Best Dessert Pies of 2026

"I sent these cookies as a gift to my aunt and was thrilled with how beautifully wrapped they were and how fresh they stayed thanks to the extra cellophane. She said they tasted scrumptious and gourmet, with high-quality chocolate and nuts. I’m extremely happy with my choice!"

"When I opened the packaging, the delicious cookie aroma hit me right away. These are fresh, decorated Oreo cookies—the perfect treat if you like something special!"

"I got these as Christmas gifts for my nephews and they couldn’t wait to try them. Both the kids and their mom loved the cookies, especially paired with hot cocoa. They were a big hit!"

"I've tried several mince pies, and these stand out for their deliciously crumbly shortbread crust and well-balanced spiced filling. The mini size lets me enjoy them as a daily treat during the holidays. They aren't overly sweet, which I appreciate, and they're now my go-to festive snack. I'll definitely be reordering next year!"

"These pies are just right for Yuletide snacking. They're flavorful and small enough to enjoy after a big holiday meal without feeling overindulgent. The taste captures the spirit of the season and they're a welcome addition to my Christmas table."

"I usually bake my own mince pies, but this year I chose these instead. The shortbread crust is a big hit in my house, and the filling is tasty, though I did notice some air pockets inside. Overall, they're a great alternative when I don't have time to bake from scratch."

"As someone who grew up enjoying mince pies during the holidays, I was thrilled to find these. The mincemeat is soft and juicy, surrounded by a wonderful shortbread crust. For anyone craving a nostalgic taste of home, these are a must-have for the festive season."

"I decided to try these since it's been a while since I last had mincemeat. The crust is reminiscent of their classic shortbread cookies, and the mincemeat is among the best commercially available. The only downside was that a few arrived broken, but the taste made up for it. I'll be buying these again next year."

"I was curious about these tarts and found that they're sweet and have a cookie-like crust, almost like a Fig Newton. While I wish there was a stronger mincemeat flavor, they're still a nice treat and don't spike my blood sugar. A bit pricey, but enjoyable for a holiday indulgence."

"These are truly delicious, with a pastry that melts in your mouth and a filling that's just right. I'll definitely be buying them again!"

"I love Walker's Shortbread and mincemeat pies, so these little tarts seemed perfect. They arrived in great condition, but unfortunately, the filling was dry and hard, and there was a noticeable metallic taste—I ended up tossing them. It was a real disappointment given their potential."

"Walker's shortbread is always top-notch quality, but I found the mincemeat filling a bit too sweet, and the crust wasn't as tender as I'd hoped. If you like classic mincemeat, you might prefer homemade or frozen over these shelf-stable ones."

"I always look forward to these mince pies during the holidays. The crust is so crunchy and almost like a shortbread cookie, which means they hold up really well in transit. They're rich enough that just one completely satisfies my sweet tooth, and even though I wish there was a bit more filling, they're absolutely worth it. Definitely my favorite holiday treat from overseas!"

"I was worried these wouldn't satisfy my craving for mince pies, but wow, these blew me away! The crust tastes like a cookie, and when I added ice cream, it was even better. I'll definitely be ordering these again. So, so delicious!"

"I sent these to my dad, who loves mincemeat pies, and he and my mom were thrilled. They both said the tarts were a generous size, tasted amazing, and even froze well for later. If you know someone who misses mincemeat pies around the holidays, these are a perfect and tasty gift."

"I decided to give these a try after reading many mixed reviews, and I was genuinely surprised by how delicious and satisfying they still are. The crust has that perfect texture and the apple filling is just right—maybe a little less than before, but still plenty for me. If you’re an apple pie fan like me, these are a great pick. I’ve already ordered more!"

"These pies bring back memories, and honestly, I think they taste just like they did years ago, though they might be a bit sweeter. The crust is even better than I remember, and the price for a pack is very reasonable. Don’t let negative reviews fool you—these are still a good value and taste great."

"The pies are good but a little too sweet for my taste. They still make for a tasty treat, but I wish they weren’t quite as sugary."

"I’m thrilled by the amazing flavor selection JJ’s offers—especially the banana cream, which is an absolute favorite of mine! Hostess can’t compete with this variety. Each pie is delicious, and I love that I’m not stuck with just cherry or apple. Banana Cream is a true standout—I’m definitely buying more."

"I came across these pies when my usual Hostess and Little Debbie options were unavailable. Unfortunately, I found the banana creme pies disappointing. The texture was off, almost like undercooked dough, and the filling reminded me of toothpaste—very artificial. If you’re looking for strong banana flavor, you might be let down. I wish I’d read more reviews before ordering."

"I took a chance on JJ’s because I grew up loving Hostess pies and was hoping these would be similar. The crust brought back nostalgic memories—dense and chewy, just like I remembered. The banana filling was clearly banana, but not too strong, which I liked. Though the price was a bit high, I’ll still order again because the packaging keeps them fresh and they hit that sweet spot."

"I had an issue with my order just before Christmas, but when I called, their team went above and beyond to fix it immediately. They shipped a replacement pie in time for my holiday dinner and even let me keep the extra pecans as a bonus. The pie was delicious and loaded with pecans. I’m truly impressed with their outstanding customer service!"

"This pecan pie was one of the best store-bought pies I’ve ever had. The crust was perfect, and the sweetness was just right for me. It was packed with plenty of tasty pecans and disappeared quickly at home."

"My Heaton Pecan pie brought back memories of my grandmother’s baking. It was rich in flavor, beautifully packaged, and included clear instructions. It’s definitely going to be a new holiday tradition in my family."

"I was so impressed by how flaky and delicious the crusts are for gluten-free pastry—it honestly tastes just like the real thing! Even though they're a bit pricey, especially with shipping, the flavor makes it worth it as a treat. Katz Bakery has definitely won me over."

"I had a minor issue with my order and received the wrong items, but Katz's customer service was amazing—they quickly fixed the mistake and even let me keep the extra products as a gift. The pies are just the right size for sharing and taste fantastic. It's so hard to find good gluten-free desserts in my area, so I'll definitely be back for more."

"I was expecting a lot, but the fruit filling was more like a thick jelly and the crust was quite dense with a strange aftertaste. I understand the challenges with shipping, but it really needs more fruit or some moisture to balance all the crust."