Best American Cheeses of 2026

The Cooper Sharp Yellow Cheese offers a rich and unique sharp taste, crafted from real milk and aged cheese. This pasteurized processed cheese is versatile, allowing you to grate it for recipes, slice it for sandwiches, melt it for sauces, or cut it into cubes for snacks. Whether you're looking to add a flavorful topping, garnish your dishes, or enjoy it on its own, this cheese fits the bill. It arrives refrigerated to ensure freshness, making it a convenient and tasty choice for your kitchen needs.

Horizon Organic Cheese Slices make it simple to add a tasty touch to your meals. These pre-sliced cheese pieces are ready to use, so you can quickly enhance sandwiches, burgers, or snacks without any prep work. Being 95% organic, this cheese offers a healthier choice if you prefer natural ingredients. The convenient pack contains 12 slices, giving you plenty to enjoy and store for future use. With Horizon Organic Cheese Slices, you get a quick, wholesome way to brighten up your dishes anytime.

Cooper Cheese is a 5 lb. block of American cheese made with milk. This cheese by Cooper is perfect for sandwiches, burgers, and macaroni and cheese. The creamy texture and rich flavor of Cooper Cheese will elevate your dishes to the next level. Whether you are melting it on a grilled cheese sandwich or sprinkling it over nachos, Cooper Cheese adds a delicious touch to your meals.

Borden Fat Free Cheese Slices offer a convenient way to enjoy cheese without the extra fat, making them a great choice if you want to maintain a healthier diet. Each pack contains sixteen 3/4-ounce slices, providing plenty of servings for sandwiches, snacks, or recipes. Being fat-free means you can savor the cheesy flavor without worrying about added calories from fat. Additionally, these slices are gluten-free, so they fit well into gluten-sensitive diets. This product is perfect if you want an easy, tasty, and diet-friendly cheese option.

The Racconto Parmesan Grated is an American cheese product that offers the convenience of pre-grated Parmesan. This makes it easy for you to sprinkle over pasta, salads, or soups without the hassle of grating. The cheese comes from the trusted Racconto brand, known for quality dairy products. Its grated form saves you time in the kitchen, allowing you to enhance your meals quickly and effortlessly. Perfect for everyday cooking, this cheese adds a rich, savory flavor to your dishes, making meal preparation simpler and more enjoyable.

The Borden Lactose Free Singles offer a convenient pack of three, each containing 12 slices of American cheese. If you are lactose intolerant, these cheese slices allow you to enjoy the creamy taste without discomfort. Each 8-ounce pack provides enough slices for multiple meals or snacks, making it easy to stock up. Plus, the cheese is gluten-free, so it fits well into gluten-sensitive diets. With Borden Lactose Free Singles, you get a tasty, versatile cheese option that suits your dietary needs and adds convenience to your kitchen.

The Cooper Sharp American Cheese offers a rich, bold flavor thanks to its aging process of over 100 days, giving your meals a tasty boost. Made with real milk and natural ingredients, this cheese melts smoothly and tastes fresh, making it a reliable choice for your cooking needs. Whether you want to slice it for sandwiches, grate it for recipes, or cube it for snacks, this cheese is convenient and versatile. It’s crafted in the USA with care, making it a great option for both home cooks and professional chefs who want quality and ease in the kitchen.

The FEDOLOY Labne Cheese offers a carefully chosen product sourced from dedicated farmers worldwide, ensuring quality and authenticity you can trust. This cheese contains no hydrogenated fats, which means it is a healthier option for your diet, helping you avoid harmful trans fats. It also does not include high-fructose corn syrup, making it a cleaner choice free from unnecessary added sugars. Additionally, the absence of added MSG means you can enjoy the cheese without worrying about artificial flavor enhancers. Overall, FEDOLOY Labne Cheese provides a natural and wholesome option for your meals and snacks.

The Shullsburg Creamery American Cheese offers you a convenient way to enjoy classic American cheese with ease. This product comes with 120 pre-cut slices, making it simple to grab the perfect portion without any hassle. The cheese is America's favorite, ensuring a familiar and tasty choice for your sandwiches, snacks, or recipes. Plus, the large 5-pound loaf is budget-friendly, giving you plenty of cheese to use over time while saving money. Whether you're feeding a family or stocking up for gatherings, this cheese loaf combines convenience and value.

The Carr Valley Bread Cheese offers a unique cheese experience made right in Wisconsin, known for its rich dairy tradition. Crafted from cow's milk, this semi-soft cheese provides a smooth and enjoyable texture, perfect for snacking or cooking. As an award-winning cheese, it guarantees quality and flavor that stands out. Each pack includes four 10-ounce portions, giving you plenty to share or enjoy over time. With Carr Valley Bread Cheese, you get a delicious and versatile cheese that adds convenience and taste to your meals.