Best Honey Mustard of 2025

"This mustard has a strong yellow mustard taste, more than I expected, but I still enjoy it."

"I appreciate the organic quality and great value of this mustard; it's worth trying!"

"While the tangy flavor is just right for my sandwiches and burgers, the watery consistency makes it a bit tricky to use."

"This honey mustard sauce is delicious! I enjoy it with chicken or sausage, and the price is shockingly low. It’s a fantastic dipping sauce!"

"I'm a huge mustard fan! I used to have several types for different foods, but now I only need this one. It has a great viscosity and the perfect balance of mustard flavor without overpowering other tastes. It’s by far the best mustard I've ever had!"

"I absolutely love this mustard! I use it as a low-calorie salad dressing. It strikes a balance between sweetness and mustard flavor that’s hard to find."

"I couldn't find this in grocery stores. The taste is magnificent and the size is just right. It's one of my favorite dipping sauces, and I buy it frequently because the price is right."

"Although it's not as thick as I prefer, I really love the flavor—it tastes great!"

"I got this by accident, thinking it was regular honey mustard for my rotisserie pork. When I tried it with chicken strips, I was blown away. This stuff is amazing—it's like heaven in a bottle!"

“I absolutely love this mustard! It's fantastic with chicken, cheese, and crackers, and it really elevates my sandwiches and so much more.”

“This mustard has a wonderful hot and sweet flavor that enhances my enjoyment of hot sausages and brats. I can't believe I forgot about it!”

“I've been using this mustard for 30 years now! When my local market stopped carrying it, I was so relieved to find it on Amazon.”

"I found this variety years ago and was disappointed when it disappeared from the shelves. It's creamy with a whole grain nuttiness and a slight horseradish kick. Perfect for breakfast or lunch sandwiches, vinaigrettes, and marinades."

"I decided to try this Dijon mustard because of the reviews. As a fan of hot honey, I expected a great combination, but it tasted like regular Dijon to me. I think I'd be better off mixing the two myself."

"After purchasing this product, I can say it tastes very much like McDonald's hot mustard, but even better. It's amazing on homemade snack wraps and pairs well with nuggets."

"This mustard is so delicious! As I age, I find strong flavors harder to handle, but this one is just too good to resist. Mixing it with mayo creates an amazing dipping sauce!"

"I’m really impressed with the taste. It’s nice and creamy with just the right amount of dill, not overwhelming the mustard flavor. I’ve found my new favorite dill mustard!"

"I’ve never tasted anything like it, but I’m in love! It’s fantastic on fish and vegetables..."

"I've been buying this mustard for over five years. It adds an extra zing to everything!"

"This honey mustard is the only one I buy! It's thicker and creamier than others, perfect for sandwiches and hot dogs!"

"My family in England can’t find it anymore, so they always take some back when they visit. It's very flavorful!"

"I was excited to stock up on Guldens mustard with the 12 pack. It's a great middle ground—not too bland and not overwhelmingly bold."

"After years of sticking to another brand, I finally tried this mustard and ended up buying a full case! It's officially my new go-to mustard."

"This honey mustard is by far the best value I've ever tasted, but I was disappointed when it recently disappeared from stores. I didn’t mind ordering a full case from Amazon!"

"I used to buy a different honey mustard, but since they stopped making it, I decided to try this honey mustard dressing. It tastes just like McDonald's, which I absolutely love! I dip my chicken in it and even smother my grilled ham and Swiss with it!"

"Following my cardiac surgery, I'm on a low sodium diet. I find it interesting that the low-cal version has more sodium than the regular one. I prefer the regular version and keep one at home and one in my office fridge. I wish they offered smaller bottles, but it's not a major issue."

"This honey mustard is simply the best I've ever tasted. I will definitely keep replacing it every time. The flavor is fantastic, the size is great, and it arrived very quickly!"

"I misread the number of ounces and was shocked at the huge size. I have plenty of friends who will enjoy this delicious spread. If you have a large family, you will be happy with the size and price."

"We really enjoy this mustard. After trying many, I found this one has just the right amount of sweetness—not too sweet and very flavorful."

"I bought the largest jug I could find because running out is not an option. It's even bigger than I expected, so I adjusted my subscription. I hope I didn't mess up and buy not enough, but I will never run out—you can't go wrong with French's."