Best Crib Mattresses of 2025

"After countless sleepless nights, I found the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress to be a total lifesaver. Knowing my baby sleeps on a safe, certified mattress is invaluable. The waterproof cover came in handy during those diaper emergencies, and the mattress is firm and supportive, just as recommended. Transitioning from crib to toddler bed was seamless with this versatile mattress. I highly recommend it to any parent seeking quality sleep for their child."

"I absolutely love this crib mattress! It feels incredibly comfortable, and my baby rests soundly on it. Most importantly, it doesn’t make that annoying plastic-crinkly noise that some mattresses do. The waterproof cover is quiet and zips off easily for cleaning, making maintenance a breeze."

"I’m really happy with this well-made, firm crib mattress. My babies sleep well on it, and the crib sheets fit perfectly without any issues. The GREENGUARD GOLD certification reassures me about its safety, and I appreciate the effort that went into ensuring it’s low-emission foam."

"I think this Serta crib mattress is a winner! It's firm and supportive for my baby, which is just what I wanted. The waterproof cover is essential, and it's easy to clean. Plus, I appreciate that it's made in the USA and meets all safety standards. My little one sleeps soundly on it, and I feel confident about the quality."

"I love how light the mattress is; it makes changing the sheets a breeze. The plastic zipper cover is fantastic for any accidents! The firmness is perfect, and my baby sleeps wonderfully. This is a good affordable option!"

"This is my second time purchasing this mattress! It fits perfectly in our cribs. With two under two, nighttime messes can be challenging, but the material allows for easy cleanup while maintaining comfort."

"I bought this for my girl dog. She couldn't jump on the bed anymore, and she was not a floor dog. I felt like the mattress had a nice firmness. She loved her bed until she passed. Now, her feline sister is loving it too. I believe this mattress is great for both babies and pets, and it's easy to clean."

"My son seems to love it. The soft feeling and thickness exceeded my expectations. Set up was a breeze. We've had it for a couple of months now, and it's held up really well. It fits perfectly in his regular-sized crib and toddler bed!"

"I think the mattress is good for the price, as it came with my son's bed. The quality and material are impressive, and I would definitely buy it again. It's lightweight, firm, and my son sleeps longer on it. The appearance is also great, fitting perfectly on the bed!"

“My baby absolutely loves her bed! She falls right to sleep every time I lay her down. The size is perfect, and it’s waterproof, though I bought sheets just in case. I’m relieved there’s no smell—some beds can have odors, but this one doesn’t. It’s also quite thick, making her extra comfy.”

“I bought this mattress for my grandchild's toddler bed, and she adores it. It’s very comfortable and sturdy, and it holds up well against all her toddler antics!”

“This crib mattress is one of the most comfortable and well-made ones I've found. It’s firm but not too firm for my little one. I get the perfect blend of comfort and safety, and I’ll definitely buy another for my other baby!”

"I purchased this mattress for my son, seeking a breathable option for peace of mind. The firmness is just right, and he enjoys sleeping in it! There was no smell upon arrival, which was a pleasant surprise. I even tested it by burying my face into it and could still breathe. The mattress seems easy to clean, and I bought a waterproof cover for convenience. Overall, I would definitely buy again!"

"As a new mom, I was terrified of SIDS, often staying up to check on my baby. After getting the Newton mattress, I feel so much more at ease, and now we both get better sleep. It's not only comfortable and breathable, but it's also a breeze to clean after any accidents. Although it’s a bit pricey, it's worth every penny for the peaceful nights it provides!"

"I used to worry endlessly about my baby sleeping face down. This Newton mattress has really eased my anxiety. It's incredibly comfy and breathable, and I can wash both the outer layers and the inner mesh, which is a game changer. I even tried it myself and found it very comfortable. I line it with a thin cotton sheet, ensuring my baby is safe while sleeping face down. Absolutely worth the investment!"

“I bought this for my 2-month-old baby. So far, she is sleeping great on it! It's breathable yet firm for a newborn and also waterproof. Plus, it's not too noisy. I love that I can flip it over when she transitions to a toddler bed. It fits snugly in her crib, and it's a more affordable option compared to the hype around the Newton mattress.”

“This mattress is a perfect fit for our toddler bed! It's strong and has a good firmness for our little one. We've dealt with some vomit and accidents, but it just wipes clean, which is fantastic! It doesn't feel plastic or make crunchy sounds, so that's a plus!”

“Our baby loves the new mattress. I was worried it would be too firm, but she really enjoys it. It has no bad smell, which is a win when ordering from Amazon. Definitely a great value!”

"I love this mattress! It's comfortable and free from harsh chemicals or smells. After extensive research, we are very happy, and our baby loves it too."

"I transitioned my 5-month-old into the crib with ease! The breathable feature helps us parents sleep better too! It's soft and easy to clean, which is a huge plus!"

"Initially, I was hesitant about the price, but after using it, I realize it's worth every penny! The peace of mind knowing my baby can breathe regardless of sleeping position is invaluable!"

"I find it super comfortable and a great price. It fits well and is somewhat waterproof too."

"My child absolutely loves this mattress! It's firm enough, and she both sleeps and plays on it."

"I believe it's worth the price. The quality is good, and I'm pleased with the sleep experience."

"I was quite worried about receiving a damaged mattress like some reviewers, but it arrived in perfect condition. This mattress is puffy and very comfortable—I even felt like taking a nap! It's a great fit for my son's toddler bed and safe for babies too. I highly recommend it; it's a great price for a decent mattress!"

"I appreciate how easy it is to wipe down this mattress after accidents or for weekly sanitizing. It's been affordable and holds up well after two years of use, so I’m very satisfied with it!"

"I bought this for my senior dog, and he instantly recognized it as his. It's lightweight, making it easy for me to move from the porch to the bedroom at night. I’m really pleased with this purchase!"

"This mattress is exactly as advertised and incredibly comfortable for my toddler's bed at her grandparents. Everyone wanted to sit on it and hoped they could find one in a queen or king size!"

"I was initially hesitant due to some reviews, particularly about a strong odor. However, I experienced no odor at all. The mattress arrived quickly, expanded properly, and is great quality for the price. It's comfortable and supportive with two different sides, making it a great buy!"

"I kept my baby in the bassinet until she was about 5 months old, and transitioning her to this crib mattress was a breeze. She slept through the night after just one use. I love that it has a firm side and a soft side, which is perfect for when she becomes a toddler!"