AmishTastes

4.4 Fact checked

Buy on Amazon

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

When purchasing a product, price is the consumer's primary concern. At present, AmishTastes has 123 products for sale. AmishTastes products range in price from $14.75 to $55.99, and the average price of all the products is about $36.57.

We found that most of the AmishTastes products are manufactured by Kutztown Soda, Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop, and Walnut Creek. The manufacturers provide AmishTastes with a steady supply of products, and they have a good cooperative relationship with each other.

You can confidently purchase AmishTastes products from the seller AmishTastes. The brand holds an average rating of 4.4, testifying to its excellent reputation.

AmishTastes Best Sellers

Last Updated: Jan 12, 2025

AmishTastes Mini Whoopie Pie 20ct Variety Box

Dessert Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; AmishTastes Shady Maple Mini Whoopie Pie 20-Ct. Variety Box (4x each Chocolate, Pumpkin, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Raspberry, Red Velvet)

Serving Suggestion: Serve with milk or a freshly brewed hot coffee - yum!

Each mini whoopie is approximately 2-2.25" diameter in size; Homemade by the famous Shady Maple Bakery in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Individually-wrapped whoopie pies, baked with a wonderful homemade flavor

Packed in a bakery-style white box of heavy cardboard for excellent crush protection during shipping

AmishTastes Kutztown "Nix Besser" White Birch Beer, Favorite Amish Drink, 24 Oz. Bottles (Pack of 4)

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; This premium White Birch Beer is non-alcoholic and has a smooth, rich texture with an old-fashioned flavor

Share a frosty mug with your special someone and just watch them fall in love

Made with pure cane sugar; No HFCS, no dye food colorings, and no caffeine

PA Dutch Amish drink; Made with the same original recipe for the past century

Discover the quality that comes straight from Pennsylvania Amish country

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Homemade Whoopie Pies, Chocolate, Favorite Amish Food, 12 Count (Pack of 2)

Snack Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Children love them; Wow your guests! These Amish-style snacks are individually wrapped and pack a wonderful homemade flavor

Each whoopie is about 3 inch diameter in size; Homemade by the famous Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop on Gibbons Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Great for lunches, dinner desserts, and as a quick pick-me-up snack

Serving Suggestion: Serve with milk or a freshly brewed hot coffee - yum!

Packed in a bakery-style white box of heavy cardboard for excellent crush protection during shipping

Ingredients: Flour, sugar, water, buttermilk, oil, cocoa, egg yolks, soda, salt, vanilla. Filling: sugar, shortening, flour, egg whites, vanilla. ALLERGENS: WHEAT, EGGS, MILK, SOY.

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Homemade Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie, Favorite Amish Food, 9" Diameter/28 Oz. (Pack of 2)

Dessert Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; This premium, homemade, "gooey" Shoofly Pie is baked by the Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop in Pennsylvania's Amish country

For pies made by Smucker's Bird-in-Hand Bakery along Rt. 340, search Amazon for item B09XC2YMVT

This Wet-Bottom Style Shoofly Pie with Crumb Top Is a Favorite Amish and Mennonite Dessert

Each 6” Pie provides 3-4 servings; Each 9" Pie provides around 7 servings

Can be frozen for long storage; Packed in a white bakery-style box of heavy cardboard to help ensure safe shipping

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Homemade Whoopie Pies, Chocolate Peanut Butter Lovers, Favorite Amish Food (Pack of 12)

Snack Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Children love them; Wow your guests! These Amish-style snacks are individually wrapped and pack a wonderful homemade flavor

Each whoopie is about 3" diameter in size; Homemade by the famous Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop on Gibbons Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Great for lunches, dinner desserts, and as a quick pick-me-up snack

Serving Suggestion: Serve with milk or a freshly brewed hot coffee - yum!

Packed in a bakery-style white box of heavy cardboard for excellent crush protection during shipping

AmishTastes Soft Drinks Variety Box (Birch Beer, Black Cherry, Orange Cream, Red Cream), Kutztown "Nix Besser" PA Dutch Amish Style, 96 Oz.

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; Includes 1 bottle each Birch Beer, Black Cherry, Orange Cream, Red Cream sodas

Premium Kutztown sodas are caffeine-free and produced with the same original, high-quality recipe for the past century

Made with pure cane sugar; No HFCS, no dye food colorings, and no caffeine

PA Dutch specialty drink; Made with the same original recipe for the past century

Discover the quality that comes straight from Pennsylvania Amish country

AmishTastes Walnut Creek Canned Beef Chunks, All Natural, Heat & Serve, 14.5 Oz. (Pack of 2)

Canned & Packaged Beef

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

2pack

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie Fun Food Box, 60 Oz.

Dessert Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Frannie’s Sparkling Very Vanilla Creme, Protected With High-Density Foam, 12 Oz. (12 Ounce (Case of 24))

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Walnut Creek Canned Boneless Chicken Pieces, All Natural, Heat & Serve, 14.5 Oz. (Pack of 2)

Canned & Packaged Chicken

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Sarsaparilla Soda, Kutztown "Nix Besser" PA Dutch Style, 24 Oz. (Pack of 12)

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; Sarsaparilla Soda has a rich and creamy texture

A caffeine-free PA Dutch Amish favorite drink

Made with cane sugar; No HFCS, no dye food colorings, and no caffeine

Made with the finest ingredients, using the same original recipe for the past century

Discover the quality that comes straight from Pennsylvania Amish country

AmishTastes Diet Birch Beer, Kutztown "Nix Besser" PA Dutch Style, 24 Oz. (Pack of 4)

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; Diet Birch Beer is caffeine-free and has a smooth, rich texture with an old-fashioned flavor

PA Dutch specialty drink; Made with the same original recipe for the past century

This Diet Birch Beer is so delicious you'll forget you're drinking diet soda!

Discover the quality that comes straight from Pennsylvania Amish country

Contains no high-fructose corn syrup and no caffeine

AmishTastes Walnut Creek Canned Boneless Turkey Pieces, All Natural, Heat & Serve, 14.5 Oz. (Pack of 2)

Packaged & Canned Meats

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Homemade Whoopie Pie Box, Valentine Lovers 6 Chocolate & 6 Red Velvet (Box of 12)

Snack Cakes

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Children love them; Wow your guests! These Amish-style snacks are individually wrapped and pack a wonderful homemade flavor

Each whoopie is about 3" diameter in size; Homemade by the famous Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop on Gibbons Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

12ct Valentines Day Lover's Box includes 6 Chocolate and 6 Red Velvet whoopie pies; Absolutely delectable!

Serving Suggestion: Serve with milk or a freshly brewed hot coffee - yum!

Packed in a bakery-style white box of heavy cardboard for excellent crush protection during shipping

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Homemade Whoopie Pies, Oatmeal, Favorite Amish Food (Pack of 18)

Snack Pies

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Children love them; Wow your guests! These Amish-style snacks are individually wrapped and pack a wonderful homemade flavor

Each whoopie is about 3" diameter in size; Homemade by the famous Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop on Gibbons Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Great for lunches, dinner desserts, and as a quick pick-me-up snack

Serving Suggestion: Serve with milk or a freshly brewed hot coffee - yum!

Packed in a bakery-style white box of heavy cardboard for excellent crush protection during shipping

AmishTastes Downey's All-Natural Original Honey Butter, Favorite Amish Food, 8 Oz. (Pack of 2)

Honey

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; A fresh-made, Amish-style food from Lancaster County, PA

This pack includes 2 tubs of Original Honey Butter, made with all-natural ingredients

Clean Label Food: No Sugar, No Preservatives, No Artificial Colors, No HFCS

Wonderful on Toast, Bagels, and Croissants

Treat your family to the best

AmishTastes Root Beer, Kutztown "Nix Besser" PA Dutch Style, 24 Oz. (Pack of 4)

Sodas

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; Kutztown Root Beer is a PA Dutch specialty drink

This premium Root Beer has a smooth, creamy texture and old-fashioned root beer flavor

Made with pure cane sugar; No HFCS, no dye food colorings, and no caffeine

PA Dutch specialty drink; Made with the same original recipe for the past century

Discover the quality that comes straight from Pennsylvania Amish country

AmishTastes PA Dutch John Cope's Toasted, Dried Sweet Corn, 3.75 Oz. (Pack of 6)

Corn Meals

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Mrs. Miller's Beef Flavored Soup Base, Gluten-Free, No MSG, 12 oz. (Pack of 2)

Packaged Beef Soups

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

AmishTastes Golden Canned Corn, Famous John Cope's PA Dutch Style, 15 Oz. (Pack of 6)

Canned Corn

Buy on Amazon Find on eBay

Made in the USA; Pack of 6 Cans

Item Weight - 15 oz.; Each can provides 4-6 servings

Directions: No further soaking or cooking is necessary; The corn is seasoned mildly.

Add some butter and salt and serve hot; Mmmm, scrumptious, delicious!

Lancaster Pennsylvania Amish food at its best

AmishTastes FAQs

Is AmishTastes Legit?

Yes, AmishTastes is a legitmate brand on Amazon. After conducting a comprehensive analysis of 460 customer reviews for AmishTastes products on Amazon, we have determined its average rating. Offering great value and satisfying quality, AmishTastes has achieved a respectable rating of 4.4 from many customers, showing that its products meet customer expectations. While there may have been minor issues reported occasionally, overall, it is safe to make purchases from AmishTastes on Amazon.

Amazon has strict policies and safety measures in place that ensure only legitimate sellers and products are allowed on their platform. It also provides a secure payment gateway and offers buyer protection, ensuring your transaction is safe. In the unlikely event that there's an issue with your purchase, Amazon's customer service and return policies are designed to protect your interests.

How to find more AmishTastes products?

If you're interested in AmishTastes and want to find more AmishTastes products, you can follow the steps below:

Go back to FindThisBest's homepage.
Type AmishTastes in the search box and hit Enter to see the search results.
Find and click the correct AmishTastes to go to the new page.
Select the products you want in the AmishTastes buying guide, and take a glance at the prices and features of the products.
View the products interest you on Amazon to read the customer reviews and check the ratings. Besides, you can hit the "brand" to find more AmishTastes products.

How does findthisbest choose the top AmishTastes products?

We analyze millions of AmishTastes products reviews and customer reviews to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We have a professional team with decades of experience to test the products, which can help ensure that we provide our readers with accurate advice and best recommendations.

How can I purchase AmishTastes products via FindThisBest?

Go to the AmishTastes page.
Select the product you want in the AmishTastes buying guide, and then view the product on Amazon. For example, if you are interested in the top 1 product AmishTastes Mini Whoopie Pie 20ct Variety Box, you can view it on Amazon page.
Place your order on Amazon.

Who are the manufacturers of the AmishTastes products?

Most of the AmishTastes products are produced by Kutztown Soda, Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop, and Walnut Creek. The manufacturers provide AmishTastes with a steady supply of products, and they have a good cooperative relationship with each other.

What is the purpose of your brand guide?

Our mission is to provide you with the most up-to-date and objective information about the AmishTastes products, helping you make more informed buying decisions. We recommend best choices of the products from the AmishTastes brand, helping you make better shopping choices with less time and energy.

Similar Brands

Magic Seasoning Blends