Best Canned Pickled Herrings of 2025

"I find these kippers to be exceptional. While I'm not a fan of kippers, I can appreciate the quality and value for those who enjoy them."

"I'm ordering these again because they help me meet my protein and omega-3 needs. The smokiness makes them taste fantastic, plus they're a great deal!"

"I remember enjoying these growing up. Now, buying them in a mini-case makes for a nourishing and affordable mini-meal that my family loves."

"I was surprised by the consistency in each can. The meat is delicious."

"These kipper snacks bring back fond childhood memories. They have just the right smoky taste, and I love them on a saltine cracker."

"I regularly purchase these for their great taste and filet quality. They are high quality, nutritious, and I often enjoy them straight from the can."

“These kippers have a brutally fishy smell, but for the daily omega 3 and 6 benefits, it's a small price to pay. They taste decent with vinegar or Worcestershire sauce, and I appreciate that they are soft and easy to chew with no bones.”

“I think these kippers are among the best in flavor for the money. They make for a fast lunch; just grab a can and some saltines, and I'm good to go. Yum!”

“I’ve tried several brands of herring, and this one uses salt and sodium phosphate as preservatives. Unfortunately, this has made it bland and dry for my taste. Even my cat, who usually loves canned fish, refused to eat it.”

"The herring arrived open, and the liquid had saturated the bag it was in."

"I find it to be pretty expensive, but it's worth it for the good taste."

"I received my jar in good condition, but the herring was mushy and not the best quality."

"I'm grateful that we can get good herring from the internet."

“I find these to be almost identical to what my Swedish grandma used to make. They really put the grocery store brand to shame!”

“The flavor is fantastic! It's the classic pickled herring in wine I love. I plan on getting the 32oz party pail next time.”

“I was excited to try this, but I didn't notice sugar in the ingredients. It didn't taste like what I expected, so I had to rinse the fish to improve the flavor.”

“I find these to be great for keto or dieting; I don’t have to eat multiple tins. They’re some of the best and most affordable options.”

“Being a vegetarian, I get much of my protein from canned fish. I was pleased with the herring with cracked pepper; I ended up finishing the whole can in one sitting! The addition of pepper was genius!”

“I’ve never had a bad experience with Bar Harbor products. These are large cans with big filets, and I buy them by the case for cost-effectiveness. They’re just super good for you.”

"I think the flavor is delicious and the texture is excellent. I used to get the Smoked/Peppered version, but the price skyrocketed. I found this simply smoked version for the same price I used to pay, and I decided to give it a go. It’s just as tasty, with a simple salt and lightly smoked flavor. I enjoy it on crackers, and while it is quite salty, I find it so good that I even like the oil. I just bought four more cans because I really enjoy this product!"

"I was thrilled to discover this product! It’s perfect for making Haitian patties. I did find it cheaper elsewhere, but I would still purchase it here in case of an emergency. It's a great staple to have on hand!"

"Instead of mashed chunks like tuna, this herring comes with two whole filets in each can. It looks fantastic when I open it, and the taste is just as impressive. It's a convenient option for snacks or emergencies, especially when paired with horseradish sauce and crackers. Plus, it has a long shelf life and is made in Germany, which is a bonus for me!"

"From the moment I opened the tin, I was transported to a rugged coastline. The Season Peppered Kipper Snacks are not just a snack; they are an odyssey across the seven seas. Each bite releases rich, smoky flavor, and the subtle pepper seasoning enhances the natural taste of the herring. They are versatile enough to be enjoyed straight from the tin or added to gourmet salads. This is a tributes to the art of smoking fish, and I'm left craving more with every bite."

"I was pleasantly surprised by how good these kipper snacks are! I ordered a six-pack after my local store stopped carrying them, and I have zero regrets. They have the perfect balance of flavor; not too peppery or smoky, just right. The texture is flaky and has a nice browning from the smoking process. I’ve enjoyed kipper snacks my whole life, but this brand has taken it to a whole new level. I will definitely be ordering again!"

"I decided to try these kipper snacks since I love their sardines, but I found them a bit dry and lacking in flavor. Although the quality and packaging are good, they didn't quite meet my expectations. If you’re familiar with herring, you might enjoy them more, but I’ll probably stick with the sardines for now."

"I wasn't familiar with canned fish beyond tuna and sardines until I visited a tapas restaurant. They had a conservas platter that included canned mussels, cockles, tuna, and herring, and I particularly enjoyed the herring. I decided to try the Polar Peppered Smoked Herring as a reasonably priced option since I wanted some at home. I was pleasantly surprised! I made herring toast and a smoked fish dip, and found the flavor to be slightly peppery and mild. However, the sauce has a very fishy smell, which requires multiple hand washes if it gets on me. My cans contained 3 or 4 fillets, and I would definitely order again."

"I was quite pleased with how tasty this snack is. The pepper and great smoke flavor are evident. Unlike canned sardines, these are proper fillets and well-seasoned, which I appreciate. I do advise being cautious when opening the can since the liquid smells strongly of fish, but the fish itself tastes amazing!"

"I really got myself hosed on this. I paid $33 for one can of these herring fillets, and while they could be the best tasting ones ever, $65 per pound is simply not worth it. I thought I was getting 18 cans, but I was mistaken. Buyer beware!"

"This is a great little snack, but I need to be careful. The nutritional guidelines suggest that one tin contains two servings of herring, but if I’m honest, I can easily consume an entire container in one go. That means I have to double the calories and sodium content, which I do keep track of. The herring is excellent, and the horseradish adds a nice kick. Personally, I prefer it with horseradish over smoked. If you’re a fish fan, I highly recommend these herring fillets, but just keep an eye on your numbers."

"I tried these herring fillets, but I didn't detect any horseradish flavor at all. It felt like a missed opportunity. However, my dogs loved what I couldn't eat!"

"These herring fillets were a huge hit at our Midsummer party! The flavor was simply great."