Best Canned Tomato Sauces of 2025

"This is the best tomato sauce I’ve tried, closely resembling those pricey Italian imports. The cans arrived in perfect condition."

"I use this sauce for my stuffed cabbage and spaghetti recipes. It's a staple in my kitchen."

"I was thrilled to find that Amazon carries Del Monte since it’s hard to find in my local stores. I ended up ordering several cases!"

"While I noticed some cans were dented and a bit rusted, I've experienced worse. For the affordable price, I'll definitely order again."

"This sauce tastes just like mother's homemade. The texture is great, and I appreciate the color and value."

"My order arrived on time, just as described, and the cans were undamaged. I'm completely satisfied with my purchase."

"I trust Contadina for all my canned tomato needs. It's always ** competitively priced** and often has discounts. You'll find various products from them in my pantry!"

"I usually prefer fresh home jarred tomatoes, but I ordered these on a whim. Surprisingly, they tasted very fresh, and my gravy came out nearly perfect! I'm very satisfied."

"I enjoy using this product along with Contadina diced, paste, and crushed tomatoes for my sauce. The taste is excellent!"

"These canned tomato sauces are perfect for me. Buying in bulk saved me money, and I’ve been making tons of spaghetti sauce!"

"I find this to be the best affordable tomato sauce. It's very flavorful, and I don't need to add any salt at all!"

"Contadina is my go-to brand for tomato sauce. It has a rich flavor that’s never bitter, and I love that it’s well-priced compared to regular grocery store options."

"I appreciate being able to order Contadina online since many nearby stores don’t stock it. However, I was disappointed that 7 of the 12 cans were dented, making two unusable."

"I mixed this tomato sauce with a can of Contadina tomato paste, some Italian herb seasoning, and freshly ground black pepper to create an excellent pizza sauce. After baking the hoagie roll pizzas, my husband loved them so much that he wished I’d make them again. I’m definitely stocking up on hoagie rolls and pepperoni! Having a few cans of this sauce on hand is perfect for any pizza cravings. It’s also useful for thinning spaghetti sauce or in any recipe needing tomato sauce. I’m a fan of its great flavor!" - The Rebecca Review

"This tomato sauce has a good taste and arrived in perfect condition. The pricing is also very reasonable. It’s just a classic tomato sauce!"

"I use this sauce in many of my recipes. It works perfectly for making marinara with the fresh herbs I grow at home. I prefer the plain version since it allows me to season it to my liking, unlike pre-seasoned sauces. It’s a great base for any sauce!"

"I've tried various brands, but this one outshines them all in terms of flavor and texture. I always choose this brand now, especially since the price is great!"

"I started buying this tomato sauce in bulk a few months ago due to my back injury, making it hard to carry heavy items. I just checked, and the price per can here is the same as the individual can price at Krogers. I won’t shop at Krogers again for several reasons, but this is a fantastic alternative! Free overnight delivery right to my home means I never run out and it cuts down on grocery trips!"

"We've always enjoyed this tomato sauce, but I should mention that when I order a case, the labels end up upside down on the cans, so I have to flip them for my can opener. Still, it's great sauce as usual!"

"I was disappointed when every can arrived dented. However, I want to focus on the product itself. Muir Glen's tomato sauce is amazing—pureed tomatoes that taste exceptionally fresh. I've used it for everything from spaghetti to pizza, and it never disappoints. The quality is outstanding, and I appreciate the organic certification. I just hope my next shipment arrives in better condition."

"I absolutely love this sauce! It's lower in acidity compared to others I've tried, and with a few fresh additions like garlic and onion, it becomes even better. Of course, it's great on its own too!"

"I’ve been a fan of Muir Glen for years. Their tomato sauce is my go-to for making Pasta Fagioli. It's honestly the best I've ever used, and my husband agrees that it's chef-recommended. I can definitely see why!"

"I find this sauce wonderful for spaghetti and other needs."

"I created a great BBQ sauce by mixing in A1 steak sauce and Hershey's Special Dark powder."

"I appreciate the long shelf life and unique Tetra pak packaging."

"I absolutely love this sauce for mixing in meatloaf and making spaghetti sauce. It's a great value and so easy to use."

"I originally bought this by accident, thinking it was just tomato sauce. To my surprise, it worked great for last-minute dinners. I just brown some hamburger, add a couple of these, and voilà, dinner is served! My kids even liked it, which is a huge win!"

"I've been using this meatloaf sauce for years. After my first time, I knew I wouldn't go back to making my own. However, I started having trouble finding it at local stores, so I ordered it on Amazon to ensure I always have my favorite sauce on hand!"

"I try to use as much organic as possible and avoid seed oils. This sauce is so delicious and flavorful! I used it on two homemade pizzas and had a quarter cup left over. It was delivered quickly and the packaging was great, with no damage to the cans."

"These are the best tasting canned tomatoes I've ever had! I was totally surprised at how much better they are compared to other brands. When I opened the can and tried a piece, it felt like I was tasting something fresh! I'm delighted!"

"I've been ordering these for several years after trying several others. They are reasonably priced for organic products, and I really enjoy them!"