Best Allspice of 2026

"This allspice brings a perfect, comforting flavor to everything from cookies to chili, and even coffee. The cinnamon-nutmeg-clove mix fills my kitchen with joy. The jar size is ideal and lasts a long time since you only need a little. I highly recommend it for anyone who wants to add flavor and warmth to their cooking."

"I picked this up for my holiday baking and was thrilled with the excellent price compared to local grocery stores. It's just what I needed for my recipes and makes baking even better!"

"As someone who loves to cook, I sometimes forget how many layers of flavor allspice can add. This brand really impressed me with its freshness and sophisticated flavor profile—it brought back great memories of past dishes. Truly a great choice for any chef."

"I used this blend to brine a venison roast for a week, and it turned out to be the best corned meat I've ever tasted. It far surpasses any store-bought corned beef, so this is definitely my new go-to seasoning."

"I really enjoy using this to season boiled shrimp; it makes them taste just like the classic shrimp boil I remember. This product brings back that traditional flavor."

"I made a batch of pickles and found this spice mix gave them a wonderful flavor. While there was a touch more clove than I prefer, the quality and quantity are outstanding for the price, and it'll last me a long time."

"Once I ground it, the fresh scent filled my kitchen. The large grains are impressive and the cost is a great deal. Plus, I love that I can reuse the bottle."

"This spice is essential for my autumn blends—arrived full of flavor and really made a difference in my recipes."

"I used it for Jerk Chicken and it turned out fantastic! I was so happy with it that I just placed another order."

"I've found that McCormick Ground Allspice always delivers a fresh, aromatic quality that perfectly complements both sweet and savory dishes. I especially enjoy using it to create Mexican spiced coffee creamer, where it pairs wonderfully with my other spices and cocoa."

"For over a decade, I've counted on this allspice for my Christmas fruit cakes and puddings. The freshness and aroma are always spot-on, and the price is quite reasonable. It also works great in everyday cooking."

"Even though I only use allspice occasionally, the small container size is just right for keeping it fresh. While McCormick can be a bit pricier, I appreciate that it's never stale or adulterated—and the packaging is perfect for stacking and storage."

"I was surprised by the large amount of fresh allspice berries I received for the price. They're perfect for my simmer pots, and the aroma fills my home beautifully. I also appreciate how well the packaging keeps everything fresh."

"I actually bought these allspice berries for an art project, and they worked out perfectly for my Christmas spice trees. I still have plenty left to use for decoration!"

"Every time I order spices from this seller, I can count on freshness and careful packaging. The price is fair, and the quality keeps me coming back."

"I found these allspice berries to be fresh and exactly what I needed for my Thanksgiving turkey brine. The flavor was clear and there weren’t any odd pieces. They’re solid quality—not extraordinary, but I’d definitely purchase them again if I run out."

"I use these allspice berries for my homemade pickles and they provide a wonderful, aromatic flavor to every batch. The scent when opening the bag is like Christmas in the kitchen! The bag is large and lasts a long time, even after several rounds of pickling. I’m looking forward to trying them in other recipes and even in holiday potpourri."

"These allspice berries are fresh and fragrant, perfect for my mulled wine. They added just the right touch to my recipe, and I couldn’t ask for more from a spice."

"I love how fresh and aromatic this cinnamon is—perfect for my cooking, and a great value so I use it often."

"I'm happy knowing this is lead-free cinnamon at a good price, plus it's easy to grab locally."

"The cinnamon arrived quickly and it's very flavorful. I'm glad Amazon offers a larger size for frequent use."

"I was impressed by the fresh, fragrant aroma as soon as I opened the package. These allspice berries worked perfectly in my mulled cider, delivering a wonderful taste."

"I use these whole allspice berries for my Thanksgiving cranberry sauce, and the flavor is fantastic. The bulk amount means I'll have plenty for new recipes, too."

"Finding whole allspice berries locally is tough, but my order arrived quickly and the berries smelled incredibly fresh even before I tried them."

"I started buying these spices after seeing them recommended by America's Test Kitchen, and I have to say, the flavor is outstanding. I've tried several varieties and each one has been consistently high-quality. I definitely plan to stick with this brand for the long haul."

"As someone who uses allspice in my morning oatmeal, I can honestly say this is the freshest allspice I've come across. It really enhances the flavor of my breakfast."

"Whenever I'm shopping for spices, I go for Simply Organic because they're always fresh and I know the flavor will match the aroma when I open the jar."

"I was truly impressed by the unique Jamaican spice flavor this product added to my dishes. I even blended the berries to make a convenient shake-on spice — it really elevated my meals."

"As a first-time user, I found that this product brought an incredible depth of flavor to my cooking that I hadn't experienced before."

"These were perfect for my snowman craft project — exactly what I hoped for. They arrived in excellent condition, right on schedule."