Best Sandwich Cookies of 2025

"I find the 365 Chocolate Sandwich Creme Cookies to be my ultimate indulgence, offering a scrumptious treat for chocolate lovers! The rich and decadent chocolate flavor makes every bite delightful. The perfect balance of creamy filling and chocolate cookies is hard to resist, and I love the generous 20 Ounce pack size that allows sharing with friends and family. They’re suitable for any occasion, whether as a quick snack or a dessert."

"These cookies are absolutely delicious! I appreciate the vanilla taste of the cookies and the cake flavor of the crème, reminiscent of birthday cake ice cream. They have just the right amount of crunch and are a great treat with afternoon tea or coffee."

"When I travel to the U.S., I always visit Whole Foods. I’m thrilled that Canadians can now access Whole Foods brands through Amazon.ca. The 365 Everyday Value Creme Cookies are exceptional. They use cane sugar, which noticeably enhances the taste. They are Non-GMO, Kosher, and Vegetarian, making them a great fit for various dietary preferences. In my opinion, these are probably the best commercially produced cookies around, offering great value for the quality."

"I sent these cookies to my daughter when she was feeling grouchy, and she absolutely loved them! She was so giddy about receiving them and said they taste great. She enjoys putting them in her cookie jar and plans to buy more once they run out!"

"I’m not usually a fan of store-bought cookies, but I found these Happy Belly Vanilla Sandwich Creme Cookies to be quite satisfying. The outer layers remind me of dense animal crackers, and the inner vanilla creme is just right—not overly sweet, which I appreciate. I can see myself buying them occasionally."

"These cookies are really good and the price is excellent! However, I must say, the packaging could definitely be better. Keep a ziplock handy if you don't finish them in one go!"

"I couldn't resist eating them before snapping a pic for my review! The quality, quantity, and price are unbeatable—I'll definitely be back for more. The creamy peanut butter filling and nice texture of the cookie made it all worth it!"

"I always reach for these cookies as a little treat with my coffee or ice cream. They arrive fresh every time, and I love that I can enjoy a few without worrying about my diabetes. The texture is just right for me, and at this fantastic price, I couldn't be happier!"

"I was skeptical at first, but I took a chance on these cookies when my beloved Nutter Butters were unavailable. I was blown away! As soon as I tried the peanut butter creme, I was hooked. They taste just like my favorite cookies, but without the overwhelming sweetness. I'm officially a fan and won't look back!"

"I found the cookies to be delicious and a great variety. The two-cookie packs are just the right amount for my husband and me."

"I used these cookies as thank you gifts, and they were perfectly sized and wrapped. They made great additions to gift bags."

"I dressed as Cookie Monster for Halloween and handed these out. They were a big hit with all ages, but I was disappointed to find I was shorted 10 cookies in my order."

"I absolutely love these cookies! The lemon flavor is truly unique and one of my favorites."

"I was pleasantly surprised by these lemon OREOs! They pair wonderfully with my favorite teas and I recommend chilling them for the best experience."

"Though I prefer chocolate OREOs, these lemon cookies are a nice change. The soft cream filling is tasty, but I found them a bit too sugary."

"As an Oreo cookie lover, I can't get enough of these! I often pull them apart to savor the filling first, or sometimes I just go for it and shove the whole thing in my mouth with some milk. I must admit, I've tried fancy cookies from around the world, but nothing beats the joy of picnic Oreos! I even received a package of Oreos as a birthday gift and let my guests have the cake while I indulged!"

"My family is obsessed with Oreos, and since they taste the same no matter where I get them, the price is the deciding factor. When we ran out, I found these at Amazon for the lowest price, and they arrived fresh and in perfect condition. Super easy choice!"

"As a stay-at-home mom with medical issues, I was craving Oreos and was thrilled when my order arrived right on time and perfectly intact! These cookies really hit the spot!"

"I absolutely love these cookies! They have a delicious vanilla taste and the crème reminds me of birthday cake ice cream. The crunch is just right!"

"These cookies used to be my go-to alternative to Oreos, but I think they have changed the recipe. The cookie part is now a bit harder and drier."

"When I visit the U.S., I always stop by Whole Foods. Now that I can order these exceptional cookies through Amazon, I'm thrilled! They use cane sugar instead of artificial sweeteners, making a noticeable difference in taste."

“I absolutely love Oreos; they're the best cookie ever! They always arrive in great condition, not broken, and are fresh and delicious. I enjoy getting them regularly through Subscribe and Save.”

“These cookies are incredibly tasty, but I had to stop buying them because the High Fructose Corn Syrup gives me heartburn. I wish they would remove that ingredient so I could enjoy them again!”

“I always have to remind myself not to eat the whole bag at once, because they are just that good! I find myself ordering more frequently.”

“I think they're Oreos with a classic taste! Some of them arrived broken, but I expected that lol. They were fresh and tasted great. I love them!”

“The flavor was great, but the packaging could have been better. I had a few broken cookies.”

“These cookies were okay, but the filling was extremely thin, making them taste more like just a chocolate cookie. I probably won't buy this type again.”

"I think everyone knows Oreos, but these have a delicious vanilla flavor that makes them a nice change."

"For me, the cookie is good, but I personally would enjoy it more with less filling... maybe I'm just getting older."

"I used to stick with regular Oreos, but I've found these to be a new favorite!"