Best Sandwich Spreads of 2026

"I've purchased this pistachio cream twice now and it's likely to become my go-to brand. The creamy consistency and natural green color blend perfectly into my Dubai chocolate recipe, with no waste thanks to the ideal jar size. The quality justifies the higher price for me, and the jar always arrives well-sealed and leak-free."

"I love how creamy and flavorful this pistachio cream is. It's delicious on toast and bagels, and I'll definitely be coming back for more. Great taste and texture overall."

"While the cream was smooth and sweet, I found the pistachio flavor a bit subtle for my personal taste. The jar wasn't completely full, but it still worked well as a filling for my chocolate and strawberry desserts. Added a nice sweet layer even if the pistachio note was mild."

"Having tasted pastries in Italy, I was delighted that this pistachio butter brought back those authentic European flavors. It’s delicious on both bagels and croissants!"

"I bought this to make my own Dubai-style chocolate at home, and it turned out fantastic. The flavor is so good that I sometimes just eat it by itself!"

"The bottle is easy to use and has amazing taste, but I wish it was offered in a bigger size. Also, one of my bottles leaked in the package, and the product inside was a bit dry."

"The Biscoff Cookie Spread truly amazed me—its smooth, sweet flavor is spot-on to the original cookies. I love how I can put it on toast, fruit, or just eat it by the spoonful. Absolutely delicious and worth every penny!"

"After dental surgery, I tried Biscoff Spread for the first time and it made those tough weeks much more enjoyable. It’s not a peanut butter replacement for me, but as a dessert treat, it’s outstanding. I like it best when kept in the fridge or freezer—the thicker, chilled texture is perfect for savoring straight from the jar. If the spread feels greasy or thin, try storing it cold!"

"This spread is incredibly tasty, just like the famous cookies you get on some airlines. It’s delicious on bread, pancakes, fruit, or even on its own. The flavor is addictive, and it arrived in perfect condition—I totally see why it’s so popular online!"

"As someone with a severe nut allergy, I was thrilled to find a spread that’s not only delicious and creamy but also completely nut-free and safe for me. The taste reminds me of peanut butter, and I appreciate that it’s made in a peanut-free facility. My only wish is that the container were larger and the price a bit lower, but it’s worth it for the peace of mind and flavor."

"I include this in my vegetarian diet regularly because it’s a nutritious protein source with low sodium and no sugar. It always arrives well-packaged, and I’ve been satisfied with both the product and the service for years."

"As a school nurse, I recommend this to families with peanut allergies. It’s a creamy, tasty alternative to peanut butter, and works well as a snack with apples. The only note is the slight sunflower seed aftertaste, but it’s not a dealbreaker, especially for those seeking a safe substitute."

"I was expecting something like Nutella, but this pistachio cream is on a whole different level—the depth of flavor and quality truly stand out. Even as a picky eater, I was impressed. It's honestly magical and worth every penny."

"As a baker for a local restaurant, I tried this pistachio cream after seeing some creative recipes online. It arrived in great condition, was easy to use, and enhanced my desserts. The price is fair, and I'll definitely be ordering again soon."

"I've purchased this pistachio cream several times and it never disappoints—smooth, sweet, and creamy, with just a little needed for amazing flavor. It's hands down the best I've tried and I highly recommend it."

"I've been enjoying this product since 1977 and it’s still just as delicious and refreshing as the first time. Perfect for all sorts of dishes—I absolutely love it!"

"I tried Heinz salad cream for the first time and found it to be delicious and ideal for mixing with mayo. It made my deviled eggs and potato salad taste amazing, plus the delivery was fast and the packaging solid."

"Most American mayos lack the simple piquancy I want in my sandwiches, but this has it. Heinz salad cream is exactly what I’ve been missing—thank you!"

"I've become hooked on this sunflower seed butter—it's super smooth, rich, and totally organic with absolutely no added sugars or salt. Even though I wish it didn't contain sunflower oil, I honestly can't stop eating it! The seller's customer service was beyond impressive; after a mix-up with my order, they quickly resolved everything and even let me keep the extra jars. Highly recommended for both the product and the seller!"

"Because of my nut allergy, this has become my staple for PB&J sandwiches and healthy snacks. It's a delicious, protein-packed substitute that fits perfectly into my recipes. I always feel confident buying from this brand."

"After accidentally buying this instead of my usual peanut butter, I was pleasantly surprised! Now, it's my favorite addition to smoothies—creamy, flavorful, and blends perfectly. Trust me, you'll want to try it!"

"Because I have an egg allergy, I needed a substitute for my favorite mayo. Follow Your Heart is the closest to Hellman's, which I love, and I'm genuinely satisfied. It's the best alternative I've found."

"I'm not strictly vegetarian, but I really appreciate that this mayo is lighter than traditional mayonnaise. I use it in egg salads, on plant burgers, and in veggie bowls—it's so versatile and easy to mix in."

"I've sampled many vegan mayos, and this one stands out for its thick, creamy consistency and wonderful flavor. I love that it's healthier than other vegan options, and it makes my meals taste great!"

"I've been buying this mayonnaise since it first launched because it's the only organic mayo I've found that uses high-quality ingredients and still tastes great. I appreciate that it doesn't rely on unusual oils or preservatives, and the texture is just right—thick without being oily. While it does have a shorter shelf life after opening, the delicious flavor makes it worth it."

"I enjoy the smooth consistency and refined spicy flavor of this mayo. Unlike other spicy condiments that can be too salty or harsh, this one is balanced and not overly spicy or salty. I find myself tasting it before every use just because I love the unique, well-considered flavor!"

"As a longtime fan of Hellmann's, I tried this organic version when the original was out of stock. It's definitely not the same as the classic Hellmann's—there's a distinct taste that stands out, and it wasn't what I was expecting in my chicken salad. After refrigerating, the flavor mellowed a bit, but I still prefer the original Hellmann's for its neutral taste."

"I absolutely love the convenience of the squeeze bottle—it makes Vegemite so much easier to use and share without any mess. The great taste remains the same, and I enjoy it with almost every meal. If some folks don't like the flavor, that's just more for me!"

"I switched from Marmite to Vegemite just because of the affordable squeeze bottle. While Vegemite has a stronger, earthier flavor than Marmite, I actually like it and the packaging is much more practical."

"I found Vegemite's taste very strong and honestly, it's not for me. After trying it on buttered toast, I noticed a residual plastic flavor from the packaging. I'd suggest buying it only if you already enjoy Vegemite or really want to see what the fuss is about."