Best Caramel Candy of 2026

"As someone who's upping my fiber, I love that these caramels deliver a huge fiber boost in just a few bites. They're soft, chewy, and really tasty—a little aftertaste, but nothing bothersome. Honestly, they're now my go-to daily fiber treat!"

"I have a sweet tooth but watch my sugar. These are the best no sugar caramels I've ever tasted! They're delicious, with a great texture, and I went through the whole box way too fast. I'll have to pace myself next time."

"ChocZero caramels are exactly what I need for my keto diet. They're truly keto-safe with no glucose spikes and the quality and flavor are top notch. Plus, there are plenty in the box—definitely worth it!"

"These candies were a huge hit with my family—my son especially can’t get enough of the soft caramel. I’m grateful they’re still available, and the bag was packed full and fresh when it arrived."

"I remember calling these 'bulls eyes' growing up, and they’re just as delicious and addictive as I remembered. The chewy caramel is gentle on teeth and the taste is still wonderful."

"Bought these for a group of older friends to bring back memories, and I ended up eating a quarter of the bag myself! The caramel is soft, not hard, and the cream center is spot on. Just make sure to get them fresh!"

"I’m a big fan of caramel apple candies, and these really hit the mark with their incredibly soft texture and classic caramel flavor. The apple aftertaste lasts surprisingly long and isn’t overpowering. I especially appreciate that every piece is individually wrapped and the resealable bag keeps them fresh. My family and guests enjoy them too!"

"What stands out to me is how buttery and creamy the caramel is—it’s just so smooth and melts in your mouth. I love that it’s made with real condensed milk, cream, and butter instead of artificial powders. No weird aftertaste, just pure caramel goodness every time."

"As someone who loves the caramel green apple lollipops, I was hoping for that same balance of caramel and tartness. While the caramel here is soft and strong, the apple flavor isn’t as pronounced and there’s a slight plastic scent from the artificial flavoring. Still, the candy is enjoyable if you’re a caramel fan."

"I was so impressed with the insulated packaging and ice gel pack—my candy bars arrived perfectly fresh and unmelted. The price was even lower than local stores, and the expiration date was excellent. I’ll definitely buy here again!"

"HEATH bars are a classic favorite for me—the combination of chocolate and toffee is irresistible. With this box, I get 18 bars at once, all tasting as good as ever."

"These toffee bars are delicious and arrived unbroken. I did notice they’re not quite as thick or chocolatey as they used to be, but they’re still really good."

"I'm absolutely hooked on these candies—they're so tasty and seem to last forever! Even though they didn't arrive in the Werther's-branded packaging, the quality inside is what counts."

"Werther's hard candies are my all-time favorite. They arrived well packaged and fresh. I'll definitely order again!"

"The candy didn't come in the original Werther's packaging, which was unexpected, but honestly, Werther's is always delicious—there's just so much to love about it!"

"These caramels are incredibly soft, creamy, and perfectly salty. From the very first bite, I was hooked—it honestly tastes just like something homemade. Totally addictive and impossible to put down!"

"I’ve never had caramels this good before. They’re unbelievably smooth, never sticky, and the balance of sweet and salty is spot on thanks to the Celtic sea salt in the center. Every piece just melts in your mouth—one isn’t enough!"

"These are the best caramels I’ve ever tasted. The texture is soft and buttery with a delicious flavor. I love how they’re made—definitely worth buying again!"

"I did a taste test with several brands, and these P-Nuttles were the clear winner—amazing flavor, perfect coating, and overall excellent quality. I love butter toffee peanuts, and these stand out above the rest."

"These are absolutely addictive and make my mouth water every time. The butter toffee flavor is just right and sweet, but I might have to rethink buying again since the price keeps going up."

"I had some delivery issues, but once they arrived, the peanuts were fresh with a thick, delicious toffee coating. Most nuts were well-coated, although there were some toffee pieces at the bottom. Overall, they're the best I've tried, and I even reuse the container for storage!"

"I was thrilled to discover Creme Savers again after thinking they were discontinued. The chocolate and caramel swirls look beautiful, and the flavor is just as rich and satisfying as I remember. I especially love the silky texture and the fact that they're vegan and gluten-free, which makes them a perfect treat for me. The candies are individually wrapped in a way that keeps them from getting sticky. I'm definitely going to buy these regularly!"

"These candies are tasty and a good size, and I really enjoy their slow, satisfying melt. There's a bit of stickiness to the wrapper, but it's not a big deal."

"I found the flavor to be pretty average—I couldn't really taste much chocolate or caramel. It was sweet and pleasant enough, just not as amazing as the high reviews suggested. I probably won't buy this flavor again."

"I've been searching for a coffee candy that matches the flavor of the old Coffee Nips, and Brach's Coffee Candy is a fantastic substitute. The coffee taste is bold, creamy, and never artificial, with just the right sweetness. I end up finishing bags quickly, so I now keep them on auto-delivery. They're addictive, high quality, and perfect for anyone craving a satisfying coffee-flavored treat."

"Brachs has been a favorite candy brand of mine for years. Their hard caramel candies deliver a creamy, authentic caramel taste that lasts a long time in your mouth. The price is fair, the quality is great, and if you love caramel, you’ll enjoy these. I’ve bought them multiple times and will keep coming back."

"I regularly order these from Amazon for my aunt in Florida and my wife. It’s very convenient, and they both absolutely love receiving them as gifts. These candies have become a staple present in our family."

"SKOR bars are truly my all-time favorite treat. I love the perfect salty-sweet balance and the crunchy toffee with a light chocolate coating. I'm always on the lookout for these whenever I shop."

"Honestly, these are way better than Heath bars! The chocolate is rich, the toffee is just right, and I really hope you keep them stocked, because I’ll definitely keep coming back for more."

"I think this is one of Hershey’s best chocolate bars—the toffee is light and doesn’t hurt my teeth, and they always arrive fresh and delicious right at my door."