Best Taffy Candy of 2025

"I find this saltwater taffy absolutely delicious. Sure, a couple of pieces were melted and sticky, but what do you expect when it’s shipped from a hot warehouse? I say, just order the yummy candy!"

"I bought this bulk bag for my daughter's tropical theme party. Although I faced some frustration with clumps of candy that were unusable, I loved the variety of flavors, especially the cinnamon. The kids enjoyed all the other flavors too!"

"This taffy is very good and delicious! It disappeared quickly, and I will definitely purchase it again."

"I really enjoyed the soft and fresh taffy. It had a great taste, especially for a sugar-free candy!"

"Growing up, I loved saltwater taffy. However, my recent experience was disappointing. Most flavors tasted similar, and the texture was too soft instead of chewy. I was hoping for that distinct flavor experience from my childhood, but it just wasn't there. Only the green sour one stood out, and I found it too sour for my taste. Overall, it was a big letdown."

"I wish the flavors were better labeled. I mistakenly shared a licorice piece thinking it was chocolate, and my daughter didn't enjoy it at all. Some flavors were delightful, like cherry, but others were surprising. It's a bit of a gamble with each bite. I appreciate the sugar-free aspect, but there were flavors I couldn't identify, and that made it less enjoyable for me."

"I absolutely love Airheads! This pack comes with a fantastic variety of flavors. They arrived fresh and are perfect for sharing. For the price, they are definitely worth it."

"I found myself in a pinch needing last-minute party favors, and the Airheads Candy Bars Variety Bulk Box came to the rescue! It not only saved the day but also made the party a hit! The variety is impressive and the individually wrapped bars made favor assembly a breeze. Living in a warmer climate, I was pleasantly surprised by the non-melting feature. The kids were thrilled, and I felt like the hero of the day!"

"I purchased these for school bus children, and they absolutely love them! The value is nice, and I always end up buying them in bulk. They come super fast, and I always receive exactly what I ordered. Plus, they are much cheaper than store prices!"

"I recently indulged in a box of assorted flavor saltwater taffy, and it was a delightful experience from start to finish! The assortment of flavors is fantastic, with each piece offering a unique burst of taste. The freshness is remarkable, and the packaging is beautifully wrapped, making it a perfect gift or treat for myself. I highly recommend it to anyone seeking a sweet, nostalgic treat that delivers on taste and quality."

"I grew up on a boardwalk and always loved saltwater taffy, but I didn't know what REAL S.W. Taffy was until I tried THE TAFFY SHOP's version. It's always fresh, and the guides are so much fun! I find myself addicted to it, and it's worth cutting back on other treats. This is truly the FOOD OF THE GODS!"

"These were fresh, soft, and full of flavor. I was impressed with the excellent quality of the taffy and found it to be a great price too. The lingering taste is nice, and the taffy is not stale or hard, unlike what I experienced with another seller."

"I find the banana flavor to be delicious and truly worth the price! The product is soft and fresh."

"For me, this is a great value! There’s a large quantity in the box, and they’re very soft and chewy. However, I was a bit disappointed that banana seems to be the filler, with fewer flavorful options."

"I absolutely love these sweets! I counted and confirmed that I got 145 sweets in this tub. They have a lovely taste and don't stick to my teeth, which is a huge plus. The tub itself is strong and sturdy, perfect for storing other items later!"

"Finding full-size taffy like this is tough. My brother had some for trick or treaters, and I had to ask where he got them. Of course, it was Amazon! I picked a pack a month ago, and my 74-year-old dad loved them too. They were fresh, stretchy, and delicious. I just ordered another pack. I'm so glad they have an assorted pack without banana flavor, which I can't stand. My favorites are grape and watermelon, but all flavors were perfect."

"I've been a fan of this candy since the 90s! It's very fresh and lasted a few weeks. I'm just thrilled to have it!"

"I was really excited about these, but when they arrived, I was hugely disappointed. They were hard as a rock and definitely not fresh. I felt it was a total waste of money."

“I loved these as a kid. They are really tasty, chewy, and fresh, but I just wish the bag was larger.”

“This is my favorite flavor of Laffy Taffy. It's very flavorful, chewy, and soft.”

“This candy still tastes and looks just like the candy I had when I was a kid. I am now 64 years old.”

“The candy was very fresh and soft, but I found the wrapper stuck to the candy, making it hard to peel off. I probably wouldn’t buy it again for this reason.”

“I was very happy to discover that Amazon offers bags with just Banana flavor, since it’s my favorite flavor!”

"I love the variety of flavors offered. The taffy lasts a long time and remains soft, which shows it’s fresh. I finished the whole bag in just three weeks!"

"This taffy is quite delicious! It has a great taste and is not overly soft. I enjoyed every flavor, and they weren’t overpoweringly artificial. I’m sure you’ll love it too!"

"I was a bit disappointed with the lack of tropical flavors in the mix. While it’s fresh and soft, I really hoped for more variety."

"These are my absolute favorite candies, and I was thrilled to find that everything arrived fresh and perfect in the bag. Thank you!"

"I love being able to purchase my favorite flavors without wasting any I don’t like. It's a great choice!"

"I bought this for my niece who adores the cherry flavor. She was so happy, and the package even arrived before the expected date!"

"I found this Laffy Taffy to be delicious, especially the banana flavor! It’s a hybrid of flavors, and now I'm regretting not getting a bigger bag."

"These are super yummy! I enjoy the flavor duos, and my kids do too. Sometimes they arrive melted, but I totally get that."

"I've bought these before and had mixed experiences. Some were amazing, while others felt like they had been sitting around too long. The flavor is just what I expected, but the texture wasn't as soft and chewy as I'd hoped."