Best Allspice of 2025

"I loved the freshness of this spice, perfect for my peach pies!"

"Amazon saved the day! I couldn't find any brand in stores, but this one didn't disappoint. It tastes good and made my food delicious!"

"Finding allspice online at a reasonable price was a game-changer for me. The delicious smell is just an added bonus!"

"I absolutely love these spices, especially during this season. I keep a pot simmering, and my home smells like I’m baking. They’re perfect in cider for mulled cider. The packaging seals tight, keeping everything fresh!"

"For the price, this is great value. I appreciate the functional packaging and the quantity is impressive. I’m using these for some simmer pot gifts."

"I need to start using this spice more; it smells so good! I have plenty for the holidays, and I find it much better to have whole spices than ground."

"I find the taste to be excellent and the smell is quite pungent. The quality is very high and it's incredibly fresh. Overall, it offers great value for the size."

"This product is awesome! My mom used it for kibbeh, and I got a pound for about $9, which is much better than the small cans I usually see for $5 for just a few ounces. Amazon has fantastic prices on bulk spices that can be tricky to find in stores."

"I absolutely love this product! I only rated it 4 stars because it didn't arrive as promised; it was delivered a day late. Otherwise, I would have given it 5 stars!"

"I really appreciate the convenience of having my products delivered right to my door. As an older person with some mobility issues, it makes my life so much easier. Just a small request: please ask the delivery folks to place my items behind my potted plants, as we have issues with porch pirates stealing deliveries."

"I've tried other spice brands without any issues, but I was disappointed to find that this particular spice had expired in February 2020. I didn't realize it was non-returnable. A lesson learned for me!"

"When I received my order, the seal was broken on the bottle. It was quite unpleasant to open it and find it unsealed. I wasn't happy about this experience."

"This is a first for me; it seems like the packaging has melted due to the high temperatures. Not what I expected!"

"I find the size perfect for spices I don't use often."

"This is the right spice for Hurricanes—delicious!"

"I used it as a cinnamon substitute in my rolls since I'm allergic."

“I create small batch handcrafted spice blends, and the potency of these spices is much better than what I find in the local supermarket. My wife noticed the wonderful aroma immediately after I opened the bag.”

“I mix these allspice berries with other spices, and they smell wonderful! They add such a great touch to my recipes.”

“I was thrilled to find these whole allspice berries, as it’s become impossible to locate them locally. The robustness of these berries is impressive, and the price is excellent.”

“I can't find a size this big locally. Great product!”

“The spice has great flavor and is money-saving since I cook with it frequently.”

“This is the best! McCormick delivers top quality and is a trusted U.S. brand at a great price. I'm sold!”

"I absolutely love the fresh fragrant smell and warm flavor this adds to my cooking. It really makes my homemade pumpkin spice mix next level."

"I'm very pleased to have found this 4 oz. package at such a great price. It will definitely last a long time for me."

"Allspice usually comes in tiny containers and is expensive. I'm thrilled to get a larger package like this, and I prefer the bag over plastic. I would definitely buy again."

"I found a fantastic recipe for apple cider on the Pioneer Woman website that required these. They arrived quickly and worked perfectly for the recipe; the cider turned out great!"

"This product serves my purpose well, and it's become a continuous reorder item for me."

"I was thrilled with this purchase; the allspice berries were very fresh and aromatic, especially since I've had trouble finding them in stores lately."

"I absolutely loved this spice! The smell is delightful and it works well on oatmeal, yogurt, and toast."

"I’ve always appreciated Spice Island products. They’re consistently potent and flavorful. The price on Amazon was less than half of what I found locally."

"The smell and taste are heavenly! I’ve added it to my coffee, yogurt, and toast, and I’m excited to try it in my oatmeal. I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking to add some positivity to their meals!"