Best Sandwich Cookies of 2026

"I’m usually not big on sandwich cookies—even the top brands only worked for me if they were double stuffed. But these really surprised me! The cookie is packed with flavor and the filling is just right. Considering the price, they’re definitely worthy of a recommendation."

"For me, these beat the 'O' and Wmart brands, and they’re cheaper too! I’m glad I found them, along with other awesome deals on Amazon Grocery."

"I ordered these for my son, who doesn’t like chocolate, and the vanilla cream was a hit. They’re just as thick as higher-priced brands, arrived fresh and unbroken, and have a nice balance between cookie and filling. Plus, the price is great!"

"The large party pack of Oreos is a staple in my house. I love that they arrive fresh, unbroken, and full of flavor. Everyone in my family enjoys them, whether straight from the package or dunked in milk. I appreciate the reasonable price and careful delivery."

"I find these Oreos to be perfect for baking, ice cream toppings, or just snacking. The subscribe and save option guarantees freshness and the best rate, which is a huge plus for me."

"Honestly, it's hard to beat a giant package of classic Oreos. They always taste just right and arrive in great shape. I do wish there was a bit more creme in the middle, but they always satisfy my cravings. I have to hide them to keep the rest of the family from eating them all!"

"I absolutely love having these single-serve cookie packs in my pantry. The individual packaging keeps each portion fresh and makes it super easy to grab a treat without overindulging. They're perfect for lunchboxes, quick snacks, or sharing at parties. The taste is consistently delicious, and the cookies are always fresh—no more stale cookies from open bags! I think they're a great investment for anyone who wants a convenient, tasty snack."

"This variety pack is a must-have at my house! I started buying it 'for the kids,' but honestly, I find myself reaching for a pack after the gym—it's all about balance, right? The mix of classic OREO, OREO Golden, and CHIPS AHOY! means there’s something for everyone. Individually wrapped servings help with portion control and keep everything fresh. My family loves having options, and so do I."

"I did notice a few issues with my recent order. Some of the cookies arrived broken, and there was one completely sealed pack with no cookies inside. While the cookies that were there tasted fresh and the variety was good, the packaging was a bit inconsistent and the sizes were not larger than the regular ones as I expected. Still, they were convenient for on-the-go snacking."

"As someone who enjoys sharing snacks with friends, I found the package size to be bigger than expected and the cookies were fresh, unbroken, and arrived on time. I ended up sharing them because there were so many, and the value was excellent."

"I'm 66 and care more about indulging in what I love than anyone's opinion. Oreos are the best cookies—great for eating plain, mixing into ice cream, or adding to desserts. The double stuff is especially good. The packaging is easy to open, and I wholeheartedly recommend them for any treat."

"Bought these for my grandson and he absolutely loves them. They're always fresh, delicious, and arrive in perfect condition. Honestly, I could see us getting these on subscribe and save every week because you can never go wrong with double stuff Oreos."

"These cookies are so delicious that I actually keep them hidden from my family and friends. They are just that good—I really don’t want to share!"

"I love the creamy peanut butter filling, which makes them taste just like my favorite Girl Scout cookies. I’m thrilled I found them online since I can’t find them in stores nearby."

"My kids devour these cookies so quickly that I have to stash them in the freezer. They taste even better chilled—truly a hit in our house!"

"These cookies are incredibly crunchy and have a delicious peanut butter taste. They're not overly sweet and they don't crumble apart as you eat them. I think they're even better than Nutter Butter cookies. Highly recommend!"

"Honestly, I could not stop eating these! The flavor is spot on and they're not too sweet. They really remind me of Nutter Butters. I finished the whole box way too fast."

"While these cookies are crunchy and have a good filling, they're not quite as good as the Girl Scout peanut butter cookies. Still, for the price, they're a great alternative and taste pretty good."

"I love that these cookies are individually wrapped, so they stay fresh and crisp. They're ideal for packing in lunchboxes or as snacks on the go. No more worries about stale cookies!"

"I handed these out for Halloween to my neighbors, delivery drivers, and even my hairdresser. Everyone enjoyed them! I was happy to see they weren't crushed during shipping and the 4-pack size is just right for a chocolate treat. I’ll definitely be buying more for holiday gifts!"

"These Oreos were a total hit with my students! It's their favorite snack prize and a great choice for classroom rewards. Quality is consistently good and the kids are always excited to get them."

"I honestly didn’t expect much, but these cookies are shockingly delicious—like a mash-up between a Nutter Butter, an Oreo, and Reese’s. My wife instantly picked up on the flavor combo, saying it tasted just like an Oreo with Reese’s inside. They also arrived fresh, which made the experience even better."

"I’m usually wary of new Oreo flavors, but these blew me away with their peanut buttery, chocolatey goodness. The creamy filling is smooth and rich, and once I realized the Reese’s connection, everything clicked—especially my lack of self-control. I finished the whole package in a day and have zero regrets. If you love peanut butter and chocolate, you need these in your life."

"The delivery was great and the driver was super polite. The cookie itself is like a crunchy candy bar, so good that I’ve already ordered another one. Definitely exceeded my expectations."

"These have become a holiday must-have in my home. The bright lemon and creamy white chocolate are perfectly balanced, making them both refreshing and indulgent. I love keeping them on hand for guests or as an everyday treat, and they've always been fresh and a crowd favorite."

"My family and I were blown away by these cookies! The light lemony taste with just a hint of zest is absolutely sublime, and everyone agreed we'd be happy to buy them again."

"I've always enjoyed Milano cookies and this new flavor is no exception. The texture is smooth and they're easy to enjoy as a quick snack or in lunchboxes. My only issue was that a lot of cookies arrived broken, but the delicious flavor and quality made up for it."

"I keep a variety of snacks on my porch for delivery drivers, and these Oreo Mini Mix packs are always the first to disappear. The individual bags are super convenient and the cookies are fresh and perfectly crunchy. Both the Original and Golden flavors are a hit, making this pack a consistent favorite for anyone looking for a quick, tasty treat."

"These mini Oreos are perfect for packing in lunches or grabbing on the go. I love that they stay fresh in the individual bags and appreciate the choice between chocolate and golden varieties. They deliver the classic Oreo taste in a small, satisfying portion."

"As a huge Oreo fan, I go through these quickly, especially since my little brothers love them too. The value is great and they're always fresh, but I wish there was a more even split between the Original and Golden flavors. Still, they're an excellent snack for anyone who loves Oreos!"