Best Fudge of 2025

"I have to say, this fudge is absolutely the best I've ever tasted! It's creamy and rich without being overly sweet. I will definitely order again!"

"We ordered this fudge for my mother-in-law's birthday. Even though it arrived late due to a hurricane, it was a huge hit! The prices are worth every penny for such quality fudge!"

"I was blown away by Uncle Ben's fudge. I ordered an assortment and it arrived in less than 24 hours! It's creamy, thick, and the portion sizes are generous!"

"This fudge is incredibly delicious! I ordered the amaretto fudge and penoche, and they were both so yummy! I'm definitely going to reorder."

"I found the fudge to be full of flavor and it had a great texture. Plus, the packaging is really cute and perfect for gifting!"

"While the box was large, there were just two small plastic containers inside. I felt it wasn't a great value for the price."

“I found this homemade fudge to be really good. It stayed soft for a week, and the cute little plastic knife was perfect for cutting it. The variety is great, and I believe it's well worth the cost compared to regular store-bought candy.”

“I've been searching for fudge this holiday season and discovered this company on Amazon. I ordered chocolate fudge and a chocolate + peanut butter combo. The chocolate was enjoyable, but the combo really surprised me. I’m definitely ordering again!”

“At 74 years old, I’ve tried many peanut butter fudges, but none compared to my mom's homemade version. I just received this fudge and felt like I was back in her kitchen. This peanut butter fudge tastes just like hers. So happy to have found this!”

"I found this fudge to be absolutely delicious! It’s often tricky to get fudge right, but this one is creamy and tastes amazing. The coconut fudge is especially addicting! When I had an issue with my first order, the customer service was exceptional, and I appreciated the kindness I received."

"The fudge came in 90+ degree weather, but thankfully, it was well-wrapped and didn’t melt. It tastes good, but I expected more pecans. Also, I thought it was a bit pricey for the size."

"I was really looking forward to trying this fudge, but I was a bit let down. I ordered the chocolate pecan turtle fudge, and it lacked real flavor. It has a hint of caramel and nut crunch, but when swallowing, it leaves an aftertaste that isn’t pleasant. I might try other flavors, but I’m not inclined to buy this again."

"I used to enjoy See's fudge at the mall, but this is equal or even better! It ships quickly and is oh so fresh and creamy. I will definitely be reordering!"

"I hardly ever give a 5-star rating, but Betsey truly went above and beyond! I ordered some gluten-free fudge that looked amazing in the pictures, and despite a mistake in my order, she quickly sent me a replacement, possibly even overnighting it. The fudge was incredible—so creamy and with fresh nuts. I was pleasantly surprised to not have heartburn afterwards. I will be a customer for life!"

"The fudge was very creamy and smooth, and quite sweet. However, I found it lacking in chocolate and peanut butter taste. I probably wouldn't buy it again."

"This is my first time ordering this brand, and I couldn't be happier. Rich, creamy, and fresh—it's delicious! I tried the 3 sample box with orange, strawberry cheesecake, and coconut chocolate almond, and the coconut is definitely my favorite. If you’re unsure, just order it—you won’t regret it! The packaging was impressive, with each piece wrapped individually, and it arrived in a 'cool' pack FedEx envelope."

"I treated myself to two boxes with five flavors. This fudge is incredibly rich, just as good fudge should be. The Chocolate Raspberry is perfectly balanced—the tart raspberry with sweet chocolate is delightful. However, I wasn't fond of the Peanut Butter; it felt quite dry. The Orange Dreamsickle reminded me of my childhood chasing the ice cream truck. Overall, the Milk Chocolate was delicious, and the traditional Chocolate Fudge was the best of all!"

"I love the variety of flavors available! I make sure to repeat my order every month. I really enjoy this fudge and definitely recommend it to others!"

“I thought this would be a quirky gift, but honestly, the fudge is top-notch and the whisky flavor is a delightful touch. Best fudge I've ever tasted! The container is absolutely charming, and I plan on buying more for Christmas presents… and maybe some for myself, just in case they don’t share.”

“I absolutely love clotted cream fudge! The packaging is really nice, with each piece individually wrapped. However, I found the texture a bit gritty, which wasn’t what I expected. The flavor was decent, but I was hoping for something creamier.”

“I purchased this for myself as a treat, but I was quite disappointed. When I opened the package, there was an unpleasant smell that I couldn’t identify. The taste wasn’t sweet or enjoyable at all. I really can’t understand the rave reviews; this just wasn’t good for me.”

“I don’t claim to be a fudge expert, but I’ve sampled enough to know what’s good. When my fudge arrived, it seemed like everyone had a radar for it! The fudge is silky and has no aftertaste. The walnuts add a nice snap to the chocolate. I’m definitely ordering more, and this time, no sharing!”

“If heaven had a candy store, it would sell fudge from Fedele's. It's so good! Thank you!”

“I really enjoyed the freshness of the fudge. I prefer larger walnut pieces, but it was nicely packaged for gifts. I treated myself for my birthday, and I’d definitely buy again.”

"I've ordered from this fudgemaker a couple of times each year for the past few years, and their fudge is always delicious! I could have sworn I smelled it from inside the house when my latest order arrived! My favorite flavors are down to a science: Milk chocolate to start, Cookies n' cream for a holiday sugar high, and regular chocolate to ease off until I’m ready to order again! The cookie pieces in the cookies n' cream are soft like the fudge, which is great for my sensitive teeth! Highly recommend!"

"I adore this brand of fudge. The ability to create my own box from a range of flavors is fantastic. This time, I ordered one old favorite and five new ones. Here's my ranking from best to worst: 1. Black Coal - can't quite pinpoint the flavor, but it's amazing; 2. Spiced Rum - true to its name; 3. Butterscotch - perfectly flavored; 4. Chocolate Walnut Bourbon - subtle bourbon taste; 5. Cappuccino - used to be a favorite until they added cinnamon on top, which I didn’t enjoy, so I scraped it off; 6. Maple Bacon - a huge disappointment with a burnt taste. I’ll definitely keep buying their fudge, but never this flavor again."

"This fudge is excellent. It's fresh, creamy, and melts in my mouth. I enjoyed all three flavors in my order and will definitely be ordering more!"

"I bought several as little extra gifts, and they're just fab! Who doesn't LUV Ralphie?! The box was a bit smaller than I hoped, but I could smell the fudge, so I know it’s fresh! I'm pleased and would buy again."

"This fudge is creamy and delicious, the perfect treat that melts in your mouth. I had it while I was stoned, and it was just awesome!"

"I got this fudge as a Christmas present for my dad, who is a fan of A Christmas Story and loves chocolate. I wish I had taken a picture of the box before wrapping it; it is a bit smaller than expected for the price. But honestly, you're really paying for the nostalgia. A little fudge goes a long way, and the box feels kind of hefty. I can't comment on the taste, but I think this was a good deal for making my dad's holiday a little brighter. The box arrived in great condition with no dents and a very good best-by date."