Best Mechanical Bathroom Scales of 2025

"I was tired of fussy scales that needed batteries and often failed to perform properly. For around $30, I found a scale that is battery-free and allows for easy manual reset. It can handle various weights and matches the accuracy of my doctor’s scale. I appreciate the spacious surface; my wide feet fit well, with only my pinky toes slightly hanging off. Thanks to previous reviews, I was ready to take a photo of the reading since the tick marks are hard to see."

"I wanted a straightforward scale, but the number markers are quite small. At 6'2", I find it challenging to read the display clearly. It’s a good scale otherwise, but I wish the numbers were larger for better visibility."

"I was hoping to enjoy this scale, especially since I'm done with unreliable digital ones. However, at 5'10", I struggled to see the dial even with my glasses on. I gave it 3.5 stars for its sturdy design, but sadly, I’ll have to return it because visibility is a significant issue for me."

"I love this scale! It’s easy to calibrate and feels very sturdy. Great value for the price! No worries about batteries or connectivity issues here."

"The scale works well for me, but I do struggle a bit with the small numbers. I often need to take a picture with my phone just to read it."

"I mainly bought this to weigh my garage door. It’s reasonably priced and seems accurate enough compared to my digital scale. The numbering is a bit small, but overall, it fits my needs."

“I appreciate the low-tech design of this scale; it’s so easy to use and doesn't require any batteries.”

“After dealing with inconsistent tech scales, I was happy to return to something sturdy and faithful. No batteries needed!”

“I found this scale to be lightweight and easy to tuck away, though I must admit it’s not as accurate as digital options.”

"I appreciate that this scale works great and is easy to use. I chose it because it doesn't require batteries, but I found it to be very small. As a woman who wears size 7 shoes, my feet almost cover the entire scale, and it only weighs up to 260 lbs. Other than that, it functions well."

"I bought this mechanical scale as a replacement for a faulty digital one. Unfortunately, despite my efforts to calibrate it correctly, it never returned to zero after weighing. I even ensured it was on a flat surface, but the readings were erratic. I expected a scale to do its only job—provide accurate weight measurements—but this one failed miserably. I'm left wondering if affordable scales are even made to work properly anymore."

"I like this scale for its manual calibration and no battery requirement. However, I overlooked whether it was designed for adult-sized feet. Perhaps there's someone out there with smaller feet, but I still find it accurate."

"I appreciate how accurate this scale is after calibrating it. It’s just the right size for my women's size 7 feet, and I love that it fits perfectly in my small bathroom."

"As a man with size 12D shoes, it’s difficult to find a scale that accommodates my feet. I have noticed that it’s somewhat challenging to read from afar, but overall, I’m satisfied with my purchase."

"I contacted customer service due to an issue with the scale, and they were incredibly responsive! They sent me a new one within two days, and it works perfectly now. Great support!"

"I threw out my older digital scale immediately. Just ensure it’s on zero before stepping on, and I have no problems."

"This scale is nice and sturdy, but I found it quite challenging to read the numbers. Even my husband struggled, so I unfortunately returned it."

"I dislike changing batteries, and with this scale, I can just do a simple calibration and step on. It's exactly what I needed for a straightforward experience!"

"I appreciate that I can just step on the scale and it works — no complicated process. The big, bright display makes it easy to read, even without my glasses!"

"This is my first time ordering from Amazon alone and I found the process to be simple and straightforward. The scale arrived in great condition and works consistently, which makes me very happy!"

"We were really looking forward to using this scale for our diet, but it was never on zero. I had to adjust it every time. This morning, it showed 120 pounds out of nowhere! It's completely inaccurate and I'm very disappointed."

"I really liked this scale, but I find the dial hard to read. My solution is to snap a picture with my cellphone and zoom in to see my weight, which works for me!"

"I chose this scale for its sturdy build and accuracy. It sits well on the ground and is stable, making it a solid choice for my family. Definitely a good deal for the price!"

"Honestly, I’m one of the few with perfect vision, yet I still struggle to see the numbers on this scale. The small hash lines make it tough to read accurately. If I hadn’t tossed the box, I would likely return it!"

"I find this scale works perfectly for my family, both kids and adults."

"I absolutely love this scale! The ability to calibrate it makes it very accurate, but the display is too small for me to read without taking a photo."

"This scale is basic and has everything I need. I don’t worry about batteries, and as long as my weight stays where it needs to be, I'm happy."

"I’ve had this scale for just a few days, and I’m impressed with its accuracy. After following the calibration instructions, it worked perfectly for both my wife and me. The large numbers are easy to read, and it feels well-made. I chose this mechanical scale for simplicity and it’s definitely a good buy. It’s a bit big, but we found room for it in our bathroom."

"I searched everywhere for a scale like this and was thrilled when I found it. It’s well-constructed, accurate, and easy to read. The calibration is straightforward with just a small adjustment wheel. Two years in, and it's still performing beautifully. I can confidently say it’s a great scale at a great price."

"I was excited about this scale for my dieting journey, aiming for simplicity without digital complexities. However, upon unpacking, I was disappointed to find that the plastic lens came off immediately. The chrome bezel is also plastic, which cheapens the look. Adjusting the calibration dial is too easy, and the font on the dial is hard to read. I expected better quality and will opt for a refund."