Best Sugar Free Pudding Mixes of 2026

"I enjoy having a mix of flavors in this 6-pack, which keeps dessert time interesting and lets me try different combinations. Using just a bit of the sugar-free pudding mix in my protein ice cream makes it smoother and tastier. My only note is that the strawberry was a bit too sweet for me, but I know everyone's taste is different."

"This pudding is great when I want something sweet that won’t spike my blood sugar much. I do notice a slight chemical flavor, so I usually add a pinch of salt and dilute it more than directed, and that seems to help."

"When I mix these sugar-free puddings with my favorite protein powders, I get a high-protein, low-sugar snack that I really enjoy. Highly recommended for anyone watching their sugar intake."

"I tried this pudding mix with my frozen yogurt, and I was honestly blown away by the delicious flavor and affordability. While I can't comment on it as a stand-alone pudding, it worked perfectly in my recipe and really elevated the taste!"

"I often add a tablespoon of this mix to my Ninja Creami with vanilla protein powder. It's genuinely tasty and blends well, but I wish they'd use stevia or monk fruit instead of aspartame so I could keep enjoying it regularly."

"I'm totally obsessed with this sugar-free pudding, especially the lemon blueberry flavor! It's become our household favorite—whether I mix it into shakes or top it with Cool Whip, the flavor never disappoints."

"I was really surprised by how chocolatey and authentic this sugar-free pudding tastes. I use it to add flavor to everything from breakfast to desserts, and I haven’t noticed any aftertaste at all. It’s incredibly versatile and quickly became a staple in my kitchen."

"For me, this Jello has become a daily treat—it’s so easy to make and keeps my sweet tooth in check without blowing my calories. When I use almond milk, it’s even lower in calories, though it doesn’t set quite as firmly as with regular milk. Great value for a delicious dessert!"

"I honestly can’t get enough of this chocolate fudge Jello. The silky, rich texture and deep chocolate flavor make every bite feel special, and it’s become a real highlight in my day. No other dessert compares now that I’ve found this one."

"This pudding is my go-to for a creamy, low-calorie treat that satisfies my ice cream cravings. I love freezing it and using it with my Ninja Creami—no extra fat or sugar, but still delicious!"

"I’m a huge fan of this sugar free pudding—it’s perfect for mixing into cakes, frostings, or with cool whip. I use it in protein shakes or for desserts, and I like how versatile and easy to customize it is."

"As someone watching calories, I appreciate this pudding’s inoffensive flavor and great price. It’s a real lifesaver for sweet cravings compared to what I find at local stores."

"I tried this pudding mix as a frozen yogurt flavoring, and the flavor blew me away—absolutely delicious! The price point is also really affordable. While I can't speak to it as a standalone pudding, it worked beautifully in my recipe that called for pudding."

"I added a tablespoon to my Ninja Creami with vanilla protein powder and found it incredibly tasty. However, I won't be using it again because it contains aspartame. I'd love to see a version with stevia or monk fruit instead."

"I'm obsessed with this flavor from the sugar-free sprinkles pudding mix line. All the sugar-free flavors are fantastic, but the lemon blueberry is our absolute favorite. I enjoy mixing it with protein shakes or Cool Whip, and I'm definitely planning to reorder."

"I absolutely love that this pudding is sugar-free and super easy to make. It's delicious, and I really appreciate having a sweet treat that doesn't spike my sugar. I keep coming back for all the flavors!"

"Even though my kids aren't usually fans of banana pudding, they really enjoyed this brand and now request it all the time. The quality and taste are impressive, and it's a great value for the amount you get."

"As someone who needs vegan options, I was pleased this pudding worked perfectly with lactose-free milk and had a pleasant, genuine banana flavor. The flavor on its own was just okay, but I think it could be improved with some creative toppings or a crust."

"I'm obsessed with this sugar free pudding mix flavor! I mix it into my protein shakes and even top it with Cool Whip. I keep coming back for the lemon blueberry—it's definitely our favorite!"

"I used this mix in my Ninja Creami with vanilla protein powder and loved the taste, but I'm a bit disappointed it uses aspartame. I'd love to see them switch to stevia or monk fruit so I can enjoy it more often."

"The lemon flavor is smooth and not overpowering, but I couldn't taste any blueberry at all. If you're after a strong fruit flavor, this might not be the right choice. Still, it's nice for a sugar free pudding fix."

"The vanilla pudding flavor was absolutely perfect, and the chocolate felt rich and fudgy. I loved the texture, and using a mini stick frother made the consistency just right. Even though there's a bit of a saccharine aftertaste, these puddings really satisfied my cravings. I just wish they were a little less expensive, but I'm already planning to try more flavors!"

"As someone who’s both vegan and can’t eat sugar anymore, I’m so grateful for this pudding! I made it with unsweetened vanilla almond milk and it came out great. The aftertaste is very mild and totally manageable for a sugar substitute. The whole box was under 150 calories, which fits perfectly with my diet. I liked all the flavors and will definitely reorder."

"I tried the vanilla and thought the taste was pretty bad. It didn’t mix well and left a lingering, artificial aftertaste in my mouth. Unfortunately, it even made my stomach hurt, so I had to throw the rest away. Maybe the chocolate is better, but I wasn’t willing to try after the first experience."

"I love how fast and effortless this pudding is to make. The texture always turns out smooth and stable, plus I don’t have to worry about it separating in the fridge. The flavor is satisfying and makes for a great quick treat."

"I was thrilled to find a vegan, sugar-free instant pudding that doesn’t require any stovetop work. Using almond or cashew milk, I get a thick, creamy dessert every time. For the best mix, I use a handheld blender. This is the best Simply Delish flavor I’ve tried—natural chocolate taste without being overly rich, and great for anyone with dietary restrictions."

"This pudding is genuinely delicious—it reminds me of chocolate custard and makes a surprisingly big batch for such a small box. The taste, texture, and price are all excellent, especially for a low-calorie dessert. I’ll definitely be buying it again."

"I'm always happy to find butterscotch cook & serve pudding in stock. I love how creamy and rich it turns out, especially when I mix in extra dry milk powder and walnuts. The flavor is just right, and it really brings back childhood memories. Honestly, I much prefer cooking pudding at the stove—it's relaxing and so much better than instant varieties."

"For me, this is the best butterscotch pudding out there. It takes a little more time to make than instant, but the flavor and creaminess are totally worth it."

"I appreciate that this pudding is easy to prepare and tastes great. It's also a nostalgic treat, especially during the holidays. The only downside is that I'm watching my sodium intake, so I can't enjoy it as often as I'd like."