Best Canned Peeled Tomatoes of 2025

"I'm absolutely delighted with Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes! They have truly transformed my cooking experience. The authentic flavor and tender texture are remarkable, and I appreciate that they contain no added salt or preservatives. They save me so much time in the kitchen since they come peeled and ready to use. I can't recommend them enough!"

"I remember purchasing a can at the market for just over $6 to make spaghetti sauce. They are simply delicious! I love that I can add my own spices and flavors to them. Now, I buy them on Amazon because it's cheaper. You should definitely give them a try; you won’t regret it!"

"If you're serious about cooking authentic Italian cuisine, these are the tomatoes for you. They have a rich and intense flavor that’s hard to find elsewhere. Yes, the price for a pack of six may look high, but the quality makes it absolutely worthwhile. They add an elegant touch to any meal!"

"I absolutely love these tomatoes! They make the best pasta sauce and are perfect in soups."

"After taking an Italian cooking class, I learned that using these specific tomatoes makes all the difference. Every year, I set aside a day to make sauce, and I always choose this product because it consistently delivers delicious results."

"Cento San Marzano tomatoes transformed my sauce! The color was brighter, and the flavor was outstanding. I added a bit of paste for richness, and it was a huge hit during the holidays."

"I find these tomatoes to be good quality at a reasonable price. Last time, they were $9.90, which I felt was a great deal, and they taste delicious."

"During winter, when my tomato plants have stopped producing, I always keep whole, peeled canned tomatoes on hand. Grocery store sauces just don't measure up, and making my own is quick and satisfying. While these aren't top-end San Marzano tomatoes, they're perfect for sauces and offer a great price."

"Canned tomatoes are a pantry staple for me, and I use them throughout the year for everything from pasta sauce to chili. I love that I can order them online in bulk. I did notice a dent in one can, which made me a bit concerned about possible contamination, but overall, the flavor is mellow and satisfying for my dishes. I plan to subscribe for regular deliveries."

“I find these tomatoes to be wonderful for my sauce. They’re not too sweet and definitely not bland. Just the right balance.”

“In my experience, this is the best canned tomato I've ever used. The flavor is so rich, and my tomato soup turned out perfect.”

“I exclusively cook with these tomatoes. Their fantastic flavor and outstanding quality make a significant difference. Marcella Hazan’s words resonate with me: there should be whole, firm tomatoes with just a touch of juice, and these are exactly that. I’ve been let down by imported brands, but these prove that local can be better.”

"I find this product to be always good and fresh. They make a great sauce that's truly worth the money."

"These canned tomatoes are sweet and flavorful. I enjoyed making a delicious penne dish with them, adding some sautéed organic ground beef and minced garlic. It was an excellent source of protein!"

"My mother used these tomatoes in her Italian dishes, and I continue that tradition. They are the best Italian stewed tomatoes I've found, aside from homemade. I'm so glad I can find them on Amazon since they aren't available in most supermarkets."

"In my quest for great Italian food, I stumbled upon these tomatoes on Amazon, and I couldn't be happier. The quality is excellent, ripe, and sweet, making for a wonderful sauce that has truly enhanced my cooking."

"As someone who regularly makes red pasta sauce from scratch, I can confidently say that canned tomatoes like these are among the best I've tried. They offer a consistent quality and save me the hassle of using fresh tomatoes, which can be messy and less flavorful."

"I was disappointed with my experience. I conducted a blind taste test among various canned tomatoes, and surprisingly, Cento was rated second to worst. I had high expectations based on the reviews, but my homemade canned tomatoes outperformed them all."

"I'm thrilled about this brand. I've always believed that if I had to choose just one type of food, it would be Italian, especially anything involving tomatoes. However, tomatoes are my top food allergy—just touching them makes my hands burn! Despite this, I can't help but love them. I've tried using sugar to minimize the acidity, but with this brand, they are so fresh and low in acid that I simply enjoyed them straight away. I made a Marinara sauce with my usual recipe, and it tasted unbelievably better! I'm donating other brands in my pantry because it's only Mutti for me now. I can't wait to try all their products!"

"I've been buying this product for years and absolutely love it. However, my recent delivery had two dented cans, one of which was dented on the seam, so I decided to toss it. Despite this minor issue, I'll continue purchasing this quality product. It looked like a shipping problem."

"I never paid much attention to the tomato products I used until I got a pizza oven. After researching and reading about pizza making, I came across Mutti tomatoes and decided to give them a shot. Now, my family pizza nights are a game-changer! Everyone who tries my pizza asks about the sauce and praises its freshness. My secret? Just Mutti whole peeled tomatoes, hand-crushed, some fresh basil, and garlic—that's it! I once tried a different brand when I ran out of Mutti, and I was disappointed with the flavor. From now on, it's Mutti or nothing!"

"I love these tomatoes! They are a godsend for my heartburn. I made a large batch of marinara, used some for lasagna, and pressure canned the rest. The taste is great and the acidity is low. I will be using these forever!"

"To my surprise, all 18 cans I ordered arrived in pristine condition. I appreciate the care in packaging, with cans wrapped in bubble wrap and separated by cardboard. These are some of the best tasting DOP tomatoes I’ve experienced; they're soft and delicious!"

"Unfortunately, I had to get a refund. Most cans were severely dented, and the one can I tried was unimpressive. I’ve used authentic San Marzano tomatoes for years, and this product lacked flavor and quality."

"I bought these for an Ina Garten recipe that specifically called for San Marzano tomatoes. They delivered a good depth of flavor."

"These tomatoes are the best canned tomatoes I have ever used for sauce. They are the next best thing to those from my garden."

"I had to wait a bit longer than normal for these Italian plum tomatoes, but it was well worth it. Every dish will yield excellent results."

"I don’t mess around when making my pasta sauce, so San Marzano tomatoes are a must. This brand is very high quality and not seedy. I’ve tried many types but always come back to this one. Since no local market carries this brand, it’s Amazon to the rescue. I highly recommend it!"

"Opting to spend a bit more on San Marzano tomatoes for a large crowd was the best decision! This is the first canned tomato that hasn’t caused me any stomach issues. The flavor is rich, fresh, and robust! My sauce was even more flavorful the next day, and it froze well too. All of the cans arrived dent-free. If you can, spend the extra money; they’re worth it!"

"No more store sauce for me! It might be a little pricey, but it's beyond worth it for the texture and taste! I used four cans to make sauce for 15 people. Cooking it down for hours created an amazing aroma. This is truly worth the price for the pleasure of the taste!"