Best Ice Cream of 2026

"I've always loved Haagen-Dazs, and these mini ice cream bars have the ideal blend of chocolate, almonds, and creamy vanilla. The flavor is outstanding, and the snack size makes them easy to enjoy anytime. Even when they melt a bit, the texture stays creamy—not watery."

"I bought these for the mini size, thinking it would help me with portion control, but they're so delicious and melt in your mouth that I found myself reaching for a second one. If the packaging is kept cool during delivery, you'll get firm, on-the-stick ice cream for the perfect treat."

"This is my go-to when I want an indulgent, high-quality sweet treat. The thick chocolate coating over the super creamy vanilla ice cream tastes so rich—absolutely worth it when you want something special."

"I absolutely love this ice cream—it’s like a frozen cup of gourmet coffee! The flavor is rich and balanced and the texture is creamy and indulgent. It’s not overly sweet, so I enjoy it both on its own and with desserts like brownies or pie. No other brand compares—this is the only coffee ice cream I’ll buy!"

"For me, Häagen-Dazs Coffee Ice Cream is just exceptional. The taste is so good and authentic, and it stays chilly and crisp in the freezer. I also appreciate the energetic caffeination—it’s a treat that perks me up!"

"I really enjoy how creamy and dense this ice cream is. Along with their vanilla, it’s one of the few that uses just a handful of simple ingredients. That’s something I always look for!"

"I absolutely love this brand—the creamy texture and rich, authentic flavor make it my go-to ice cream. Plus, finding it at such a great price and receiving it in a cooler bag is a total bonus!"

"For me, the clean ingredients are a huge selling point. So many other brands are full of additives, but Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Bean tastes pure and delicious. It’s perfect for pairing with desserts or just satisfying a sweet craving."

"This is hands-down my favorite vanilla ice cream—it’s super rich and flavorful. I especially enjoy adding granola on top for a little crunch!"

"I'm always impressed by how rich and creamy this butter pecan ice cream is. The flavor of toasted pecans comes through beautifully, and there's a hint of caramelized sweetness that sets it apart. It tastes like a true treat, not just a basic ice cream."

"The taste is fantastic and the texture is rich and creamy. I just wish the quantity was a bit more for the price."

"I managed to snag this for an amazing price—just $2.18! Totally worth it for the quality."

"I've tried a lot of ice creams that claim to be the real deal, but Tillamook stands out with its smooth, creamy texture and genuine taste. Unlike others, it’s made with real ingredients, and you can truly taste the difference."

"I was pleasantly surprised by the deep, rich vanilla flavor and the super creamy consistency of this ice cream. The ingredient list is impressively clean, which is important to me. It’s honestly some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had!"

"As someone who avoids processed sugars and artificial additives, I was happy to find that Tillamook uses only basic, quality ingredients. It’s light, fluffy, and not overloaded with extras—a real treat for anyone who cares about what’s in their dessert."

"My family and I are big fans of this sherbet—the flavors are so vibrant and taste real, not artificial. The lemon stands out for me, it's like smooth, tart lemon ice. The texture is just right, especially on hot days. Plus, the price is better than most brand names."

"After trying this, I realized I should have been buying sherbet all along—it's delicious and exceeded my expectations, especially for the price! Definitely a treat worth repeating."

"As a long-time sherbet lover, I can say the quality here is excellent, and it costs me $3 less than what I pay at grocery stores. It's become a staple in my house."

"I've always considered Ben & Jerry's a staple from my childhood, and their Half Baked flavor is truly iconic. The combination of cookie dough and brownie pieces brings back memories of late-night snacks. While it's become a little pricier, I still love indulging in it as a special treat rather than a regular purchase."

"I picked up this ice cream to treat my niece, even though I rarely eat ice cream myself. She absolutely adored the Half Baked flavor, and honestly, I was surprised by how much I enjoyed it too. The mix of brownies and cookie dough is irresistible, especially for kids. For me, it's a once-a-year indulgence, but it's always worth savoring every bite."

"The taste is phenomenal—super creamy with a fantastic mouthfeel. I try different flavors, but this is my favorite chocolate variety from Ben & Jerry's. If you're looking for a dessert that never disappoints, this is it."

"I always look forward to this ice cream because of its delightfully creamy texture and reduced sugar. Plus, it’s always delivered right on schedule, making it so convenient!"

"I was really impressed with how affordable and tasty this ice cream was. The fact that it was delivered the same day I ordered just made the experience even better!"

"Watching my 4-year-old savor each bite of this vanilla ice cream was a treat in itself. She described it as 'eating a cloud' and couldn't stop smiling, calling it 'the sweetest magic ever.' Truly a moment of pure happiness."

"It’s hard to beat the combination of deep, rich chocolate flavor and incredibly creamy texture in this ice cream. I love that it’s made with simple, natural ingredients—no corn syrup, just real chocolate and cream. Plus, the price is much better than at my local store, so it’s a win for both taste and value."

"Every time I scoop into this Haagen-Dazs chocolate, I’m reminded why it’s a favorite. Smooth, indulgent, and never overly sweet, it delivers that authentic chocolate taste I crave. Perfect treat for a cozy night in or when I want to level up my brownies."

"I appreciate that this ice cream contains only four, all-natural ingredients—no artificial flavors or additives, just the essentials. It’s the kind of product where you can taste the quality in every bite."