Best Low Carb Bagels of 2025

"I am terrible at reading reviews, and this time it really backfired. These bagels are AWFUL. I wasted $26 on them since they are non-returnable. They taste like moldy cardboard. Don't waste your money; just eat a real bagel once a week!"

"Initially, I found the texture squishy and eggy, but after toasting it, it became fantastic! I often make bagel pizzas with toppings, and it has become a staple for my lunch. As a VSG patient, I can only eat a quarter at a time, but they satisfy my bread cravings without making me feel stuffed!"

"I've tried all the ThinSlim products, and for keto, I think they are quite good! However, I noticed that some people say they taste cardboardy or spongy because they’re not preparing them correctly. The key is to thaw them properly and toast them in a pan with butter for the best results!"

“I think the taste is fantastic! Nothing beats them halved and toasted with butter alongside yogurt or quiche. I'm really satisfied with my purchase and will definitely be ordering again.”

“I was quite disappointed when I realized I only received three bagels for $16. They were okay—chewy and a bit salty for my taste—but I won't be buying them again because of the price.”

“As a bagel lover on a low-carb diet, I was excited to try these. Unfortunately, I found them moist, rubbery, and too chewy. It was a disappointing purchase, and I feel like I've wasted my money.”

"I just received my bagels and started my low carb journey over a week ago. Bread is my weakness, so giving it up is a challenge. I was excited to find these bagels with only 4 net carbs each. I prepared for the worst but was pleasantly surprised! I toasted my first bagel and topped it with 1 egg and sausage—it was sooooooo good! It tasted just like a regular bagel with no aftertaste or weird texture. This will definitely help my keto journey, so order these before I buy them all!"

"After tasting bagels that someone else bought, I decided to order them myself. Unfortunately, the product I received was not what I expected—different company, different specifications, and not as high quality, yet at a higher price. I was so disappointed that I almost gave up on ordering keto bagels online. But after receiving the correct bagels from the right seller, I changed my rating to 5 stars. They are very good and a healthy option, especially with cream cheese for breakfast!"

"Though I thought the bagels were pretty good for being low carb, they are not truly keto-friendly since they're still made of flour. I rated them a 3 out of 5 because they need more cinnamon and raisins. They are a bit pricey for 3 bagels, especially since they say a serving is half a bagel. Overall, the taste isn't bad—I just prefer more flavor."

"I recently started a low carb lifestyle and was surprised by the variety of bread replacements available. For me, Sola bagels are the best and among the lowest priced options. They don’t taste exactly like real bagels, but as an occasional treat, they’re fantastic. Toasted, they are absolutely delicious!"

"I find these bagels to be amazing! They taste just like regular bagels but without the carbs. I’m really happy with this product!"

"I gave the plain Sola bagels 4 stars. They aren’t quite as good as regular bagels, but since I can’t enjoy those anymore, these are a nice alternative. They have a good texture and only 7 grams of carbs. I’m ordering more right after I finish this review!"

"I really enjoy Chompie's bagels. The texture is fantastic and they remind me of the bagels I miss. While there's a slight sweetness, I’ve gotten used to it over time. I appreciate the sesame seed topping, and they toast beautifully. After ten years without bagels, I’m thrilled to have these back in my life!"

"Although I keep trying to find good keto-friendly bagels, I have to say this one has a spongy texture that doesn't quite match a true bagel. I tried slicing them thin for toasting, and it worked better than another brand I tried. I’ll continue to eat these, but I can't fully recommend them yet."

"Being a New York girl, I have high standards for bagels. These are fluffy and moist, with a nice chew. They’re slightly sweet, reminiscent of a Montreal bagel, which is different for me but I’m warming up to it. After trying several other brands, I find these to be a masterpiece. I’ll definitely be ordering more!"

"I was really looking forward to trying these low calorie, low carb pumpernickel bagels, but they turned out to be a disappointment. They have no flavor and, when toasted, they feel like cardboard. I wouldn't recommend them."

"I was curious about these bagels, but where is the pumpernickel flavor? They hardly taste like it at all."

"The flavor of these bagels was poorly executed. Also, their size was unexpected; they're less than 1/2 inch thick, making it difficult to cut them in half."

"I was very surprised by how delicious these were! While I won’t be buying them again because $20 a bag is a bit steep, if budget isn't an issue, GET THESE! Yum!"

"These make it possible to enjoy tuna and crackers or cheese and crackers. I rated them a 4 because the serving size is small. They are a bit on the expensive side for what you get."

"I absolutely LOVE these as a snack or meal addition. They are very crunchy and tasty, although I couldn’t quite discern the flavor. Nevertheless, I will definitely buy them again!"

“I was so excited to try these bagels! They arrived fresh and soft, and I must say, they taste better than any other brand I've tried. I really thought I was throwing money away, but these are worth every penny.”

“I just received my blueberry bagels a few days ago, and I was pleasantly surprised. They were soft and toasted perfectly. The taste is still under consideration for me, but they weren’t off-putting. I look forward to trying them again with just butter to savor their true flavor.”

“I’ve tried several brands of low-carb bagels, but these are definitely the best. While they don’t taste exactly like NYC bagels, they are more than worthy to enjoy with cream cheese and coffee. I will definitely be purchasing these again!”

"I find these bagels fantastically sturdy and perfect for my ketogenic diet. I enjoy broiling them with butter and garlic, or using them as hamburger buns and for deli sandwiches. They truly satisfy my bagel cravings."

"I really like the taste, but they're a bit chewier compared to full carb bagels. The problem arises with the packaging; every time I order, they arrive smashed. I’ve been cutting them in half to make sandwiches or pizza crusts. I would appreciate it if they could improve the packaging!"

"To be honest, these bagels are not worth the price I paid. I expected to love them, but they fell short of my expectations."

"I really loved these snacks! I bought them for so long, but now I can't find them anywhere. Please bring them back!"

"These were a definite no for me. The taste and texture were just horrible. I couldn't even finish one and ended up throwing them away."