Best Bakery & Dessert Gifts of 2026

"I wanted to surprise my neighbor with a Christmas gift, and having enjoyed Barnett's before, I knew it would be perfect. The classy presentation and sturdy, crisp biscotti make for a delightful treat, especially with coffee or tea."

"I sent this to a friend as a present, and they raved about how delicious and enjoyable the biscotti were. It's always great to hear the gift was appreciated!"

"I picked up the 12-piece chocolate box for a holiday celebration, and I was impressed by the beautiful packaging and the decadent assortment of flavors. The chocolates felt gourmet, and the box made an ideal gift for friends and family."

"I sent this box of cookies as a gift to my aunt, and she was delighted. The presentation was stunning, with extra cellophane to keep them fresh. She raved about the scrumptious, soft cookie sandwiches filled with premium chocolate and nuts. I couldn't be happier with my purchase."

"The moment I unwrapped the box, the aroma of fresh cookies was incredible. They tasted amazing and were beautifully decorated—an ideal treat for anyone who loves fancy Oreo-style cookies."

"I bought these cookies for my nephews at Christmas, and they were so excited they tore the package open right away! Their mom made hot cocoa and joined in, and everyone agreed the cookies were delicious and fun."

"I was really impressed by the delicious assortment and beautiful presentation of this box. The baked goods were absolutely enjoyable, and the packaging made it feel special. I'll definitely be ordering again!"

"I sent this as a Christmas present to my sister, and she told me she loved it. It made for a wonderful gift and was very well received. Thank you for making her holiday so sweet!"

"I bought two of these baskets as gifts—one each for my mom and daughter. They both said the treats were delicious and the packaging was thoughtful, especially the clear instructions on how to store each item. My mom also appreciated that everything was individually wrapped for freshness."

"I was blown away by how fresh and delicious these cookies tasted—honestly, each one seemed like it had just come out of the oven. The 2 lb box is a great value for the price, and I love that every cookie comes individually sealed. I'm a big fan of chocolate chips, so next time, I'm definitely trying the double chip variety!"

"Whenever I send these as gifts, my friends always rave about the amazing taste and quality. It's become my go-to for making people happy!"

"I loved that there were four different kinds of cookies, and all were absolutely delicious and incredibly fresh. It honestly felt like they had just been baked. Thank you, David!"

"I was truly impressed by the beautiful packaging and the delicious assortment of gourmet biscotti, chocolates, and cookies. Everything arrived fresh, and it felt like a special treat to open. This made a wonderful gift for my mom—I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a thoughtful present!"

"My husband absolutely loved this basket! He finished it all in one day. I just wish there were even more flavors and maybe a larger size, because we're definitely buying this again."

"Honestly, I wasn't satisfied with the flavor. The biscotti looked nice, but they were bland, dry, and much too hard for my taste. Even the toppings couldn’t help. I appreciate the presentation, but I won’t be gifting these again."

"I couldn't believe how quickly I finished both boxes—these cookies were just that delicious! They made for a perfect treat for myself, and I'd absolutely recommend them for gifts as well. I'm definitely planning to purchase again."

"After ordering an extra box to sample, I honestly doubted the rest would make it as gifts! These are not your average sandwich cookies—they're seriously addictive and taste amazing."

"I received these as a birthday gift and was lucky enough to get to share them. The cookies were wonderfully crunchy, crumbly, and super chocolaty. The toppings were spot on. My only hesitation is the price per cookie feels a bit high for the size, but they make a convenient and tasty present."

"I became instantly hooked after trying these at work—they're incredibly delicious, wonderfully soft, and always fresh! Remind me of pecan sandies, but even softer and with a lovely powdered sugar coating. I'll definitely be buying them again!"

"These cookies bring back memories of baking with my mom for special occasions. They arrived perfectly packaged, fresh, and beautifully baked. I'll absolutely be reordering!"

"My entire family loves these cookies—they really do melt in your mouth! We look forward to getting them every year, and they're so good it's hard to stop eating them."

"I loved the variety of flavors in the box, and the peanut butter cookies stood out as incredible. The cookies arrived fresh, intact, and earlier than expected in a nice tin. It felt a bit pricey, but sampling different options helped me decide on future purchases."

"I sent these cookies as a holiday gift to my cousins and their kids, and they were a huge hit! The packaging was excellent, with no broken cookies, and even the 7-year-old said they were delicious. I’d absolutely recommend this for gifting."

"The cookies tasted great, but I felt they were overpriced for what I received. The packaging seemed cheap, and the cookies were exceptionally thin—almost like discounted, day-old cookies. Still, I have to admit, the flavor was excellent."

"After my son spent two weeks in the hospital, I wanted to make his birthday special at home. I brought him this cookie gift basket and he thought it was awesome and tasted fantastic. It really cheered him up!"

"I ordered this for my husband's birthday and he was genuinely surprised. The cookies were fresh and delicious, and the packaging was perfect for gifting."

"A few cookies had a slightly whiteish color, like when chocolate gets a bit old, but they were still tasty and I finished them all. The assortment and decorations made it a fun treat."

"I was really impressed by the freshness and flavor of these cookies. The fact that they're individually packed makes them feel even fresher, and the customer service was outstanding. I definitely feel like I got a great value."

"I bought these as a gift for someone who loves Italian cookies, and he thought they were delicious and very close to the fresh ones he usually buys. The only small difference was that the jelly was a bit thinner than he's used to, but the taste was spot on."

"Unfortunately, my experience wasn't the best. The cookies tended to fall apart when I bit into them, leaving a lot of crumbs. The chocolate was a bit too soft for my liking, but at least the jelly inside was enjoyable. I personally prefer the ones from the grocery store."