Best Fruit Butters of 2025

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 15, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Fruit butters are a delicious and versatile spread made from cooked fruit and sugar. Unlike traditional jams or jellies, fruit butters are cooked for a longer period of time, resulting in a smooth and creamy texture. They can be used in a variety of ways, from spreading on toast or biscuits to adding flavor to baked goods or even as a topping for ice cream. Popular fruit butter flavors include apple, pumpkin, and pear, but many other fruits can be used as well. Fruit butters are a great way to add a burst of fruity sweetness to any dish.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Green Jay Gourmet Peach Butter Cover #TOP 1
Green Jay Gourmet Peach Butter
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Langer Farms Unsweetened Apple Butter 16oz Cover #TOP 2
Langer Farms Unsweetened Apple Butter 16oz
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz Cover #TOP 3
Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Fruit Butters

#TOP 1

Green Jay Gourmet Peach Butter

Green Jay Gourmet Peach Butter Cover
Green Jay Gourmet Peach Butter - All-Natural, Gluten-Free Fruit Spread - Peach Spread with Peaches & Spices - Gourmet Fruit Butter - No Corn Syrup, Preservatives or Trans-Fats - 19 Ounces

Indulge in the rich, creamy, and fruity taste of Green Jay Peach Butter - the gourmet fruit butter that brings a new way to experience peaches. Made from all-natural, gluten-free real food ingredients, this fruit spread contains no corn syrup, preservatives, or trans-fats. Green Jay Peach Butter is cooked carefully in small batches, making it a better butter that can replace the same-old, boring butter. With subtle hints of secret spices, it is perfect to spread on crumble bars, cinnamon rolls, croissants, and grilled chicken. Green Jay Peach Butter is responsibly sourced and made in the USA, giving you nothing but the best.

What We Like
Delicious flavor variety
Great texture
Versatile for different uses
Good value for price
Brings nostalgia
What We Don't Like
Too sweet for some
Chunky texture
#TOP 2

Langer Farms Unsweetened Apple Butter 16oz

Langer Farms Unsweetened Apple Butter 16oz Cover
Langer Farms Unsweetened Apple Butter, 16oz, Packaging May Vary

Langer Farms Apple Butter is a delicious option for those seeking a naturally sweet fruit spread. Being unsweetened means you can enjoy it without added sugars, making it a healthier choice for your diet. This product is 100% plant-based, perfect for anyone following a vegan lifestyle. Additionally, it's both dairy-free and gluten-free, ensuring that it fits into various dietary restrictions. Whether you're spreading it on toast or using it in recipes, this apple butter offers a wholesome and tasty alternative to traditional spreads.

What We Like
Natural apple flavor
No added sugars
Versatile use
Wholesome ingredients
Great texture
What We Don't Like
Inconsistent jar condition
Potential packaging issues
#TOP 3

Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz

Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz Cover
Manischewitz Apple Butter, 17oz | Smooth & Sweet Spread, Great for Sauces & Glazes, No Sugar Added

Manischewitz Apple Butter is a delicious fruit butter made with just two simple ingredients, and cooked long and slow to produce a rich, dark brown sauce. Naturally sweet with no added sugar, this smooth and jam-like spread is perfect for dipping biscuits, spreading thickly on toast, or topping your favorite cake. Add it to your favorite sauces and glazes for a deliciously sweet and tangy flavor. Kosher certified for year-round use, this apple butter is a healthier way to enjoy a sweet pleasure.

What We Like
Pure apple flavor
Low-calorie option
Versatile culinary use
Flavorful addition
Low in sugar
What We Don't Like
Occasional bland taste
Packaging issues
#TOP 4

Amish Valley Apple Butter

Amish Valley Apple Butter Cover
Amish Valley Products Apple Butter Glass Jar Old Fashioned Homestyle Slow Cooked (No Corn Syrup)

Amish Valley Apple Butter offers a delightful taste of homemade goodness. Made in Ohio’s Amish Country, this 16 oz glass jar contains all-natural ingredients, ensuring you enjoy a pure and wholesome product. The slow-cooked process enhances the rich flavor, making it perfect for spreading on toast or adding to recipes. This apple butter also makes for a thoughtful gift for teachers, hosts, or friends, allowing you to share a piece of traditional Amish craftsmanship. With its simple and delicious ingredients, you can feel good about enjoying this sweet treat.

What We Like
Delicious flavor
Perfect consistency
Homemade taste
Great for cooking
Affordable small jars
What We Don't Like
Inconsistent packaging
Slightly expensive
#TOP 5

Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack

6 Piece Set
Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack Cover
Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack (6 pack)| Apple Butter, Pumpkin Butter, No Sugar Added Organic Apple Butter, Cherry Butter, Peach Butter, Pear Butter|

Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack includes Apple Butter, Cherry Butter, Organic Apple Butter, Peach Butter, Pear Butter & Pumpkin Butter. With clean ingredients and real fruit as the number one ingredient, this product is GMO and gluten-free. It can be a perfect housewarming gift that reminds you of the smell of grandma's kitchen when she made homemade apple butter. Made in the USA in an allergen-free facility certified by Safe Quality Food.

What We Like
Delicious flavors
Great variety
Well-packaged for shipping
Perfect for gifts
Good value for price
What We Don't Like
Inconsistent texture
Some products not as expected
#TOP 6

Eden Organic Apple Butter Spread, No Sugar Added

024182000696
Eden Organic Apple Butter Spread, No Sugar Added Cover
Eden Organic Apple Butter Spread, No Sugar Added, Great Lakes Apples, Slow Kettle Simmered, 17 oz Glass Jar

The Eden Organic Apple Butter Spread is a versatile, tangy sweet spread that is perfect for healthy eating. Made with a blend of organic apples, slowly kettle cooked with a bit of organic apple juice concentrate, this spread contains no refined sugars, additives or preservatives. It can be spread on bread, muffins, pancakes, and waffles, or used in baking. It is organic, Kosher and pareve, vegan, wheat-free, gluten-free, low calorie, sodium, and fat-free.

What We Like
No added sugar
Delicious taste
Thick and creamy texture
Versatile usage
Sturdy packaging
What We Don't Like
Molds quickly in fridge
Pricey for short shelf life
#TOP 7

Tennessee's Best No Sugar Added Apple Butter

2 Count (Pack of 1)
Tennessee's Best No Sugar Added Apple Butter Cover
Tennessee's Best Fruit Butters | Handcrafted in Small Batches with Real Fruit | All Natural-Gluten Free| Just Like Moma Used to Make! (No Sugar Added Apple Butter Two Pack)

Tennessee's Best Apple Butter is crafted with high-quality ingredients to deliver exceptional flavor. You can enjoy it on your favorite breakfast items like toast, biscuits, pancakes, or waffles. It also makes a delicious filling for fried pies or a delightful layer in stack cakes. With no preservatives or artificial flavors, you can feel good about what you're eating. For over 25 years, this apple butter has been a beloved family choice, ensuring that each jar brings a taste of homemade goodness right to your table.

What We Like
Delicious apple flavor
Great texture and spreadability
Sugar-free option available
Fast shipping
What We Don't Like
A bit runny
#TOP 8

Amish Wedding Blackberry Butter, 2 Jars

Amish Wedding Blackberry Butter, 2 Jars Cover
Amish Wedding Premium Blackberry Butter, TWO 16 oz. Jars

Amish Wedding Blackberry Butter is set to redefine your taste experience. This delicious fruit butter spread pairs perfectly with a variety of dishes, including cobblers, scones, and even grilled chicken, adding a unique twist to your meals. You can enjoy it on cakes and muffins for an extra touch of sweetness. Importantly, this product contains no high fructose corn syrup or dairy butter, making it a healthier choice for those looking to avoid these ingredients. With its rich flavor, this blackberry butter is a delightful addition to your pantry.

What We Like
Unique flavor enhancement
Versatile usage options
No high fructose corn syrup
Healthier alternative to butter
#TOP 9

Stonewall Kitchen Maple Pumpkin Butter

161003
orange
Stonewall Kitchen Maple Pumpkin Butter Cover
Stonewall Kitchen Maple Pumpkin Butter, 12.25 Ounce

Stonewall Maple Pumpkin Butter is a must-have in the pantry. This sweet mixture of maple and pumpkin can be used to spice up any recipe or enjoyed straight from the jar. Whether you're looking to add a unique flavor to your favorite dishes or simply enjoy a delicious spread, this butter is perfect. It can be used as an ingredient in various recipes, adding a touch of sweetness and richness. Made with premium ingredients, Stonewall Maple Pumpkin Butter is expertly crafted to bring you the best in specialty foods and fine home living.

What We Like
Delicious flavor combinations
High-quality ingredients
Pairs well with various foods
Great for baking
Unique taste experience
What We Don't Like
A bit too sweet for some
Texture like baby food
#TOP 10

Eden Organic Cherry Butter

024182000788
8 Ounce (Pack of 1)
Eden Organic Cherry Butter Cover
Eden Organic Cherry Butter, 8 oz Glass Jar, Montmorency Tart Cherries

Eden Organic Cherry Butter is a nutrient-rich cherry butter that comes in 8 oz Glass Jar. The cherry butter is made from four pounds of Michigan organic Montmorency Tart Cherries and is kettle simmered to a tangy spread with no water, sugar, or additives. It contains at least seventeen beneficial antioxidants and has a Brix of 56. Eden Foods is a principled natural food company, est. 1968, that uses healthy soil, long-term organic, non-GMO, skilled growers and handlers to offer a reliable alternative to commercial food.

What We Like
Delicious, pure cherry flavor
All-natural ingredients
Organic and medicinal benefits
Versatile for various uses
Good quality product
What We Don't Like
Somewhat expensive
Slightly tart for some tastes
Buying Guide Image

Finding the Best Fruit Butters for You

Introduction

When it comes to choosing fruit butters, there are several factors to consider. From the type of fruit used to the texture and consistency, the options can seem endless. In this article, we'll provide some helpful tips for choosing the perfect fruit butter for your taste preferences and needs.

Types of Fruit Butters

One of the first things to consider when choosing a fruit butter is the type of fruit used. Some common options include apple, peach, and strawberry. Each fruit has its own unique flavor and texture, so be sure to choose a type that appeals to your taste preferences.

Additionally, some fruit butters may be made with a blend of different fruits. This can add a layer of complexity to the flavor and can be a great option if you enjoy trying new flavor combinations.

Consistency and Texture

Another important factor to consider when choosing a fruit butter is the consistency and texture. Some fruit butters may be smooth and spreadable, while others may be chunkier and more spreadable. Consider how you plan to use the fruit butter and choose a consistency that will work best for your needs.

Additionally, some fruit butters may be made with added ingredients, such as nuts or spices. These ingredients can add depth to the flavor and can also change the texture of the fruit butter. Be sure to read the ingredient list and choose a fruit butter that has a consistency and texture that you enjoy.

Flavor

Of course, the most important factor to consider when choosing a fruit butter is the flavor. Take the time to taste several different options and choose a fruit butter that has a flavor that you love. Don't be afraid to try new flavors and experiment with different combinations to find the perfect fruit butter for your taste preferences.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing the perfect fruit butter involves considering several factors, including the type of fruit used, the consistency and texture, and the flavor. By taking the time to consider these factors, you can choose a fruit butter that is sure to be a delicious addition to your meals and snacks.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What are the different types of fruit butter?

There are various types of fruit butter available, including apple butter, pumpkin butter, pear butter, plum butter, strawberry butter, and more. Each type offers a unique flavor and can be made using trusted recipes and cooking tips.

2. Are fruit butters healthy?

Fruit butters are generally considered healthier than store-bought jams or jellies because they contain less sugar. To make them even healthier, you can choose to add no sugar or use natural sweeteners like honey. The level of sweetness can be adjusted according to personal preference.

3. Does fruit butter need to be refrigerated?

Yes, it is recommended to refrigerate fruit butter, especially after opening the jar, to extend its shelf life. Leaving it at room temperature for a prolonged period may affect its taste and quality.

4. How long is homemade fruit butter good for?

Homemade fruit butter can last for one to two weeks in the refrigerator. It can also be frozen using freezer-safe packaging for longer storage. Some fruit butters can also be preserved using the water bath canning method.

5. What is the shelf life of fruit butter?

Unopened fruit butter, like apple butter, can last for 12-18 months when stored in a cool, dry pantry. Refrigerating it can extend its shelf life, and freezing it can keep it good for up to two years.

6. What do you use fruit butter for?

Fruit butter can be used in various ways: spread it on toast, swirl it into yogurt for a delicious breakfast, or incorporate it into baking recipes. Its smooth and spreadable texture makes it a versatile and tasty ingredient.

7. What are fruit butters good on?

Fruit butters, such as apple butter, can be enjoyed on bread, toast, muffins, or any other baked goods. They serve as a sweet and flavorful substitute for butter and can be made from a variety of firm fruits.

Editor's Notes

During our fruit butter research, we found 24 fruit butter products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 21,761 customer reviews through our big data system to write the fruit butters list. We found that most customers choose fruit butters with an average price of $18.15.

The fruit butters are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of fruit butters, including Green Jay Gourmet, Langer Farms, Manischewitz, AMISH VALLEY PRODUCTS, Dillman Farm. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 1,163 consumers with an average rating of 4.9.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!

Fruit Butters Comparison Table

#TOP1
#TOP2
#TOP3
#TOP4
#TOP5
#TOP6
#TOP7
#TOP8
#TOP9
#TOP10
Brand Green Jay Gourmet Langer Farms Manischewitz AMISH VALLEY PRODUCTS Dillman Farm Eden Tennessee's Best Amish Wedding Stonewall Kitchen Eden
Flavor Peach Apple Apple,Butter,Sweet Regular Apple,Butter,Peach,Cherry,Pumpkin Apple No Sugar Added Apple Butter Two Pack Blackberry Maple Pumpkin Butter,Cherry
Item Weight 19 Ounces 1 Pounds 17 Ounces 16 Ounces 9.4 Pounds 17 Ounces 16 ounces 16 Ounces 12.25 Ounces 8 ounces
Package Information - Jar - - - Jar Bottle Jar jar Jar
FTB Score
ftb score rating icon 9.8
ftb score rating icon 9.7
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.3
ftb score rating icon 9.2
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 9.0
ftb score rating icon 8.8
ftb score rating icon 8.7
Where to Buy