Best Canned Mushrooms of 2026

"I've found these mushrooms to be an excellent choice whenever I need canned mushrooms. The flavor is always good and the quality never disappoints. I've reordered them several times and they've become a staple in my kitchen."

"These mushrooms are a real pantry lifesaver for me. They work perfectly in sauces, soups, and stews, and I love that they hold their texture during cooking. It's great not having to worry about refrigerator spoilage."

"I just tried my first can and was surprised at how quickly I went through it. I used some on a burger and the rest in a rice dish—the taste was excellent. The only thing is, the cans are a bit small, so I have to use them more sparingly."

"I absolutely love these mushrooms—I could honestly eat them straight from the can! The flavor is fantastic, they keep their shape during cooking, and the price is definitely worth it. I’ve bought them several times since I can’t find them locally."

"I thought I was buying freeze-dried mushrooms but received canned ones instead. The mushrooms themselves are very good quality, but I feel the price is a bit too much for the amount you get. That’s why I rated it three stars."

"I was excited to try these in a new stir fry recipe, but both cans arrived severely dented and the vacuum seal was broken. Unfortunately, that ruined my experience with this purchase."

"I was really pleased with how none of the cans arrived dented—that’s rare for Amazon. The price is great, and they arrived on time. I tasted them right away and found the portobello slices delicious with excellent texture. The cans are a bit on the small side, but the large slices and minimal water make it worth it. I’m already planning to buy more."

"I love the ease of grabbing a can of organic crimini mushrooms whenever I need them—no more cleaning and slicing fresh mushrooms every time I cook! The texture is tender yet firm, and the Subscribe & Save price is the best I’ve found. Though slice sizes can vary, the quality is always consistent. For anyone who isn’t a stickler for using only fresh mushrooms, I strongly recommend this brand."

"Because I couldn’t always keep fresh mushrooms handy, I started using these canned ones for soups, omelets, and sautés. They have great flavor and are full slices, not just bits and pieces. While I still prefer fresh, these are so convenient I’ll keep buying them—I just wish the cans were bigger since I often need two for one recipe."

"I was looking for shiitake mushrooms at a reasonable price, and I'm glad I found Polar's canned slices on Amazon. The meaty texture and the fact that they're ready to eat out of the can are huge pluses for me. I appreciate that they offer a healthier, budget-friendly option compared to dried shiitake, and the flavor is agreeable. It's great not having to cook them first like with fresh mushrooms."

"I needed mushrooms that would last for a long time without spoiling, and these canned shiitake slices are perfect for my pantry. They have an excellent shelf life and taste great in various dishes. These are my go-to choice for convenient storage and easy meal prep."

"I used to buy a different brand, but switched to these when my usual was out of stock. I'm totally satisfied—they're a quick and healthy addition to stir-fry and other recipes. Although there's a bit of sodium, using half a can per person works well for me."

"I found these marinated mushrooms to be a deliciously tangy treat—each bite is bursting with flavor and the texture is spot on: soft, juicy, and never mushy. They’re incredibly versatile, perfect for salads, charcuterie boards, or just enjoying right from the jar. I especially love that they’re low in calories and look gorgeous when served to guests."

"As a repeat buyer, I can say these mushrooms are consistently tasty with a flavorful marinade. The pieces are large and satisfying, and I always enjoy adding them to my salads. If you’re a fan of marinated mushrooms, these are a solid pick."

"I was really hoping these would be as good as my favorite brand, but the flavor was just too overpowering for my taste. I tried rinsing and re-brining them to salvage the jar. On the plus side, the jars arrived intact, but I wish the taste was milder."

"I really appreciate the high quality and perfect portions of these mushrooms. They're delicious on everything and I'm so glad I discovered this brand!"

"These are the best canned mushrooms I've tried—the big pieces and robust flavor make them worth the price."

"I love how convenient and reasonably priced this large quantity is, especially with grocery costs rising. It’s great to have mushrooms on hand for any recipe."

"I always keep these mushrooms on hand because they make every dish more flavorful and are extremely convenient to use. Even though they’re a bit pricier, the quality and taste they bring to my cooking make them totally worth it."

"After following the soaking and boiling instructions, I’m consistently left with juicy, flavorful mushrooms that are perfect for recipes. The container lasts me through many meals, and I love that there’s no dirt and I can use every last bit, including the soaking liquid, to boost my dishes."

"Whenever I use these mushrooms, I notice a major difference in the depth of flavor in my food. I usually grind them into a powder and add them to everything, and it’s so handy to have mushroom flavor ready anytime without worrying about spoilage."

"I absolutely love these mushrooms—they're so versatile that I toss them into my spaghetti and almost everything else. They're just great to have on hand!"

"The mushrooms are deliciously seasoned with green peppers and onions. I find them perfect for adding to soups or stir fries—they really enhance the flavor."

"These mushrooms remind me of a Bread and Butter Pickle—they have a sweet pickled taste rather than the traditional Italian style I'm used to. Not bad, just a bit different than I expected."

"I always keep a case of these mushrooms at home because fresh ones are costly where I live. The pieces are generously sized and consistently high quality. Every time I open a can, there’s no strange smell—just the aroma of mushrooms. I’m very satisfied with this product."

"These mushrooms are absolutely worth the price! Even though they’re sliced, the pieces are big and plentiful, and if I chop them smaller, they last even longer. Best mushrooms I’ve had in years!"

"The flavor is fantastic, and my order always arrives quickly. I do wish the cans were larger since I go through two at a time, especially when air-frying them with garlic for burgers or adding them to soup for extra servings and taste. They’re perfect for my Philly cheesesteak subs!"

"I use these mushrooms in almost every meal I prepare. Their large size and great shelf-life make them a staple in my kitchen. As a fan of straw mushrooms, I find the taste consistently enjoyable."

"Roland's straw mushrooms are always delicious and have the perfect texture for soups, pastas, or salads. I trust the quality, and love that they can be stored for a long time. Just be sure not to overcook them, and you'll enjoy a much better texture than smaller varieties."

"I've found the mushrooms to be soft—not mushy—and really tasty, even in dishes where other mushrooms get rubbery. My only wish is for BPA-free cans. Also, my first order arrived badly dented, but customer service took care of it quickly and sent a perfect replacement."