Best Fruitcakes of 2025

"I've had one of the best fruit cakes ever! It’s very moist and packed with lots of fruit and nuts. I highly recommend it!"

"I enjoyed trying the Claxton dark recipe as an alternative to my usual favorite. The quality ingredients made it quite good, though it had more raisins than I typically prefer. Overall, moist and flavorful, and I would order again!"

"This cake has become a favorite in our household. The flavor is great, and it has the right balance of fruit and nuts. We’re thrilled to find it available on Amazon!"

"I've always loved Claxton's fruit cakes. One of my three cake bars didn't taste as fresh, which is why I rated it 4 instead of 5."

"This is the BEST fruitcake I've ever tasted! It has a deep flavor and is packed with moist fruit. Perfect!"

"I was thrilled to find Claxton fruitcake on Amazon. It arrived moist and fresh, tasting exactly as I remembered from years ago!"

"This cake is incredible! My sister bought two, and I'm enjoying a piece every day with tea. It's so moist, and the fresh fruit and nuts make it the best fruitcake I've ever had. I plan on buying another one for the upcoming holidays!"

"I was thrilled with this fruitcake! It's full of fruit and nuts, and has the perfect moisture level. After I recommended it to a friend, she's decided to buy some for her daughters as well. This is exactly what I was looking for!"

"While the fruitcake is edible and I did finish the full pound, I found it to be a bit on the bitter side. A touch of molasses or brown sugar would really elevate the flavor. It’s decent but could use some improvement."

"I found this fruitcake to be wonderful! It truly has an old-fashioned style with rich flavors and moisture. There’s plenty of fruit and nuts in every bite, and I highly recommend it."

"I absolutely loved this fruitcake! The only thing I wished for was an almond paste topping. While it was a bit crumbly, it was just delicious! Plus, it comes in a really pretty tin. I'm savoring it slowly to make it last!"

"My grandmother and I have been searching for a delightful white fruitcake, and this one did not disappoint. It comes in a nice reusable tin and the flavor is simply divine. It’s definitely worth the price if you're particular about your fruitcake!"

"I loved this fruitcake even though I'm not a fan of fruitcake! It was incredibly moist and packed with nuts and fruit. I initially bought it as a gift for my boss, but I ended up wanting one for myself after tasting it!"

"Every year, I order one for my husband's birthday because he absolutely loves this cake! I've become a new fan of its moistness and quality, which has more nuts than fruit!"

"After trying several fruitcakes, my family held a taste test, and this one came second. It had a similar aroma to the top contender but was a bit dry and rated 3 stars overall. Still, it’s worth a try!"

“I absolutely love this fruitcake! I've been enjoying it for the last 20 years, and it never disappoints in texture and ingredients. The perfect ratio of cake to fruit makes it taste fantastic!”

“When I opened the package, I was thrilled to find that it was very good and met all my expectations. It arrived just in time for my holiday celebrations.”

“I decided to try this fruitcake based on its popularity, and I'm glad I did. It's loaded with dried fruits and nuts, and while the dark version has a unique taste, it was definitely a value for the money.”

"I ordered a 1lb cake for Christmas. It's smaller than I imagined, but one bite and any concerns about the cost vanished. This fruitcake tastes like the real deal, reminiscent of my childhood in the 60s. It's rich and potent; even a thin slice is enough. The fruit pieces look stunning, almost like a stained glass window. I’m definitely ordering again!"

"The cake was insanely delicious, but I was surprised by its size. I expected a loaf, not a cube. For the cost, I'm not sure I would buy it again."

"I’m a fan of fruitcake and decided to try this brand. There was plenty of fruit and nuts, but the color and texture were off-putting for me. The brown color made it hard to distinguish what was in the cake. The taste was fruity and nutty, yet it had a bitter undertone that gave me heartburn. Not my favorite."

"About two weeks before Christmas, my friend and I dedicated a full day to making her family fruitcake recipe, which originated from a Catholic abbey. That cake was the best I've ever tasted, but now we’ve discovered this fruitcake and what a Christmas blessing it is! It's so similar to that cherished recipe, without all the hassle! Excellent cake with no shortage of nuts, fruit, and “spirits.” It’s rich, dense, and moist."

"I was initially hesitant to purchase this fruitcake because I typically dislike the taste of alcohol, but after reading a review indicating the alcohol flavor was minimal, I gave it a try. I can detect a hint of rum, but it’s more of a fruity fragrance. The cake is packed with nuts and fruit, which are quite expensive, and the dark cake is deliciously moist. These cakes are handmade with meticulous attention to detail, and I just ordered more to ensure I don't run out!"

"This fruitcake is very nice! It’s tasty and filled with lots of fruit and nuts, making it dense and perfect for the holidays. I love warming it up to enjoy with coffee or a drink!"

"At 78 years old, I’ve had many fruitcakes, but this one is truly the best I’ve ever tasted!"

"I remember my mom bringing home the A&P Jane Parker cake every Christmas. This cake is just like that—moist and full of fruit! I couldn't help but taste it while writing this!"

"As a child, I didn't enjoy fruitcakes, but now this one is fabulously delicious—I’m so glad I bought a 3-pound cake just for myself!"

"I found the cake to be a real crowd pleaser. The quality ingredients and taste exceeded my expectations. I'm definitely going to reorder for Thanksgiving and Christmas."

"This fruitcake is quite delicious! It's moist but not sticky, packed with raisins and nuts. It’s a classic fruitcake, heavy like a brick, and I appreciate the great spices. Thankfully, the maraschino cherries are minimal, making it enjoyable for any fruitcake lover."

"I was disappointed by the lack of flavor and didn't notice any pineapple. I had to add brandy to enhance the taste. It's edible, but I’ll keep searching for better options."