Best Dessert Pies of 2025

"I found this pudding to be excellent in taste, especially after not having time to steam one myself this year. Although it's smaller than what I'm used to, I really enjoyed the high-quality ingredients and the good texture. I plan to whip up some Creme Anglaise to serve with it!"

"This cake is truly what every fruit cake strives to be. It's dense and lightly sweet with just enough booze for flavor. I loved the dried cherries and found it hard not to finish it all at once, though the almonds on top weren't my favorite texture."

"I was on the lookout for a rich Christmas cake like the ones from my childhood, and this one was simply amazing. The combination of candied fruit and peels was delightful, and I will definitely be ordering it again!"

"I was truly impressed by the freshness and quality of these little pies. I sent them as a gift to my mother, who adores mince meat pies, and she couldn't stop raving about them all Christmas! They are perfectly sized for the rich filling and are delectable. The packaging was beautiful, and they arrived right on time for the holiday. I highly recommend them!"

"When my British daughter-in-law asked for mince meat pies for Christmas morning, I knew I had to deliver. Her eyes lit up when she saw these tarts, and I felt I had done well! They hit the spot perfectly for her!"

"I think these tarts are really tasty and worth every penny spent! Though a few had damaged pie shells, I understand they traveled all the way from Scotland. The taste is simply incredible!"

"I could easily devour 10 of these pies daily! Forget Hostess and their boring flavors. JJ's Pies are incredible! The Banana Cream Pies are a gift from the Almighty! I plan to buy more and explore their great flavors like Peach, Cherry, and Boston Cream. Thank you, JJ's, for offering a legit selection!"

"I had high hopes for these pies after finding them online, but they arrived soggy and tasteless. The filling was almost solid, and I was disappointed. I’ll stick to buying from local outlets instead of ordering online again."

"I took a chance on these pies because I remember loving Hostess Pies as a kid. The packaging is solid for freshness, and I was pleased with the quality. I’ve ordered twice and plan on ordering again. Different tastes mean reviews can vary, but I think they’re worth it!"

"I absolutely love these pies; they remind me of Hostess lemon pies that are hard to find now!"

"I was quite disappointed with the quality of my pies. The filling was a black paste, not berries, and the crust was too hard to cut. I found the sugar coating unhealthy and ended up throwing it away."

"When I first ordered, I wasn't sure what to expect. After trying them, I found them to be pretty good. They weren't stale or overly moist. I recommend refrigerating them for a better taste."

"I was really impressed with the excellent customer service and the fact that it's a non-profit giving back to the community!"

"Unfortunately, my pie arrived broken and the crust was burnt and soggy. It didn't resemble the picture at all, and I found it quite pricey for an apple pie."

"I'm pretty sure something this good is illegal! Even though it didn't arrive in one piece, the taste was so wonderful that I didn't mind the mishap. You HAVE to try this pie!"

"I was truly impressed that these arrived perfectly with not one crumb out of place. The gorgeous packaging with embossed snowflakes made me hesitate to throw away the box. We enjoyed these wonderful little pies on Christmas morning with tea, and they would also be a delightful treat between courses or right after dinner. Overall, they are a fantastic treat and would make an excellent gift. Ours were fresh and delicious!"

"My daughter surprised me with some boxes of these mini pies, and I find them absolutely scrumptious! I had been disappointed about not finding mince pies in local stores, as they were a staple during the holidays when I was growing up. These pies brought back bittersweet memories. The crust is buttery and flaky, and the filling is both sweet and savory. I would definitely buy these again!"

"These mini mince pies taste great, especially when I heat them up in an air fryer. The crust is nice, and while the filling is tasty, I feel there's not enough filling in them, creating pockets of air. However, they are still enjoyable."

"My first experience with the pie wasn’t great, but when I got home from work today, I found a beautifully packed box with another pie. I’m so embarrassed that I’m speechless. I will definitely buy from this company again!"

"I was really excited to try the Muslim Bean Pies that I used to enjoy from the Brothers on the street corners, but sadly, this pie didn’t match my memories. It wasn’t bad, but I was hoping for something greater. I probably won’t purchase it again, although it might appeal to others."

"I wanted to bring a unique dish to my office potluck. I remembered a pie that tasted like sweet potato pie but had a better texture. I ordered it, and it was everything I remembered and more. Everyone in the office loved it too!"

"I found them to be perfect for adding a touch of mincemeat for Christmas! They were fresh and flavorful!"

"I received these very quickly; they were fresh and tasty upon arrival."

"I was a bit surprised by their size; they are tiny pies, but I enjoyed the good taste and crispy patty."

"I’ve always wanted to try Shoofly pie, so I finally took the plunge and ordered some. The pies arrived earlier than expected and tasted incredibly fresh, just like I had bought them in person. I enjoyed one at room temperature (which was delicious), but I preferred it cold after refrigerating. I was initially worried about the sweetness, thinking it might be overwhelming like pecan pie, but it turned out to be mildly sweet and absolutely delightful. The crust was perfectly tasty, which is crucial since many pies lack a good crust. Even days later, the pie tasted as fresh as the day I received it. I highly recommend buying the two-pack to save money, as it's essentially like getting a second pie for free! This is definitely my new favorite pie!"

"I completely forgot how wonderful wet-bottom shoofly pie could be. These pies are simply amazing! They are handmade with care, and the crust is just as good as the filling. Don't let the ingredients scare you off; this pie is nothing like cough syrup! It’s more like a coffee-crumb cake treat, perfect with a hot cup of coffee. I love to gift these pies as an alternative to the usual Thanksgiving desserts, but they are a bit pricey, so I choose my recipients wisely!"

"I wanted to love these pies. They arrived quickly and looked great, but sadly, they just didn't taste right. The ones I've had in the past, especially from my PA Dutch in-laws, had a much stronger molasses flavor, while these tasted more like corn syrup. They were a bit pale in color, and I was hoping for something richer. Unfortunately, I won’t be ordering these again."