Best Canned Oysters of 2025

"I've always enjoyed oysters in various forms, but these canned oysters have really impressed me. The texture and size are remarkable, and even though the price for a case of 12 might seem high, it's comparable to local grocery options. With only oysters and olive oil as ingredients, they are perfect for a nutritious snack or a recipe. I'm definitely buying these again! Highly recommend for any oyster lover!"

"These oysters are far superior to other canned brands I've tried. The taste is much nicer and I keep ordering them because my husband loves them. Fast shipping and great packaging make it a win-win!"

"After trying these oysters, I can confidently say they are the best I've ever had. They don't use seed oil and are not from China, which is a big plus for me. I'm highly recommending them!"

“I find the Bumble Bee brand of smoked oysters to be delicious and easy to open. They are definitely on par with Crown Prince but at a better price.”

“I was pleasantly surprised by the nutritional value of these oysters. I used them in a stir-fry and they added a great flavor without being too fishy. Plus, I learned I can freeze leftovers!”

“I wasn't expecting the oysters to come in hot chili sauce, which changed the flavor quite a bit. However, I still enjoyed them and finished the whole can!”

"I rarely write reviews, but after seeing some here, I felt compelled to share my thoughts. While the price has doubled, it’s still comparable to grocery store prices from years ago. I initially turned to Amazon for bulk buying due to grocery prices. Regarding nutrition, I find the cholesterol content acceptable as dietary cholesterol does not affect blood cholesterol. Oysters are nutrient-dense, providing essential vitamins and minerals. The taste is fantastic, especially when paired with crackers and cream cheese. Just a heads up—save these for before date night, as they can affect your breath!"

"These oysters are truly delicious! I love how they're always plump and not dry. The smokiness is just right, and they practically melt in my mouth. I can’t stop eating them! They make for a great snack, especially when entertaining guests alongside crackers and cheese—always a crowd-pleaser!"

"I admit I was initially worried after reading some negative reviews and even tried to cancel my order, but I’m so glad I didn’t! These oysters are plump and flavorful, with a subtle smoke that sets them apart from others I’ve tried. I’ve already polished off four cans in just two days. While they are a bit costly, they are totally worth it!"

“I've been enjoying these oysters for over 20 years! They might not smell great, but once I taste them, I don’t care—they're that good!”

“I really love these oysters; they have a firm chew and aren't slimy like some others. They have a nice smoky flavor and pair well with crackers and Tabasco. I even make oyster stew with them. I find them for half the price on Amazon compared to my local store, so I’m always grabbing a can to enjoy.”

“I bought a big box on sale, thinking I got a great deal, but then I noticed the price shot up to over 100 bucks. Thankfully, I caught that in time and canceled my order.”

"I found these oysters to be delicious and the perfect size, so I could enjoy more of them!"

"I was curious about these smoked oysters for their nutritional benefits, and now I'm hooked! The price is great too!"

"I love enjoying a beer and oysters on crackers while watching football. These are just as good as more expensive options!"

"I really enjoy having good quality oysters at home. Despite being a canned product, they still deliver the authentic oyster taste with great texture and aroma. I would definitely buy them again."

"I found these oysters to be excellent for snacking. I pour the contents into a colander to rinse, then mix with wine or cider vinegar for a delightful treat with my favorite crackers!"

"Although nothing beats fresh oysters, the Roland Whole Oysters are a great alternative when combined with aromatic vegetables and cream for a delicious oyster stew. Just warm them gently to keep the fresh seafood flavor intact!"

"These oysters are incredibly tasty with a nice smoky flavor and are quite large. I think I’ll opt for the smaller ones next time since I prefer them, but they are great overall and the price is right."

"I’m really impressed by the full flavor and excellent quality of this product. I’m completely satisfied!"

"These little oysters have a firm texture and a pleasant smoky flavor that isn’t too strong. I enjoy them in salads, on crackers, or in pasta. I like the Polar brand for their consistent quality. The only downside is the sodium content; I wish it were lower, but I can manage since I rinse them before eating. Also, I’m not a fan of cottonseed oil, but it doesn’t affect the taste much for me."

"I really enjoy the taste and texture of these oysters, and I appreciate the larger size. They also offer good value!"

"For me, Reese has always been synonymous with quality. I love having these on crackers, whether round or square. They make for great appetizers and are pretty good snacks as well. I prefer the petite size over the larger ones since they seem to be mushy. The smoked taste is excellent; I've been enjoying these for decades. Sometimes, my grocery store struggles to keep the petite size in stock, so I save them for special occasions or whenever I'm craving them. I've tried other brands, but they just don't measure up, and while these may occasionally have a bit of shell, others have more."

"I really like smoked oysters; they're perfect for a quick snack or those little sandwiches people serve at gatherings. It's clear that not all brands are created equal!"

"I've found Polar to be a reliable brand that consistently delivers good quality. These whole oysters are just as expected—not overly salty or fishy. I’ve also tried their oyster pieces, but I believe these whole oysters are much more satisfying and justify the extra cost."

"When my usual brand was unavailable, I decided to buy two cases of these. Unfortunately, I noticed a very strong metallic taste that was quite off-putting for us. We gave them a second chance, but it was just too overpowering for our liking."

"I used these oysters for soups and stews, and I found them to be high quality."

"I decided to try the Oyster Pieces. While I generally prefer whole oysters, these still offered good size and texture at a lower cost. The taste was fine, and as always, Polar is a reliable brand."

"Unfortunately, I couldn't eat these oysters at all. I bought three cases, but Amazon refunded my money. I really can't understand why they sell products like this that are not edible. It seems like a questionable business practice."