Best Caramel Candy of 2025

"At 60 years old, I've enjoyed caramels my entire life, and I can confidently say these are the best caramels I've ever had. The creamy smoothness is incredible—it literally melts in my mouth. The butter flavor stands out beautifully, and the hint of sea salt is the perfect finishing touch. I've purchased four already, and everyone I've gifted them to loves them too. My only suggestion would be a tiny bit more sea salt in some bites."

"I absolutely love the crunch of the salt! I wish there was just a little more, but overall, this is still an excellent product!"

"These caramels are simply so good that I can't stop eating them! They're soft, and the hint of sea salt makes them incredibly delicious. I rated them four stars only because I could easily finish the entire jar in one sitting, lol. At 130 calories for three, if they were calorie-free, I’d give them 10 stars for sure!"

"I find these delicious, with a texture that's just right. They remind me of old-fashioned caramel, and I finished my bag in just a few days!"

"While I enjoy the flavor, these don't taste like the Kraft caramels I grew up with. The wrappers can be a bit sticky and tedious to deal with."

"I've ordered these three times now because they're that good! I love the convenience of the wrappers for my work snacks."

"I received my candies individually wrapped and in great condition. They were so fresh, it felt like they were just made, and I love that they have a two-year shelf life. They are soft and easy to chew. I will definitely be buying more!"

"Sometimes the candies are very fresh, but other times they can be stale."

"These candies bring back the best memories! They taste buttery and caramel-like, with sugary centers that are just yummy! I absolutely love these!"

"These are yummy, high-quality caramels! They stay soft and are buttery sweet. Sure, the wrappers can be tricky, but that’s common with caramels. My dog loves them too, and she’s picky! Good quality overall."

"At first, I wasn't a fan of these due to their different flavor and harder texture. But after some time, I find myself preferring them over the softer versions. They offer a longer enjoyment and less intense sweetness, which I appreciate. I’ve even subscribed to them for over a year!"

"These caramels are delicious, but unwrapping them can be a bit of a chore. If only the wrappers came off easier, I’d enjoy them even more. Still, they’re definitely a good value for what you get!"

"I absolutely love caramel creams. These are the freshest I've ever tasted. I'll definitely buy again and highly recommend them."

"At first, I was skeptical because of the negative reviews about vintage candy. But I'm so glad I tried them! They are perfect, fresh, and addicting! I think the value for money is fine, but maybe they could offer smaller portions for more people to enjoy."

"The Goetze's caramel creams are so addicting! I will keep getting them again and again. They're just like I remember from my childhood."

"I always feel nostalgic when I eat these. Childhood memories of candy corn and fall flood my mind! The Brach's store on Amazon had them at an excellent price, and they arrived well sealed and fresh. I will definitely buy again!"

"I had high hopes for this big bag after trying them at Walmart, but they were a bit moist and sticky. They weren't what I expected, so I won’t be purchasing again."

"I love the cute new shapes! They didn’t melt during shipping, which I appreciated. However, I wish I could choose the flavors based on the shapes on the bag."

"These are the caramels I've been searching for. They remind me of my childhood—the ones I used to find at grocery stores long ago. They have the perfect chewiness, just the right stickiness, and that classic caramel flavor. I love how easily the wrappers come off, unlike other brands that seem to melt into the candy. I definitely need to order more!"

"I think they taste great, but honestly, the wrappers are really tough to get off. Next time, I might just stick with Kraft."

"These are fantastic! While they can be a bit tricky to unwrap, the taste makes it worthwhile!"

“I haven't received my order yet, but I purchased Werther's Original hard candies from Amazon recently and they are fantastic for my sweet cravings. My old girlfriend introduced me to them years ago. I just hope my teeth hold up! I can’t wait to enjoy them!”

“I bought these candies for their soothing caramel taste, and now they’re a hit at church! They are delicious, but I wish the bag was larger for the price.”

“I was thrilled to find these on sale, as I hadn’t had them in years due to their cost. They’re smaller than before, but still delicious. I took a chance and bought two bags, and I'm glad I did!”

"The seller was fantastic, and my caramels arrived very quickly. I really enjoy the twist wrappings!"

"I absolutely love caramel, but these were just average, and I felt like I didn't get much for my money."

"These caramels are incredibly yummy, especially with the sea salt on top of each chew!"

"I gave these as a Christmas present, and they are absolutely the best caramel I've ever tasted. Rich, soft, and creamy! I even bought a set for myself. Highly recommend for gifts or a treat for yourself—they're yummy!"

"I kept an open mind about these caramels. The first few chews were acceptable, but then it changed completely. It tasted like soap—I had to spit it out."

"My wife adores these caramels! I got a selection of six flavors, and they were all fantastic!"