Best Eye Makeup Remover of 2025

"I've been using this for 10 years. It's the only thing that removes my waterproof mascara with just a few swipes. Very effective and leaves my skin feeling soft too."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, I've struggled to find a makeup remover that's both effective and gentle. This one stands out because it doesn't sting or burn. Just a few gentle swipes, and my makeup is gone!"

"This remover works so quickly and is gentle on my eyes. I've found it to be much better than store-brand alternatives, and it doesn't pull out my eyelashes."

"I’ve tested countless eye makeup removers, and L'Oreal Paris Clean Artiste Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover is by far the best! It removes makeup effortlessly without any discomfort or oily residue. Just soak a cotton round, hold it on my eye briefly, and gently wipe—it’s that simple! No irritation or mess, just clean, fresh eyes after. I’ve been using it for years and recommend it to everyone!"

"I find this eye makeup remover to be great! It works effectively and takes off my mascara with ease. Definitely worth the price for me!"

"While I had hoped for better results, this eye makeup remover didn’t quite match my usual choice. However, it’s still a decent product for the price, hence my 4-star rating."

"I've always found it tough to maintain a proper skincare routine, especially when it comes to makeup removal. These Neutrogena Ultra-Soft Makeup Remover Wipes have been a total lifesaver for me! They work really well, even on my waterproof mascara, melting it away without any tugging. I love how moisturized my skin feels afterward—no tightness or greasy residue. Plus, not having to rinse is a massive time-saver at night!"

"For me, the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes are a game changer. They’re ultra-soft and remove makeup effortlessly, even waterproof types, without irritating my skin. I use them daily, and my face always feels clean and refreshed. Their compact packaging makes them perfect for travel, and I appreciate the pleasant, light fragrance."

"These wipes are the absolute best for makeup removal! They clean my face thoroughly and leave it feeling smooth and moist. I love the convenience of the packaging, making them easy to take when I travel. They don’t have an overpowering scent, and they’re incredibly strong. I highly recommend them; they’re worth every penny!"

"I've been using this product for decades. It's fragrance-free and gentle, doing exactly what it claims. I prefer using cotton products for makeup removal, and this remover is the only one that works perfectly for my tough eye makeup."

"I find the Lancôme eye makeup remover to be luxurious and effective. It works quickly and leaves my eyes feeling moist. I always recommend it!"

"This is the only eye makeup remover that doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. It effectively removes my waterproof mascara without causing any discomfort. I absolutely love it!"

"I absolutely love these cleansing wipes! They are soft yet sturdy, and they effectively remove my waterproof eyeliner and mascara. This is my third purchase, and I will definitely buy again. The mild scent is pleasant, and I always wash my face afterward."

"For me, Cetaphil makeup remover wipes are essential! They are gentle on my skin and remove all my makeup, including mascara, without any irritation. I appreciate that they don’t leave a greasy residue like other wipes."

"I was a bit disappointed with the Cetaphil makeup remover cloths. They felt a bit scratchy on my skin, and although they seemed to remove makeup at first glance, I noticed more makeup coming off when I used another product afterward."

"This product is simply the best! I've been using it for years to remove my mascara. I don't wear false lashes, so I can't comment on that, but I also appreciate the manufacturer's reputable skincare line."

"I can't believe I've finally found an eye makeup remover that works so gently and effortlessly! I use it with my Lancôme Waterproof mascara, and it takes everything off with ease. It's far better than any other product I've tried, even Micellar Water."

"As someone with sensitive eyes, this is the only makeup remover that doesn't hurt. It removes all my makeup effectively. I won't be using anything else!"

"I absolutely love how this product removes my makeup effortlessly. I often use waterproof liquid eyeliner and mascara, and this makeup remover takes it off without any hassle. No scrubbing required, and it’s not oily or drying. Plus, it's affordable! I will definitely buy it again."

"As a professional ice skater, I wear a lot of makeup, and I need something that can handle it. This brand is not only cruelty-free, but it also works wonders on my sensitive skin. No matter how much makeup I have, it wipes off easily. It's my go-to product for sure!"

"This product excels at removing eye makeup, even the stubborn waterproof types. I just need a couple of swipes, and it's gone. I do find it a bit oily, but if I shake it well, it’s not an issue. No scent, and it doesn't leave my face feeling greasy."

"I have been using the Neutrogena makeup remover for a decade, and it is absolutely the best. It offers the same quality as Lancôme's waterproof makeup remover but costs a third of the price. It's super gentle on my eyes and effectively removes waterproof eyeliner and mascara. I highly recommend it for anyone needing a waterproof makeup remover!"

"Just a small amount is enough to remove everything. I switched from Clinique to Neutrogena, and now I won't go back. It cleans well and is a fantastic price. I highly recommend it!"

"I appreciate that it’s not oily and removes all my mascara, even the waterproof kind. It doesn’t dry out my eyes or cause any stinging, and it feels quite moisturizing. I’ve been using it for a long time because it works quickly and effortlessly."

"I've always been adventurous with products, but I keep returning to this eye makeup remover. It’s perfect for my sensitive eyes—no irritation, no smell, just effective."

"I switched to Almay after being uncomfortable with Neutrogena's unsealed packaging. This eye makeup remover is wonderful; it doesn't irritate my eyes and has a seal for safety."

"I've used Lancôme for years, but on a trip, I grabbed this product. It's much cheaper and works just as well! I'm really satisfied with my choice."

"On a daily basis, I use these oil-based makeup remover pads because they are perfect for traveling without worrying about leaks. They effectively remove my waterproof mascara and I’ve had the same container for years without drying out!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by these pads. They are small and easy to manage, making them ideal for removing lash glue and makeup around my eyes. While they are greasy, I appreciate the control they offer, and they work well for my daily makeup removal."

"I initially thought I was getting a great deal with these small pads, but they turned out to be extremely oily. They leave a greasy layer on my face and aren’t gentle at all. After using them, I found myself scrubbing my face just to get rid of the residue. I’ll be returning to my Neutrogena wipes."