Best Cheddar Cheese of 2025

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 15, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Cheddar cheese is a popular type of cheese that originated in the village of Cheddar in Somerset, England. It is a hard, smooth, and creamy cheese that is often used in sandwiches, burgers, and as a topping for baked potatoes. Cheddar cheese is made from cow's milk and comes in a variety of flavors, ranging from mild to sharp. It is a versatile cheese that can be sliced, grated, or melted and used in a wide range of recipes. Some popular variations of cheddar cheese include smoked cheddar, white cheddar, and sharp cheddar.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder Cover #TOP 1
Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder
ftb score rating icon 9.9
The Wisconsin Cheeseman Sharp Cheddar Cheese Cover #TOP 2
The Wisconsin Cheeseman Sharp Cheddar Cheese
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp Cover #TOP 3
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Cheddar Cheese

#TOP 1

Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder

853881004878
Orange
1 Pound (Pack of 1)
Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder Cover
Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder, 1LB (Pack of 1)

Hoosier Hill Farm Cheddar Cheese Powder is a versatile and flavorful addition to any snack or meal. Sprinkle it on popcorn, pretzels, or any snack for an instant cheesy flavor. Use it to make delicious cheddar cheese sauces, marinades, and casseroles. This cheese powder is easy to use and store, and is made in the USA. Please note that it contains milk and is packaged in a facility that processes dairy, soy, peanuts, and wheat products.

What We Like
Delicious cheesy flavor
Versatile for various dishes
Easy to use on popcorn
Permanently orange-stained fingers
Lasts a long time
What We Don't Like
Sweetness may be off-putting
Not true cheddar flavor
#TOP 2

The Wisconsin Cheeseman Sharp Cheddar Cheese

1 Pound (Pack of 1)
The Wisconsin Cheeseman Sharp Cheddar Cheese Cover
The Wisconsin Cheeseman Aged Sharp Cheddar - Gourmet Wisconsin Cheddar, Tangy and Traditional Flavor, Perfect Snack for Appetizers, Charcuterie Boards, or Red and White Wine Pairings - 1 lb.

The Wisconsin Cheeseman Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a 1 lb. aged cheese that has a sharp flavor with a tangy taste of classic Wisconsin cheddar. The cheese is aged from 2 to 4 years, giving it a noble character that can only come from careful aging. This cheese is perfect for pairing with full-bodied red wines, crisp whites, and robust beers.

What We Like
Great flavor and texture
Excellent pairing with beverages
Handled with pride in packaging
Consistent quality over multiple orders
What We Don't Like
Inconsistency in taste
#TOP 3

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp Cover
Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp White 40oz Half Loaf

The Wisconsin Extra Sharp Cheddar is a standout cheese, aged for over five years to develop a deep, rich flavor with a delightful tang. This aging process enhances its sharpness, making it an excellent choice for your beer or wine tastings. You’ll find that it adds a zesty kick to sandwiches, elevating your lunch experience. Additionally, it pairs beautifully with gourmet sausage, making it a versatile option for entertaining or casual snacking. The cheese’s texture transforms over time, becoming crumbly, which can add a unique touch to your culinary creations.

What We Like
Great flavor
Excellent quality
Unique texture
Fast delivery
Transforms ordinary meals
What We Don't Like
Shipping issues
Mild flavor for age
#TOP 4

Easy Cheese Cheddar Cheese Snack

Easy Cheese Cheddar Cheese Snack Cover
Easy Cheese Cheddar Cheese Snack, 12 - 8 oz Cans

Easy Cheese Cheddar Snack is a convenient and delicious option for cheese lovers. Made with milk, whey, and real cheese culture, it offers an authentic cheddar flavor that will satisfy your taste buds. With twelve 8 oz cans in a pack, this bulk cheese keeps you well-stocked for easy entertaining. Whether you're topping cheese and crackers or other favorite snacks, this versatile product adds a burst of flavor. Plus, it's an excellent source of calcium, making it a nutritious choice for your snack time. Enjoy the convenience and great taste of Easy Cheese Cheddar Snack whenever you crave a cheesy treat.

What We Like
Great taste
High quality
Convenient for dog treats
Cost-effective
Shelf-stable product
What We Don't Like
Not the healthiest option
#TOP 5

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar Wheel

5 Pound (Pack of 1)
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Cheddar Wheel Cover
Cheddar Wheel Five Pound

The Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese Wheel offers a generous five pounds of deliciously crafted cheese, perfect for any cheese lover. Its creamy flavor and delightful springy texture will enhance your meals, whether you’re slicing it for a cheese platter or melting it over your favorite dishes. This high-quality cheddar is an excellent choice for entertaining guests or simply enjoying a snack at home. With its rich taste, you can elevate your culinary creations and indulge in the comforting qualities of this Wisconsin-made cheese.

What We Like
Outstanding taste
Great value for money
Family favorite
Convenient storage size
Good texture, easy to cut
What We Don't Like
Mild flavor, not sharp
Wax seal duration misleading
#TOP 6

Wisconsin Cheese Mart 2 Year Cheddar

Wisconsin Cheese Mart 2 Year Cheddar Cover
2 Year Cheddar 4 Pack

The Wisconsin 2 Year Cheddar is a delightful cheese that offers a sharp and bold flavor, perfect for those who appreciate rich taste. Its semi-firm to hard texture makes it versatile for various dishes or simply enjoyed on its own. The robust and smooth profile allows you to pair it effortlessly with red wines, chocolate, stout beers, and ales, enhancing your dining or snacking experience. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or enjoying a quiet evening, this cheddar brings a touch of sophistication and satisfaction to your palate.

What We Like
Excellent flavor
Great melting quality
Good for lactose-sensitive individuals
Arrives well-packaged
Strong cheddar comparison
What We Don't Like
Slightly salty for some
#TOP 7

Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar 7 oz

Generic
Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar 7 oz Cover
Tillamook Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar 7 oz

Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar offers a delightful blend of sharpness, nuttiness, and a slight tang, making it a perfect addition to your cheese platter. This cheese is crafted from cultured milk, salt, enzymes, and annatto, giving it a rich flavor profile. Shipped with gel packs, you can enjoy it fresh, no matter the season. Whether you’re serving it on a charcuterie board or pairing it with crackers and grilled sandwiches, this cheddar enhances your meal with its unique taste. Each 7 oz block is perfect for sharing or keeping all to yourself!

What We Like
Rich, sharp flavor
Convenient shipping
Versatile serving options
High-quality ingredients
#TOP 8

Generic Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs

Generic
Generic Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs Cover
Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese 2 lbs

Generic Sharp Cheddar Cheese offers a smooth and firm texture that enhances its bold flavor, making it perfect for your cheese boards or as a tasty snack. Being naturally lactose-free and gluten-free, it caters to various dietary needs, ensuring everyone can enjoy it. Its unique crumbly yet creamy consistency adds an enjoyable element to dishes and recipes. With an extra-aging process, this cheese boasts a sharper, more mature taste profile, elevating your culinary creations and snack time. You’ll find it versatile for cooking or simply enjoying on its own.

What We Like
Bold flavor
Lactose-free and gluten-free
Crumbly yet creamy
Versatile for cooking
Extra-aged for sharpness
#TOP 9

High Temp Cheddar Cheese - Local Source

High Temp Cheddar Cheese - Local Source Cover
High Temperature Cheddar Cheese - 2.5 Lb. Bag

If you're looking for a versatile cheese, the Local Source Hi Temp Cheddar is a fantastic choice. This high-temperature cheddar cheese is designed to withstand cooking without losing its flavor or texture, making it perfect for grilling, baking, or adding to your favorite dishes. Whether you're crafting a cheesy casserole or grilling up some burgers, this cheese will hold its own, ensuring a delicious taste in every bite. Plus, its convenient 2.5 lb bag means you'll have plenty on hand for all your culinary adventures.

What We Like
Great flavor and texture
Holds up well when cooked
High-quality cheese
Good value for quantity
Excellent for various recipes
What We Don't Like
Expensive compared to standard cheese
#TOP 10

Hickory Farms Smoked Cheddar Cheese Blend 3 Pack

Hickory Farms Smoked Cheddar Cheese Blend 3 Pack Cover
Hickory Farms Smoked Cheddar Cheese Blend - Savory Flavor, 7 oz Each (3 Pack)

The Hickory Farms Smoked Cheddar is a delightful cheese that enhances any gathering. With three convenient 7 oz portions, you can easily create impressive cheese boards that pair perfectly with crackers, fruits, and cured meats. This versatile cheese is great for snacking, whether you’re hosting a party or enjoying a quiet night in. Its rich, smoky flavor also adds a delicious touch to sandwiches and salads. Plus, it comes in resealable packaging, ensuring freshness and convenience for your snacking needs.

What We Like
Perfect for Christmas gatherings
Consistently satisfying
Reliable choice every year
Buying Guide Image

The Definitive Cheddar Cheese Buying Guide

Understanding the Different Types of Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar cheese is a versatile and popular type of cheese that originated in the English village of Cheddar in Somerset. It is known for its firm, dense texture and tangy, slightly sharp flavor. Cheddar is made from cow's milk and is typically aged for several months to a few years to develop its characteristic flavor and texture.

Choosing the Right Cheddar for Your Needs

When choosing a cheddar cheese, there are several factors to consider. First, think about how you will be using the cheese. Are you looking for a sharp, tangy cheddar to add flavor to a sandwich or salad? Or do you want a more mellow, creamy cheddar to melt on top of a casserole or burger? The age of the cheese can also affect its flavor and texture, so consider whether you want a young, mild cheddar or an aged, sharp cheddar.

Selecting the Best Quality Cheddar

When it comes to selecting the best quality cheddar, there are a few key things to look for. First, choose a cheese that has a smooth, even texture and a uniform color. Avoid cheeses that have cracks, wrinkles, or mottled patches on the surface. The cheese should also have a consistent, pleasant aroma and a tangy, sharp flavor.

Purchasing Cheddar Cheese

When purchasing cheddar cheese, there are a few different options to consider. You can buy cheddar cheese in blocks, slices, or shredded. Block cheddar is the most versatile option, as you can cut it into slices, shred it, or cube it for snacking. Sliced cheddar is convenient for sandwiches, while shredded cheddar is great for melting on top of dishes or adding to recipes.

Storing Cheddar Cheese

Once you have purchased your cheddar cheese, it is important to store it properly to maintain its flavor and texture. Cheddar cheese should be wrapped in wax paper or plastic wrap and stored in the refrigerator. Avoid storing the cheese in the door of the refrigerator, as this can cause it to dry out. Cheddar cheese will last for several weeks in the refrigerator, but it can also be frozen for longer storage.

Enjoying Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar cheese is a delicious and versatile ingredient that can be enjoyed in many different ways. Use it to add flavor to sandwiches, salads, and casseroles, or enjoy it on its own as a snack. Cheddar is also great for melting, so try using it to make grilled cheese sandwiches, quesadillas, or mac and cheese. Experiment with different ages and styles of cheddar to find the one that best suits your tastes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Why is cheddar cheese different from other cheese?

Cheddar cheese is distinct from other cheeses because it is often industrially made in block form and matured quickly in warmer temperatures. This process produces moister cheeses with a sharp tang but less complexity compared to traditionally made cheeses.

2. What's the difference between cheddar and original cheese?

Cheddar cheese is a hard English cheese, while American cheese is a smooth and creamy processed cheese. Cheddar cheese has more flavor, whereas American cheese is less expensive as it is artificially processed instead of naturally aged.

3. Why is cheddar cheese so cheap?

Cheddar cheese may be relatively inexpensive due to a surplus of dairy and other food products in the United States agriculture industry. This surplus has led to lower prices for cheddar cheese and other food items.

4. What are the two types of cheddar cheese?

There are two main types of cheddar cheese. Young cheddar is mild, creamy, and smooth with a slightly buttery and melty texture. Aged cheddar becomes more nutty, crumbly, and sharp in flavor. Both types have their own unique characteristics and are enjoyed by different preferences.

5. Is cheddar cheese healthier than normal cheese?

Cheddar cheese has higher levels of saturated fat compared to other dairy products. Consuming foods high in saturated fats can increase cholesterol levels and the risk of cardiovascular disease. Therefore, it is important to consume cheddar cheese in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

6. What is the difference between cheddar and New York cheddar?

Extra sharp cheddar cheese requires a longer aging period of 18 months to two years. It offers an assertive flavor with a sharp bitterness and crumbles or breaks when cut. New York cheddar cheese, on the other hand, is much sharper and has a hint of smoke for additional flavor.

Editor's Notes

During our cheddar cheese research, we found 24 cheddar cheese products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 88,275 customer reviews through our big data system to write the cheddar cheese list. We found that most customers choose cheddar cheese with an average price of $29.33.

The cheddar cheese are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of cheddar cheese, including Hoosier Hill Farm, The Wisconsin Cheeseman, Wisconsin Cheese Mart, EASY CHEESE, Local Source. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 1,990 consumers with an average rating of 4.9.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!

Cheddar Cheese Comparison Table

#TOP1
#TOP2
#TOP3
#TOP4
#TOP5
#TOP6
#TOP7
#TOP8
#TOP9
#TOP10
Brand Hoosier Hill Farm The Wisconsin Cheeseman Wisconsin Cheese Mart EASY CHEESE Wisconsin Cheese Mart Wisconsin Cheese Mart Generic Generic Local Source Hickory Farms
Unit Count 16.0 Ounce 16 Ounce 40.0 Ounce - 80 Ounce 32.0 Ounce 7.0 Ounce 2 Fluid Ounces 40.0 Ounce 3 Count
Variety Cheddar Cheddar Cheddar - Cheddar Cheddar Cheddar Cheddar Cheddar Cheese
Item Form Powder Bar Bar spread Bar - Cheese Block Cheddar Cube Bar
Item Weight - 1 Pounds - 6 Pounds 5 Pounds 2 Pounds 7 ounces 2 Pounds - -
FTB Score
ftb score rating icon 9.9
ftb score rating icon 9.8
ftb score rating icon 9.6
ftb score rating icon 9.6
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.5
ftb score rating icon 9.4
ftb score rating icon 9.3
ftb score rating icon 9.2
Where to Buy