shipping makes it even more appealing! I love to add some celery seed and sunflower seeds for an extra crunch when I eat it with wheat thins for lunch.”

“I've been a fan of this for years, and it still maintains its consistent flavor. It's a convenient option when I'm in a hurry and need something tasty!”

“My wife and I are big fans of the Underwood Chicken Spread. We always keep it in our pantry for a quick sandwich or snack. It’s great that it doesn’t spoil like deli meats do, and buying it by the case is definitely the best option for us.”

“I absolutely love my hot stuff on Italian subs and ham and cheese sandwiches. This spread is perfect for all!”

“This hot hoagie spread is just as good as I remember from my teenage years in Boston. It’s a bit on the pricier side, but since I can’t find it in Texas, it’s well worth it! It adds just enough heat and zing without overpowering my sandwiches.”

“I searched everywhere for this flavor in grocery stores and finally found it on Amazon. I love this Hot Hoagie Spread! It has a nice little kick and is a great value for the money. I would definitely buy it again!”