Best Crib Mattresses of 2026

"I really appreciate that this mattress is firm yet comfortable, fitting perfectly in our crib and toddler bed. The fact that it is GREENGUARD Gold Certified gives me so much peace of mind about my child's safety. The waterproof protector is quiet and durable, even after multiple washes. For the quality and safety, I think it's an excellent value and would definitely recommend it to other parents."

"Switching to this mattress was a game changer for my child's sleep. Before, naps were short and restless, but with this mattress in their crib, my child falls asleep quickly and stays comfortable throughout the night. Thanks to this, my partner and I can finally get some sleep too."

"I've used this mattress since my child's crib days and now in the toddler bed. It's supportive and comfortable, and my daughter sleeps soundly without tossing and turning. The mattress is lightweight, making sheet changes easy, and the waterproof cover is quiet and simple to clean. For the price and overall quality, it's been a fantastic purchase."

"I've tried several crib mattresses over the years, and this one stands out for its perfect firmness and snug fit in the crib thanks to the square corners. I also appreciate the thick, soft, and durable waterproof layer. My only wish is for a more permanent label for the infant and toddler sides, but overall, this is a high-quality mattress I’d recommend to anyone."

"After going through three babies, I keep coming back to this mattress because it offers the right balance of safety and comfort. My children have always slept comfortably, and I love that there’s a toddler side to flip to as they grow. The size fits both cribs and toddler beds, making it very versatile."

"Switching to this mattress was a total game changer for my baby—she no longer dislikes lying down since we made the switch. The firmness is just right, and it’s clear she feels much more comfortable now."

"I’m really happy with this mattress—my toddler sleeps soundly on it and it fits his bed perfectly. The removable cover makes it a breeze to keep clean, and I love that it’s firm but still comfortable for him."

"After lots of research, I chose this mattress for its top quality, safety, and comfort. The infant and toddler sides are perfect for growing with my child, and I was relieved that it’s odorless and breathable despite being waterproof."

"As a first-time parent, I appreciate the reversible firmness for different stages and the GREENGUARD Gold certification. The waterproof cover is a lifesaver for quick cleanups, and the fact that it’s made in the USA gives me peace of mind about its quality."

"As a parent, I truly value the peace of mind this mattress provides. Its breathable material means I can sleep better knowing my baby is safe. The cover is easy to remove and machine washable, and the rest of the mattress can be rinsed off right in the tub. It’s so well-made and durable—we’ve bought one for each of our kids, despite the price, because it’s worth every penny."

"I did a lot of research after being worried about my daughter rolling over at night. When I found the Newton mattress, I was relieved. It’s more breathable than anything else I tried, with no chemical smells and no off-gassing. I even tested it myself—you can breathe right through it. Cleaning is a breeze, and I genuinely recommend it to anyone who wants extra reassurance for their baby’s safety."

"We switched to this mattress after being disappointed with other brands, and I couldn’t be happier. It’s perfectly firm yet comfortable, fits our crib exactly, and the breathability is unmatched—I even put my face into it and had no trouble breathing. Definitely a top recommendation for anyone shopping for a crib mattress."

"I’m so glad I chose this mattress! The dual-sided design is perfect—one side is firmer for babies, while the other is softer for toddlers. I especially appreciate that it's GREENGUARD Gold certified, waterproof, and hypoallergenic, which makes cleaning easy and gives me peace of mind about my child’s health. The quality and durability are top-notch, and it’s made in the USA!"

"This crib mattress turned out to be super soft and thick, and it fits our budget perfectly without sacrificing quality. I love that there’s no strong odor, and it really seems like it’ll be a comfy spot for our baby."

"From the start, I noticed there were no chemical smells or off-gassing, which was a huge relief. The mattress is both supportive and comfortable, and my kids sleep well on it. It fits the crib snugly and securely, and the lightweight design makes sheet changes much easier. After months of use, it’s still in great shape—no sagging or lumps. Definitely a dependable, practical crib mattress."

"My baby sleeps so much better now that we have this mattress. It’s firm but cozy, completely silent, and has zero odor. The fit is seamless in our full-size crib, which gives me peace of mind. I’m really pleased with this purchase!"

"As a grandmother, I wanted a mattress that was both safe and comfortable for my grandson. The breathable cover, easy cleaning, and perfect firmness really stood out to me. He sleeps much more soundly now, and I couldn’t be happier."

"The dual-sided feature is a game changer! One side is ideal for infants with extra firmness, while the other is softer for toddlers. It’s truly practical as my child grows—feels like getting two mattresses in one. Great value and versatility!"

"I'm beyond happy with this mattress. The firmness and support are exactly what I wanted for my child's transition from crib to toddler bed. The dual-sided feature is a real plus—one side is perfect for infants, the other a bit softer for toddlers. I appreciate the hypoallergenic, high-quality materials and the fact that it fits snugly in our crib. Cleaning it is a breeze. In my opinion, this is a premium, reliable choice for parents."

"The premium fleece surface of this mattress is just so incredibly soft and cozy, it's like my baby is sleeping on a cloud. The balance of comfort and firmness makes me feel secure about her safety, and her sleep has definitely improved. It's easy to maintain and built to last. Honestly, I wouldn't hesitate to call this a perfect mix of comfort and safety."

"I got this crib mattress for my baby and am really satisfied with the firmness for safe sleep and the comfortable feel. It fits perfectly in the crib, has no gaps, and is lightweight, making sheet changes simple. There was no odor, and cleaning is hassle-free. I'd gladly suggest this to other parents who want something affordable, comfortable, and safe."

"I feel so much peace of mind knowing this mattress is breathable and safe for my baby, especially since she likes to sleep on her stomach. It’s also super easy to wash—I can literally rinse it in the shower! The fit is perfect in our crib, and the quality is outstanding. I would absolutely buy it again and recommend it to other parents."

"After a lot of research, I settled on this mattress, and it’s been a fantastic purchase. It’s firm yet comfortable, and the fully washable cover has already come in handy. The snug fit and lack of chemical smell made me confident in my choice. My baby sleeps well, and I love that it will last into the toddler years."

"I was hesitant about the price, but it’s honestly worth every penny for the peace of mind. The mattress is completely breathable, so I don’t worry when my little one rolls onto his stomach. Plus, being able to hose it down for a deep clean is a huge bonus. I wish I’d bought this for my older kids too!"

"I found the bed very comfortable for my baby and it matched the photo exactly. I'm very satisfied with my purchase."

"I like that this bed is made of solid, sturdy wood and was simple to put together. The quality feels great."

"When the mattress arrived, there were large holes in the packaging, so it was dirty and unusable for my newborn. Communication with Dream On Me was difficult and disappointing."

"I’m really impressed with how firm, breathable, and high-quality this mattress is. My baby sleeps soundly through the night, and the mattress fits the crib perfectly. Lightweight, easy to clean, and offers great support. I definitely recommend it!"

"I purchased this for my three senior dogs since regular dog beds didn’t work for them. It holds its shape, doesn’t sink, and all my dogs love it. Even with heavy use, the mattress still looks and smells new thanks to using waterproof sheets. I’ve even laid on it with them, and it’s comfortable on my arthritis."

"We switched to this mattress for my toddler, and it’s been great. No more tossing and turning, and my child no longer wakes up sweaty. It came vacuum-sealed and inflated quickly, with no factory smell. The fit is snug with no gaps, and it’s as comfortable as an adult foam mattress for kids."