Best Cheddar Cheese of 2026

"I made homemade nachos using this cheese and was impressed by how evenly it melted and the bold cheddar bite it delivered. It worked perfectly for layering and topping—definitely a staple for taco night and grilled cheese."

"The flavor is delicious and the price is unbeatable. I found the cheese very fresh, and the shredded pieces are just right for sprinkling on salads."

"My children are especially picky eaters, but they really enjoy this cheddar. They say it reminds them of Goldfish crackers, so it’s become a favorite in our house."

"I was curious about ordering cheese through Amazon and picked up several varieties. I found this cheddar to be moist, not overly crumbly, and perfect for nachos. For the price and taste, it’s definitely worth trying, especially if you want to sample a smaller size first."

"After some initial disappointment, I gave this cheese another shot and was pleasantly surprised by the noticeable improvement in quality. While it’s still not the very top tier, it’s now serviceable and quite enjoyable. I also noticed a big upgrade in their sliced cheese options."

"Switching from Walmart to Amazon for groceries has been a game-changer for me—Amazon’s cheddar is at least as good, if not better, than the alternatives, and the delivery is so much more reliable. I’ve had zero issues with order fulfillment or freshness, which wasn’t the case with Walmart. Now I get most of my groceries from Amazon!"

"As someone who enjoys cheese regularly, I love that I can easily slice off a piece whenever I'm craving a snack or want to make a cheese sandwich. It’s convenient and always hits the spot."

"For me, this cheddar strikes the perfect balance—it’s not too strong, but it’s not bland either. The flavor is just right for daily use, and I don’t feel the need to overanalyze it."

"I was pleasantly surprised by the creamy texture and how well it melts in my sandwiches. Plus, it’s a great value for the price."

"This shredded cheese blend has become a staple in my family’s kitchen. We especially love mixing it into mashed potatoes—it just takes them to another level."

"I appreciate the perfect balance of cheeses in this blend. It’s so handy for a variety of dishes and saves me the hassle of grating cheese myself."

"The flavor is great and it melts nicely when added to hot foods. I find the quality to be better than sliced cheese."

"Whenever I'm too tired to cook, I always reach for popcorn topped with this cheese powder. It delivers an authentic, rich cheddar taste and coats every kernel perfectly. I even prefer it to the cheese packets from boxed mac and cheese—it's just so much cheesier and more flavorful."

"I've tried a lot of powdered cheese products and this one stands out for its strong cheddar flavor and versatility. I use it to make creamy sauces for macaroni and also sprinkle it over popcorn. It's truly the best powdered cheese I've tasted."

"I picked this up to save on the cost of store-bought cheese popcorn toppings. It clings well to popcorn and has a good flavor, though it's a touch sweet for my liking. If you mix in some salt and cayenne, it makes for a fantastic topping!"

"As a longtime cheese enthusiast, I was truly impressed by the exceptional taste and creamy sharpness of Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar. The cheese boasts remarkable complexity and a smooth, firm texture that's both easy to slice and enjoyable to eat. I also appreciate the thoughtful parchment packaging and sustainable sourcing from grass-fed cows. This cheese elevates every dish and snack—I wholeheartedly recommend it!"

"Being a cheese connoisseur, I can say the Dubliner masterfully blends the sharpness of cheddar with the nutty sweetness of Swiss and Parmesan. The result is an outstanding, versatile cheese that works well in countless recipes. I genuinely love it!"

"This cheese is always a treat—the perfect addition to charcuterie boards, sandwiches, or just on its own. I always look forward to it going on sale, as it's some of the best cheese I’ve had outside of Ireland."

"I'm always looking for bold flavors, and this cheddar really hits the spot. It’s my go-to for a quick snack with chutney and hearty bread. Not a fancy cheese, but definitely delivers on taste!"

"For me, the texture, sharpness, and overall quality of this cheddar are unmatched. I absolutely love it melted into a grilled cheese sandwich with tomato and onion—pure heaven!"

"As someone who loves cheese, I hesitated about the price at first, but I’m glad I gave it a try. Pairs perfectly with my favorite crackers—I highly recommend it to fellow cheese enthusiasts."

"I’m a huge fan of this cheese—the flavor is outstanding, melts perfectly, and never upsets my stomach like other brands. Organic Valley products are always reliable, but this raw cheddar truly stands out for freshness and taste!"

"As someone with lactose intolerance, I can actually enjoy this unpasteurized sharp cheddar without any issues. The taste is delicious, and I highly recommend it if you need a gentler cheese."

"While I normally prefer extra sharp cheddar, I still appreciate the nutritional value and overall pleasant flavor of this cheese. It’s a little milder than expected, but still quite good."