Best Potato Sandwich Bread of 2025

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 4, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Potato sandwich bread is a soft and fluffy bread that's perfect for making sandwiches. It's made with a blend of wheat flour and mashed potatoes, giving it a unique texture and flavor. The potatoes add moisture to the bread, making it stay fresher for longer. It's versatile enough to use for any type of sandwich, from classic PB&J to a hearty turkey club. Potato sandwich bread is a great option for those looking for a tasty and nutritious alternative to traditional white bread.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Martin's Sandwich Potato Bread - 16 slice 18 oz (4 Bags) Cover #TOP 1
Martin's Sandwich Potato Bread - 16 slice 18 oz (4 Bags)
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Martin's Potato Sandwich Bread - 3 Loaves Cover #TOP 2
Martin's Potato Sandwich Bread - 3 Loaves
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag Cover #TOP 3
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Potato Sandwich Bread

#TOP 1

Martin's Sandwich Potato Bread - 16 slice 18 oz (4 Bags)

Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc.
Martin's Sandwich Potato Bread - 16 slice 18 oz (4 Bags) Cover
Martin's Sandwich Potato Bread- 16 slice 18 oz (4 Bags)

Martin's Potato Bread is an organic bread made with unbleached flour and enriched with a buttery taste. This bread is famous for its Dutch taste and is perfect for making sandwiches. The organic ingredients make it a healthier option than other bread. The bread's buttery taste adds an extra layer of flavor to your sandwiches. Its 16 slice 18 oz size is perfect for a small family. Its enriched bread quality makes it a great source of nutrition for your family.

What We Like
Organic ingredients
Famous Dutch taste
Buttery flavor
#TOP 2

Martin's Potato Sandwich Bread - 3 Loaves

Martin's
Martin's Potato Sandwich Bread - 3 Loaves Cover
Martin's Potato Bread - Pack of 3

Martin's Potato Bread is a delightful option for anyone looking to elevate their meals. With its famous Dutch flavor, this bread is perfect for making delicious sandwiches, providing a tasty base for your lunchtime creations. You can also whip up some mouthwatering french toast, making breakfast a breeze. Additionally, it’s ideal for bread pudding, allowing you to create a comforting dessert. This package includes three 18 oz loaves, giving you plenty of bread to enjoy over time. Whether you're feeding a family or just yourself, this versatile bread offers convenience and flavor in every bite.

What We Like
Delicious Dutch flavor
Versatile for meals
Great for breakfast
Convenient pack of 3
#TOP 3

Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag

Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc.
2 Bags
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag Cover
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

These Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls are available in orders of 2, 3, or 4 bags and made with high-quality ingredients including high protein wheat flour, nonfat milk, potatoes, real cane sugar, yeast, and real butter. Their famous Dutch taste has made them the preferred choice in America for the past 50 years.

What We Like
Famous Dutch taste
High-quality ingredients
Preferred choice in America for the past 50 years
#TOP 4

Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls

Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc.
3 Bags
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls Cover
Martin's Potato Sandwich Rolls- 8pk 15 oz. Bag (3 Bags)

Martin's Potato Rolls are famous for their Dutch taste and are the preferred choice in America for the past 50 years. Made with high-quality ingredients like high protein wheat flour, nonfat milk, potatoes, real cane sugar, yeast, and real butter, these rolls guarantee great taste. Whether you're making a sandwich or enjoying them with a meal, Martin's Potato Rolls provide the perfect texture and flavor. With each bite, you'll experience the softness and freshness that comes from using high-quality ingredients. Indulge in these delicious rolls and elevate your sandwich or meal to a whole new level of satisfaction.

What We Like
Famous Dutch taste
High-quality ingredients
Preferred choice for 50 years
#TOP 5

Martin's Potato Bread Variety Pack- 2 Loaves

Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc.
Martin's Potato Bread Variety Pack- 2 Loaves Cover
Martin's Famous Pastry Potato Bread Variety Pack- 18 oz. Bags (2 Loaves)

Martin's Potato Bread Variety Pack- 2 Loaves is a delicious and convenient option for families who love the famous dutch taste. Made with unbleached flour, this pack includes two types of bread: Original Potato Bread and Potato Butter Bread. The Original Potato Bread is perfect for sandwiches, while the Potato Butter Bread is a great option for toast or as a side to any meal. With each slice only 80 calories, this bread is a healthier choice for your family. The Martin's Potato Bread Pack will provide variety and great taste to your meals.

What We Like
Two types of bread
Famous Dutch taste
Only 80 calories per slice
#TOP 6

Gourmet Market Lager Rye Bread

Gourmet Market Lager Rye Bread Cover
Authentic Lager Rye Bread Pack Of 3

The Gourmet Market Rye Bread is a delightful pack of three half loaves, each weighing 18 ounces. This bread is perfect for crafting delicious sandwiches or enjoying alongside soups, meats, fish, cold cuts, and cheeses. With its unique blend of ingredients, including dark lager and rye flour, it brings a rich flavor to your meals. The combination of wheat and whole wheat flour adds to its texture, making it versatile for various culinary uses. Whether you’re preparing a hearty lunch or a light snack, this rye bread enhances every bite.

What We Like
Delicious flavor profile
Versatile for meals
Convenient pack size
Great for sandwiches
#TOP 7

Martin's 100% Whole Wheat Potato Bread

Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc.
3 Bags
Martin's 100% Whole Wheat Potato Bread Cover
Martin's Famous Pastry 100% Whole Wheat Potato Bread- 16 Slice 20 oz. Bag (3 Bags)

Martin's Whole Wheat Bread is a delicious option made entirely from whole wheat flour, making it a healthy choice for your family. You can order it in packs of two, three, or four bags, giving you flexibility based on your needs. Each slice offers a great taste that everyone will enjoy, perfect for sandwiches or toast. With 15 grams of whole grains per serving, this bread supports a nutritious diet while being low in calories and saturated fat. Enjoy the wholesome goodness of this bread without compromising on flavor.

What We Like
100% whole wheat
Great family taste
Flexible ordering options
Low in calories

New Grains Gluten-Free Sourdough Bread

2 Pound (Pack of 1)
New Grains Gluten-Free Sourdough Bread Cover
New Grains Artisan Sourdough Round Bread | Gluten Free Bread, Delicious Sourdough Taste with Fluffy Chewy Texture and Crisp Tanned Crust | Bread Fresh for Simple Snacks and Tasty Sandwiches | 1 Pack

New Grains Gluten-Free Sourdough Bread is a San-Francisco-style sourdough loaf that is gluten-free, wheat-free, dairy-free, soy-free, and peanut-free. It comes sliced with a chewy crust and includes pure psyllium husk powder, which assists in promoting regularity and intestinal health. Customers have praised the bread for its great taste and texture, although some have complained about the shipping method.

What We Like
Celiac safe
Gluten and guilt-free
Diet-friendly
Good taste and texture
Promotes regularity and intestinal health
#TOP 9

New Grains Artisan Sourdough Rectangular Bread

2 Pack
New Grains Artisan Sourdough Rectangular Bread Cover
New Grains Artisan Sourdough Rectangular Bread | Gluten Free Bread, Delicious Sourdough Taste with Fluffy Chewy Texture & Crisp Tanned Crust | Bread Fresh for Simple Snacks and Tasty Sandwiches | 2pk

New Grains Sourdough Bread is a certified gluten-free artisan bread handcrafted with care to deliver the perfect sourdough flavor. Its mildly sour taste, chewy texture, and tangy notes make it versatile for snacks, sandwiches, or recipes. With no artificial ingredients, it caters to various dietary restrictions. The pre-sliced convenience allows for easy enjoyment in various ways, such as toasting, sandwiches, or even freezing for future use.

What We Like
Certified Gluten-Free
Handcrafted with Care
Perfect Sourdough Flavor
#TOP 10

Nature's Own Honey Wheat Bread

Nature's Own
10215080
Nature's Own Honey Wheat Bread Cover
Nature's Own Honey Wheat, Honey Wheat Sandwich Bread, 20 oz Loaf

Nature's Own Honey Wheat is a delicious sandwich bread that comes in a convenient 20 oz loaf. Its soft slices are lightly sweetened with honey, making it perfect for elevating your sandwiches. You can enjoy it with honey ham or classic peanut butter and jelly for a delightful meal. Plus, you can feel good knowing that this bread contains no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors, and it’s free from high fructose corn syrup. This means you can savor every bite without worrying about unnecessary additives.

What We Like
Soft, sweet flavor
No artificial ingredients
Versatile for various sandwiches
Convenient size
Buying Guide Image

Everything You Need to Know About Potato Sandwich Bread

Introduction

When it comes to making the perfect potato sandwich, the bread you choose can make all the difference. Whether you prefer a soft and fluffy sandwich roll or a hearty and crusty sourdough loaf, the right bread can elevate your sandwich from an ordinary meal to a culinary masterpiece. In this article, we will explore some of the key factors to consider when choosing potato sandwich bread, and provide some helpful tips and suggestions along the way.

Texture and Structure

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing potato sandwich bread is the texture and structure of the loaf. For a classic potato sandwich, a soft and fluffy sandwich roll or a sliced white bread is a great choice. These types of breads have a tender crumb and a delicate texture that allows the potato filling to shine. On the other hand, if you prefer a more robust and hearty sandwich, a rustic sourdough loaf or a crusty artisanal bread may be a better option. These breads have a sturdy structure and a chewy texture that can stand up to the denser and more substantial potato filling.

Flavour

Another key factor to consider when choosing potato sandwich bread is the flavour of the loaf. While a plain white sandwich roll may be the traditional choice for a potato sandwich, there are many other breads that can add interesting and complementary flavours to your sandwich. For example, a whole wheat or multigrain bread can add a nutty and earthy flavour, while a rye or pumpernickel loaf can add a spicy and tangy note. You can also experiment with flavoured breads, such as onion or garlic bread, to add a savoury and aromatic dimension to your sandwich.

Size and Shape

In addition to texture and flavour, the size and shape of the bread can also affect the overall appeal of your potato sandwich. A large and generously sized sandwich roll or loaf will provide ample space for a generous portion of potato filling, while a smaller and more compact sandwich roll or slice of bread may be more manageable and portable. You can also experiment with different shapes of bread, such as oval or round sandwich rolls, or square or rectangular slices of bread, to add visual interest and variety to your sandwich.

Toasting and Grilling

Finally, you may also want to consider whether you want to toast or grill your potato sandwich bread. Toasting or grilling the bread can add a crispy and golden texture and a slightly smoky and charred flavour to your sandwich. This can provide a nice contrast to the soft and creamy potato filling and add depth and complexity to the overall flavour of your sandwich. To toast or grill your bread, simply place it on a hot griddle or in a toaster oven until it is lightly golden and crispy.

Conclusion

In conclusion, there are many factors to consider when choosing potato sandwich bread, from the texture and structure of the loaf to the size and shape of the bread. By considering these factors and experimenting with different types of bread, you can create a delicious and satisfying potato sandwich that will delight your taste buds and satisfy your hunger. Whether you prefer a soft and fluffy sandwich roll or a hearty and crusty sourdough loaf, the right bread can make all the difference in your potato sandwich.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What makes potato bread different?

Potato bread is distinct from white bread because it contains potato flour. This makes it more calorically dense and provides more protein, fiber, and minerals. The addition of potato flour also gives potato bread a mildly richer flavor.

2. Does potato bread taste like white bread?

While potato bread is similar to mass-produced white bread in terms of texture, it has a yellow tint, thicker consistency, and a light potato flavor. However, there are variations of potato bread, such as Cherokee sweet potato bread, which incorporates sweet potatoes for a unique twist.

3. What is potato bread made of?

Potato bread is made by adding mashed potatoes to the dough, replacing some of the flour. The addition of mashed potatoes gives the bread a soft texture and a golden light crust. The taste of potato bread is similar to traditional white bread, but the potatoes enhance its overall quality.

4. Is potato bread better for you than regular bread?

Potato bread offers more nutritional value compared to white bread. It contains more fiber, protein, calcium, iron, and potassium. However, if you are concerned about calorie or sugar intake, it's important to consider that potato bread may be more calorically dense.

5. What is the point of potato bread?

Potato bread is loved worldwide for its soft and moist texture. It is perfect for making a variety of sandwiches or enjoying as toast. The presence of potato flour in the bread enhances its moisture and provides a delightful eating experience, making it a popular choice for many.

6. Why does potato bread taste so good?

The use of mashed potatoes and the starch-rich water in which the potatoes are cooked contribute to the delicious taste of potato bread. This combination creates a crumb with a tender and chewy interior, complemented by a crisp and flavorful exterior when toasted.

7. What is special about potato bread?

Potato bread has a unique quality in that the potato starches attract and hold more water than wheat starches. This makes the bread super moist and enhances its texture. Additionally, when combined with other types of flour, potato flour makes yeast dough easier to handle and shape.

8. Is potato bread a healthy bread?

Potato bread contains significantly more potassium than both whole-wheat and white bread. Potassium is important for cardiovascular health as it helps offset the negative impact of sodium by lowering blood pressure. However, it's important to consider other factors like calorie and sugar content in making a healthy choice.

Editor's Notes

During our potato sandwich bread research, we found 19 potato sandwich bread products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 74,510 customer reviews through our big data system to write the potato sandwich bread list. We found that most customers choose potato sandwich bread with an average price of $20.78.

The potato sandwich bread are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of potato sandwich bread, including Martin's Famous Pastry Shoppe, Inc., Martin's, Gourmet Market, New Grains, Nature's Own. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 61 consumers with an average rating of 4.0.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!