Best Cocktail Sauce of 2026

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 15, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Cocktail sauce is a tangy and flavorful condiment that is commonly served with seafood dishes such as shrimp cocktail. It is typically made with a combination of ketchup, horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice, and hot sauce. This classic sauce is a staple on many restaurant menus and can also be easily made at home. It adds a zesty kick to any seafood dish and is perfect for dipping or spreading. Whether you're hosting a dinner party or enjoying a casual meal, cocktail sauce is a must-have condiment for seafood lovers.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce Cover #TOP 1
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Beaver Cocktail Sauce with Fresh Grated Horseradish Cover #TOP 2
Beaver Cocktail Sauce with Fresh Grated Horseradish
ftb score rating icon 9.7
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce Cover #TOP 3
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Cocktail Sauce

#TOP 1

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce Cover
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce, 10 Fl Oz

Introducing 365 Organic Cocktail Sauce by Whole Foods Market, a fat-free and sodium-conscious option for your seafood dishes. Made with premium ingredients, this Amazon brand sauce is perfect for adding flavor to your favorite seafood appetizers. With the trust and quality that Whole Foods Market is known for, you can be sure that this product meets rigorous standards. Whether you're enjoying shrimp cocktail or crab cakes, this cocktail sauce is the ideal accompaniment. Plus, with the convenience of a 10 Fl Oz bottle, you can easily add a tangy kick to your seafood dishes whenever you want.

What We Like
Good flavor balance
Thick and spicy texture
Excellent store-bought option
Works well with shrimp
Easy to thicken with additives
What We Don't Like
Somewhat sweet for some
Odd flavor noted by few
#TOP 2

Beaver Cocktail Sauce with Fresh Grated Horseradish

71828-00212
Beaver Cocktail Sauce with Fresh Grated Horseradish Cover
Beaver Cocktail Sauce with Fresh Grated Horseradish, 13 oz squeeze bottle

Beaver Horseradish Sauce is a flavorful condiment that adds the perfect kick to your next seafood dish or sandwich. Made with fresh grated horseradish roots, this kosher, vegetarian, low calorie, gluten-free sauce contains no trans fats, cholesterol or preservatives, making it perfect for special dietary needs and easy digestion. The ergonomically designed squeeze bottle with a travel-friendly flip cap makes it easy and convenient for adults and kids alike to use. Just squeeze for more! Try our condiments made from fresh ingredients and put a dollop of your favorite mustard or wasabi on your food anytime to make it finger-licking good.

What We Like
Great flavor
Good heat level
Excellent on crackers
Ideal for sandwiches
Strong and spicy
What We Don't Like
Too strong for some
Inconsistent packaging
#TOP 3

OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce

070328820642
8 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce Cover
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce, 8 fl oz

OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce is a classic tomato and horseradish seafood dipping sauce with OLD BAY zest. Featuring their iconic blend of 18 spices and herbs, like celery salt and paprika, it has a big flavor with a thick texture and just the right amount of spice. Ready to eat, it's perfect for shrimp cocktail, oysters and crab cake sandwiches.

What We Like
Great for seafood
Tasty and tangy flavor
Convenient and easy to use
Spicy with horseradish
Well packaged for delivery
What We Don't Like
Hard to find in stores
Overpriced on Amazon
#TOP 4

Heinz Cocktail Sauce

013000001137
Heinz Cocktail Sauce Cover
Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce is a great tasting seafood sauce that is perfect for shrimp, fish, and other shellfish. This gluten-free sauce is made with tomato concentrate, horseradish, onion powder, and garlic powder for a zesty, bold flavor. Customers love the flavor of Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce, and appreciate its versatility for a variety of dishes.

What We Like
Flavorful and tangy experience
Great value for price
Easy to handle bottle
Classic taste for seafood
Consistent quality
What We Don't Like
Sweetness may overpower flavor
Less horseradish than competitors
#TOP 5

Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce (2-Pack)

013000001137
Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce (2-Pack) Cover
Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle) (Pack of 2)

Heinz Cocktail Sauce is a delicious addition to your seafood dishes, perfect for enhancing the flavors of shrimp, fish, and shellfish. Each 12 oz. bottle offers a zesty blend of tomato concentrate, horseradish, onion, and garlic powders, ensuring a bold taste that everyone in your family will enjoy. With its gluten-free formula and zero cholesterol, you can indulge in this sauce without guilt. Whether you're hosting a gathering or enjoying a quiet dinner, this cocktail sauce makes it easy to elevate your meals with minimal effort.

What We Like
High quality materials
Excellent customer service
Easy to use
Affordable price
What We Don't Like
Limited color options
Initial setup can be tricky
#TOP 6

St. Elmo Extra Spicy Cocktail Sauce

St. Elmo's Cocktail Sauce 8 OZ (2 Pack)
8 Fl Oz (Pack of 2)
St. Elmo Extra Spicy Cocktail Sauce Cover
St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce, Extra Spicy Seafood Sauce and Cocktail Sauce for Shrimp, World Famous 8 Fl Oz (2 Pack)

St. Elmo Spicy Sauce offers a unique blend of fiery flavor that has been perfected over 119 years. Made with fresh horseradish, it delivers a bold taste that is sure to elevate your seafood dishes. The refreshing tomato base and citrus notes make it an ideal complement for shrimp and other seafood, enhancing your culinary experience. Crafted with care, this sauce is perfect for entertaining guests or enjoying a special meal at home. With its long-lasting flavor, you'll appreciate how it transforms any dish into a memorable feast.

What We Like
Strong horseradish flavor
High-quality taste
Great with seafood
Spicy kick
Flavorful and enjoyable
What We Don't Like
Pricey for some
Very spicy for beginners
#TOP 7

Bookbinder's Sauce Cocktail

00271433
Bookbinder's Sauce Cocktail Cover
Bookbinder's Sauce Cocktail, 10.5 oz

Bookbinder's Sauce Cocktail is prepared in a dedicated Gluten-free allergy-friendly facility in the United States. It is a Cocktail Sauce with a package dimension of 4.4cm L x 6.2cm W x 13.9cm H and a weight of 0.65 lb.

What We Like
Great horseradish flavor
Perfect balance of taste
Not overly sweet
Ideal for shrimp dishes
Available online for convenience
What We Don't Like
Size options limited
Not for everyone
#TOP 8

Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce

Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce Cover
Bookbinders Sauce Cocktail

Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce is packaged conveniently in a box measuring 8.2 inches long, 5.9 inches wide, and 5.8 inches high, making it easy to store in your pantry. Weighing 8 pounds, this sauce is substantial enough to last through multiple gatherings or meals. The sauce boasts a rich blend of ingredients, including tomato paste and horseradish, which adds a zesty kick to your dishes. With preservatives included, you can enjoy it without worrying about spoilage, ensuring your meals remain flavorful and safe to eat.

What We Like
Unmatched quality
Enhances shrimp cocktails
Highly recommended
#TOP 9

SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce

0073848825289
8 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce Cover
SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce, 8 FZ

SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce is a gluten-free, jarred condiment that is perfect for adding a savory sweetness to your favorite dishes. Customers love the flavor and texture of this sauce, and many have found it to be better than restaurant-quality. It's a great choice for anyone looking for a delicious and affordable cocktail sauce.

What We Like
Best tasting cocktail sauce
Well-balanced flavors
Nice and thick consistency
Highly recommended by customers
What We Don't Like
Somewhat sweet flavor
Packaging issues with Amazon
#TOP 10

Primal Kitchen Unsweetened Cocktail Sauce

0850004639351
Primal Kitchen Unsweetened Cocktail Sauce Cover
Primal Kitchen Unsweetened Cocktail Sauce, Organic, 8.5 Oz

Primal Kitchen Unsweetened Cocktail Sauce is a Keto Certified, Certified Paleo, and Whole3 Approved condiment made with USDA organic ingredients and unsweetened. It is perfect for seafood dishes like calamari, crab cakes, and more. Customers have mixed reviews, with some loving the taste and others finding it too vinegary. It is a bit pricey for the size, but some customers find it worth it for the sugar-free option.

What We Like
Healthier alternative
Low in carbs
Sugar-free option
Great for shrimp
What We Don't Like
Strong vinegar flavor
Needs more horseradish
Buying Guide Image

The Complete Guide to Buying Cocktail Sauce

Introduction

Cocktail sauce is a condiment often served with seafood, such as shrimp or oysters. It is typically made with ketchup or chili sauce, horseradish, and lemon juice, and can vary in spiciness and flavor depending on the brand and recipe. Choosing the right cocktail sauce can enhance the flavor of your seafood and add an extra layer of complexity to your dish. In this article, we will discuss some key factors to consider when selecting a cocktail sauce.

Consider the Type of Seafood

The type of seafood you are serving can play a role in which cocktail sauce will pair best with it. For example, if you are serving oysters, you may want to choose a cocktail sauce with a milder flavor that will not overpower the delicate flavor of the oysters. On the other hand, if you are serving shrimp, a spicier sauce may be a better match. It's important to consider the flavor profile of the seafood you are serving and choose a cocktail sauce that will complement it.

Look for High-Quality Ingredients

When choosing a cocktail sauce, it's important to look for one made with high-quality ingredients. This will ensure that the sauce has a rich, complex flavor and will not be overwhelmed by artificial preservatives or additives. Some cocktail sauces may contain added sugars, which can make the sauce overly sweet and overpower the flavor of the seafood. It's best to choose a sauce made with natural ingredients and without added sugars.

Consider the Level of Spice

Cocktail sauce can vary in spiciness, with some brands offering milder versions and others offering a more fiery kick. When choosing a cocktail sauce, consider your own personal tolerance for spice and choose a sauce that will suit your taste. If you're not sure how spicy a sauce is, you can always ask a store associate or check the label for heat level information.

Read Reviews and Ask for Recommendations

Another way to choose a cocktail sauce is to read reviews and ask for recommendations from friends, family, or store associates. This can give you an idea of which brands and flavors are popular and which may be worth trying. Additionally, many stores will have samples available, allowing you to try a sauce before you buy it. This can be a great way to discover new flavors and find the perfect sauce for your seafood dish.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing the right cocktail sauce for your seafood can enhance the flavor of your dish and add an extra layer of complexity. Consider the type of seafood you are serving, look for a sauce made with high-quality ingredients, and choose a sauce that suits your personal tolerance for spice. Reading reviews and asking for recommendations can also be helpful when selecting a cocktail sauce. By following these tips, you can find the perfect sauce to complement your seafood dish.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is shrimp cocktail sauce made of?

Shrimp cocktail sauce is made by combining ingredients like ketchup, mild chili sauce, prepared horseradish, fresh lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, and a dash of hot sauce. These ingredients come together to create a tangy and flavorful sauce that pairs well with shrimp.

2. What's good with cocktail sauce?

Cocktail sauce can be paired with various dishes and used in different ways. It can be used to mix Bloody Marys, top ham and cheese omelets, dip deep-fried mushrooms, drizzle on crab cakes, sauce for burgers or hot dogs, dip for mozzarella sticks, top deviled eggs, and even mixed into meatloaf. The versatility of cocktail sauce makes it a tasty addition to many dishes.

3. What is zesty cocktail sauce?

Zesty cocktail sauce, like Heinz Zesty Cocktail Sauce, is a tangy sauce that combines tomato, Worcestershire sauce, horseradish, spices, and more. It has a bolder flavor compared to the original version, with extra horseradish and spices added for an extra kick of flavor. Zesty cocktail sauce is particularly delicious when paired with shrimp.

4. What are the ingredients in Heinz shrimp cocktail sauce?

The ingredients in Heinz shrimp cocktail sauce include tomato concentrate, high fructose corn syrup, distilled white vinegar, horseradish, corn syrup, salt, soybean oil, natural flavorings (contains mustard), dehydrated onions, spices, onion powder, and garlic powder. These ingredients come together to create the flavorful and tangy sauce that is perfect for enjoying with shrimp.

5. What does cocktail sauce taste like?

Cocktail sauce has a bold tomato flavor that is balanced out with acidic ingredients like lemon juice and hot sauce. This combination of flavors creates a tangy and slightly spicy taste that complements the sweetness of fresh shrimp or the brininess of raw oysters. The flavor profile of cocktail sauce enhances the overall enjoyment of seafood dishes.

6. What is Heinz cocktail sauce?

Heinz cocktail sauce is a special blend of spices combined with high-quality ingredients like horseradish and garlic powder. It provides a zesty taste and burst of flavor in every bite. Heinz cocktail sauce is a delicious accompaniment to shrimp and other seafood dishes. It is a low-calorie condiment with no trans fat, making it a guilt-free choice for those watching their calorie intake.

Editor's Notes

During our cocktail sauce research, we found 26 cocktail sauce products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 43,912 customer reviews through our big data system to write the cocktail sauce list. We found that most customers choose cocktail sauce with an average price of $6.92.

The cocktail sauce are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of cocktail sauce, including 365 by Whole Foods Market, BEAVER, OLD BAY, Heinz, St Elmo Steak House. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 385 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!

Cocktail Sauce Comparison Table

#TOP1
#TOP2
#TOP3
#TOP4
#TOP5
#TOP6
#TOP7
#TOP8
#TOP9
#TOP10
Brand 365 by Whole Foods Market BEAVER OLD BAY Heinz Heinz St Elmo Steak House Bookbinder's Bookbinder's Schlotterbeck And Foss Primal Kitchen
Package Information Bottle Bottle Jar Bottle Bottle - Jar Bottle Jar Bottle
Item Weight 0.63 Pounds 13 Ounces 0.99 Pounds 12 Ounces 24 Ounces 16 Ounces 10.4 ounces - 8 ounces 14.5 Ounces
Flavor - Cocktail Sauce horseradish Original Cocktail Original Cocktail Spicy sauce Tomato sauce Organic
Allergen Information Soy Gluten Free - Soy Soy - Gluten Free - Gluten Free Gluten Free
FTB Score
ftb score rating icon 9.8
ftb score rating icon 9.7
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.4
ftb score rating icon 9.2
ftb score rating icon 9.2
ftb score rating icon 9.1
ftb score rating icon 9.1
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 8.8
Where to Buy