Best Fudge of 2026

"From the very first bite, I could tell these were not your ordinary peanut butter cups. The dark chocolate is rich and velvety, perfectly balanced by a smooth, creamy peanut butter center. I love that they’re made with organic, high-quality ingredients—I can indulge without feeling guilty or tasting any artificial aftertaste. The texture is spot-on, with a satisfying snap to the chocolate and a melt-in-your-mouth filling. The individually wrapped packaging is super convenient, and I’m happy to support a product that’s better for my health and the environment. These are absolutely my favorite treat—luxurious, satisfying, and impressively delicious!"

"My husband and I both have dairy allergies, so finding a treat like this is a real win. The dark chocolate has a smooth, slightly Belgian flavor, and the peanut butter filling is pure and clingy. I actually prefer these to the regular grocery store brands—they’re just that good! Even though we bought them for allergy reasons, I keep reaching for them because they’re genuinely delicious. I’d definitely recommend these to anyone, not just those with allergies."

"I’m a big fan of peanut butter cups, and I order these regularly. When they arrive fresh, the peanut butter inside is creamy and the chocolate is intense and pure—no waxy or chemical aftertaste like big brands. Occasionally, I’ve received a batch where the filling was chalky, but both times I got a refund with no hassle. I find these treats filling and satisfying, and they help keep my snacking in check. Both the dark and milk chocolate versions are excellent, depending on your mood!"

"I've tried a lot of fudge, but this is by far the creamiest and most flavorful I’ve ever had. The texture is just right—smooth, not greasy, and the walnuts are big and fresh. I love that there are so many flavors, but it makes picking just a few a tough job! I wish there was a sample pack so I could try more. I’ve already sent some to my family and will order again for myself. Perfect for gifts or treating yourself!"

"The fudge was soft, creamy, and perfectly sweet. I was delighted by the huge range of flavors to choose from. Bought as a present for my husband, but I ended up loving it too! Definitely ordering again."

"I decided on a mix of flavors like orange cream, dark chocolate raspberry, rocky road, and milk chocolate. The overall creaminess was impressive, and the sweetness level was just right—not overwhelming. While some flavors, like the raspberry, were a bit understated, everything was still delicious. The only thing I’d change would be to make the flavors a bit bolder. Still, I’d happily purchase again."

"I gifted this fudge to my mother, and she absolutely loved it. It arrived fresh and creamy, not dry at all. The price was excellent, and each piece was the perfect size."

"Honestly, this is the best fudge I've ever tasted. Every bite melts in my mouth and the price is great. I plan on trying every flavor available!"

"The Penuche fudge was the best I've ever had. If you love fudge, you have to try this one—it's perfectly delicious and at an excellent price."

"I've tried several varieties of Hall's Fudge and I'm always impressed by the smooth, creamy texture and authentic flavors. The Maple Walnut is my absolute favorite—perfectly balanced maple taste with just the right amount of walnuts. Delivery is incredibly fast, making it easy to keep my favorites stocked for parties and guests. Everyone raves about it whenever I serve it!"

"The milk chocolate fudge was so delicious that I finished the whole thing as soon as it arrived. Though the price is on the higher side, the quality makes it worthwhile. It's definitely a treat I'll be ordering again!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by the richness and smoothness of the Chocolate Walnut variety—it stands out from the usual mass-produced fudges. Bite-size pieces make it easy to share, and the fudge has a lovely buttery aftertaste. The Maple Walnut is outstanding, though the layered Chocolate Peanut Butter was just okay for me, with a less pronounced peanut butter flavor. Still, overall, this fudge is a fantastic addition to my holiday treat tray and I'll be back for more."

"As someone from Scotland, I was thrilled to find a genuine Scottish fudge available online. It really brings back memories of home and is just as I remember. So happy to have this treat in the US!"

"The fudge tasted just like what I had in Scotland, and the price is reasonable compared to what you'd pay there. This is definitely the real deal for anyone craving proper British fudge."

"I found this fudge to be a lovely, soft caramel treat that didn’t last long in our house. It’s perfect for those who love quality, melt-in-your-mouth candy."

"I find this fudge to be very good, especially as a holiday treat. Although it's a bit on the pricier side, it's something I feel is a must-have for special occasions."

"I tried the assorted box with 8 flavors and thought it was pretty good overall. While not the best fudge I've tasted, I enjoyed sampling the different options and plan to order a box of my favorite flavor next time."

"For me, the fudge wasn't as moist as I'd hoped, and the flavor was just okay. I kind of felt like it wasn't worth the money."

"Since developing a milk and gluten sensitivity, I’ve struggled to find a chocolate treat I can enjoy—until I found these. These are hands down the best peanut butter cups I’ve tasted, surpassing even the big-name brands. The size is perfect, there’s no annoying second wrapper, and the peanut butter flavor is so much more natural. I keep telling my whole family about them, and I always buy in bulk since they’re cheaper here than most stores. Highly recommended!"

"I used to be unsure about dark chocolate, but Justin’s has totally won me over. The combination of dark chocolate and peanut butter is unbeatable, and this is the only chocolate brand I seek out now. It is a bit pricier than what I used to buy, but for me, the quality and flavor are absolutely worth it."

"I love these mini cups—they’re my go-to snack and a real treat. The dark chocolate is rich and the peanut butter tastes genuinely fresh and organic. Plus, the small size makes them perfect for snacking or sharing as a little thank-you gift. I always keep a stash handy for when I want a quick, satisfying bite."

"I was delighted by how smooth and creamy this fudge was—it truly hit the spot! The fact that it's made with real chocolate really stands out, and for the price, the quality is excellent. I’ll be buying again for sure."

"I bought this fudge as a special gift for my family during our first Christmas without my mother, and it brought us all so much comfort. My sister even said it tasted just like her homemade fudge. This treat made our holiday a little sweeter and I highly recommend it."

"The maple fudge was exactly what I hoped for—not only was it delicious, but the packaging with the little knife was a nice touch. The flavor is rich and satisfying, and a small slice with coffee makes for a delightful treat."

"Honestly, this might be the best fudge I’ve ever tasted! The texture is smooth and the flavor is rich, and I really appreciate the quick delivery and careful packaging. I’m already planning to order more soon."

"Tried Valley Fudge for the first time and was impressed by how fresh and delicious it was. The quality surprised me in a good way, and next time, I’ll definitely get a larger box."

"I bought the raspberry and amaretto fudge as a gift for my dad, and we both loved nibbling on them. They’re super rich, soft, and flavorful, and I liked that the company packaged both flavors together in a branded box—perfect for gifting!"

"As someone who truly appreciates both sweets and Scotch, I was blown away by this fudge. The texture is incredibly smooth and luxurious, and the Glenfarclas whisky adds a delightful warmth. Every bite is a harmonious blend of flavors that feels genuinely gourmet. It's not just a treat—it's a special experience, and I love how the packaging keeps everything fresh and makes it perfect for sharing or gifting."

"I bought this fudge for my dad’s 90th birthday, and it disappeared in a single day—he loved it! It really felt like a piece of Scotland arrived just for him. Absolutely delicious and memorable."

"Honestly, I ordered this mostly for the tin, but I was pleasantly surprised by how tasty the fudge turned out to be! There’s a generous amount inside, and it made the purchase even more worthwhile."