Best Canned & Packaged Sardines of 2025

"I absolutely love these Wild Planet Wild Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil. The texture is great, the price is reasonable, and they’re always readily available. I like to chill them in the fridge for easier slicing. I prepare them with Hummus on crackers and add my favorite hot sauce for a perfect breakfast. Sardines truly are a nutritional powerhouse!"

"I've chosen Wild Planet sardines for three main reasons. Firstly, they taste fantastic—much better than other brands I've tried. Secondly, they're great for my health, being BPA-free and packed with Omega 3s. Lastly, I appreciate their sustainable practices, using wild caught methods that are environmentally responsible. I’m now on my second case ordered through Amazon's subscription service!"

"I initially got these sardines for myself, but my dog loves them even more! They’re super fresh, packed in water, and have no added salt. I feel good sharing them with my furry friend since they’re Non-GMO and sustainably sourced. My dog does a happy dance every time I open a tin. I just reordered because we’re both hooked!"

"I started adding Beach Cliff Sardines in Water to my dog's meals, and he's obsessed! The sardines are the perfect size for mixing into his food, and I love that they're packed in water with no unnecessary additives. It's an affordable way to boost his omega-3 intake and keep his coat shiny and healthy. Plus, he gets so excited when he sees me opening the can—it's like a gourmet treat for him! Highly recommend for pet owners!"

"These sardines are absolutely delicious! I enjoy them as a snack, especially after a long bike ride. I prefer these smaller fish because they taste better than larger ones. The combo of oil and water is just right, and the smoky flavor is fantastic. I buy them whenever they're on sale—very good!"

"I'm doing a sardine fast recommended by Dr. Boz. Sardines are a super food, so I'm hoping to lose weight and feel better. These taste pretty great, especially with hot sauce. The price on Amazon is cheaper than my local Walmart. My first order had four cans, and even though they were in a shipping bag, they held up fine. Order these with confidence!"

"I thought I'd dislike them, but I quickly fell in love with these little fish. High protein, minerals, and they taste great without being too fishy. The packaging is high quality!"

"I used these sardines on pizza instead of anchovies during New Year's Eve, and it was fantastic! I plan to use a can with pasta this weekend. They are definitely a healthy and tasty option!"

"I am genuinely impressed with the quality and taste of these sardines. No salt is a huge plus, and they include the bones for added calcium, which I need. My cat loves them too, making them a great source of Omega and calcium!"

“I've been enjoying King Oscar Sardines for over 60 years. The easy pull-top can makes serving a breeze. While I love the sardines in olive oil, I believe all their varieties are fantastic. They’re not the cheapest option, but their quality is well worth the price, especially considering the value of the 4-pack.”

“I switched to King Oscar after being disappointed with a different brand. Each can I opened was a plump and perfect delight. The taste is fantastic and I love how I can prepare them as a spread with just a few simple ingredients. I feel confident recommending this brand.”

“This was my first time trying the tomato sauce version, and I was pleasantly surprised by the great taste! I just mixed it with pasta and a few spices, and it turned out delicious. It’s become a staple in my cupboard for quick meals.”

"As a sardine enthusiast, I found these to be even better than both Nuri's and Gonsalves. The addition of larger peppers really enhanced the flavor. The consistency of the sardines was also superior. I would definitely buy these again if I had the chance."

"I was pleasantly surprised by the great taste and quality of these sardines, especially at this price. However, if you're not familiar with spiced sardines, be cautious! Sometimes, the clove can really stick to the fish."

"These sardines offer more heat than other spiced options I've tried, but the flavor is fantastic. While they may not be the most attractive, I haven't encountered any scales, which is a huge plus. I will definitely order more."

"I find these sardines to be the best. They're skinless and boneless, which is exactly how I like them. The mild red pepper flavor adds just a hint of heat without being overwhelming. Plus, they're packed in olive oil, making them a healthy addition to my salads or snacks."

"In a delightful twist during dinner, I discovered my cat, who usually ignores my meals, was captivated by the Brunswick Wild Caught Skinless and Boneless Sardines. Watching him enjoy these savory sardines, I couldn't resist sharing the experience. They've not only impressed me with their rich flavor and silky texture, but they've also created a fun moment between us, proving that good food can bring joy to both humans and pets!"

"I really wanted to love these sardines, but the oil quality wasn't what I expected. I think they should be packed in extra virgin olive oil for a better taste. Although my family and I are sardine lovers, these were just okay. I ended up making fish tacos instead!"

"I've been purchasing these for years, and they are always excellent quality and delicious."

"I was thrilled to discover Season Brand sardines on Amazon after struggling to find them locally. However, I encountered a problem with excessive fish scales, which made them difficult to enjoy."

"My family and I love the taste and quality of these sardines! They are not only delicious but also very fulfilling!"

"These sardines are the best I've ever had. I just ordered more after finishing the 4-count sample pack in a single day. My favorite is the sardines in spiced tomato sauce. If you haven't tried them, I highly recommend the 4-count sample pack to experience all the flavors. The olive oil sardines are also excellent, but I personally prefer the tomato sauce. No strong fishy smell upon opening, and the olive oil tastes incredibly fresh. Highly recommend!"

"I had to rate these 5 stars across the board. When I first opened the can, I caught a slight fishy smell, but it vanished quickly. They may be pricey, but the quality and limited availability are worth it. I've never tasted canned fish that comes close to this. I started with the spiced in tomato sauce, and the flavors are amazing and well-balanced. The flesh is firm, with very minimal bones. Having tried these, I'm definitely a fan, especially for a midday protein boost or if you just love fish!"

"I’ve tasted sardines from all over, but I must admit, I was disappointed with these. I've tried several brands from Portugal that are far superior. I recommend looking for sardines from the Mediterranean or Adriatic regions instead. Not worth the price for me..."

"These sardines might just be the best I've ever had! After making a sandwich with them, I found them larger and meatier than expected. Their texture was firm yet pleasant, and the flavor was a delightful tasty fishy goodness—not overwhelming at all. I highly recommend trying them in a Mediterranean-style sardine salad!"

"I must say, I was blown away by these sardines! At my age, I had never eaten sardines due to their repulsive reputation. However, upon opening the can, I was greeted with a mild aroma instead of the usual fishy smell. They made my 72-hour sardine challenge incredibly easy, and now I'm actually craving them! I love preparing them in a skillet with Himalayan pink salt and Mrs. Dash seasoning—absolutely amazing!"

"These sardines are really good! Caught off the coast of Morocco, they have a nice texture and are not mushy at all. The olive oil is rich in taste, which enhances the overall experience. While they might not be the absolute best, they are still a great combination of flavor and quality."

"I've tried many canned fish, and this product has restored my hope in humanity. It's the only good canned fish I've ever found."

"These Brunswick Hot Pepper sardines are a new firm favorite. The flavor is marvelous, with a nice, warm heat from the green serrano peppers."

"My husband loves the meatiness of these sardines. He comments every time he opens a can, and the price is better than others."