Best Cookie Mixes of 2026

"After struggling with my milk supply, I tried these cookies and was impressed by how quickly I noticed a positive change. The flavor is delicious, and I love that they're easy to take with me wherever I go. I’m already excited to try other flavors!"

"I was honestly skeptical but desperate when my supply began to dip. These cookie bites really worked for me and tasted amazing—almost addictive! The only thing is, I found I needed to eat a few each day for the best results, but I’m glad I gave them a shot and would definitely recommend them to other moms."

"As a new mom, I’m not sure if it was just these or a combination of things, but I did see a steady increase in milk supply while enjoying these cookies. They’re crunchy, tasty, and perfect with my morning coffee. I’ll be keeping them on hand for my next baby!"

"As someone who enjoys the occasional sweet treat, I really appreciate how simple and quick these cookies are to make. I can just toss one in the microwave or bake it in the oven, depending on my mood. The portion size is perfect for one, and I love being able to add extra chocolate or caramel for variety. Since my kids moved out, it’s been great having these on hand for a solo dessert."

"For me, there’s a certain comfort in baking, and this cookie mix delivers that with ease. The chocolate chunks are rich and satisfying, and the texture is soft and generous. While the sweetness can be a bit much and the edges sometimes crispier than I’d like, overall, it’s a reassuring treat that feels homemade and brings a quiet moment of joy to my day."

"I found the instructions a little off, needing more water and oil than stated, and it took longer in the microwave than the box suggested. The flavor was just okay—not terrible, but not something I’d buy again. Still, the price is good if you want a quick dessert, but it does require a bit more effort than expected if you’re looking for convenience."

"I bought this mix for a gluten-free guest at a special event, and it turned out to be a hit with everyone! The instructions were straightforward, the cookies were soft and full of rich peanut butter flavor, and you truly can't tell they're gluten-free. I was impressed enough that I'd purchase them again for myself, even without dietary restrictions."

"These cookies are so good that my entire family asks for them now! They taste just like traditional cookies, are super easy to whip up, and have become our new go-to treat. It's great to find a gluten-free option everyone enjoys."

"I've been trying to eat cleaner and decided to try this mix. These are hands down the best chocolate chip oat cookies I've had—chewy, rich chocolate, and not dry at all. Even though the dough was a bit crumbly while mixing, the end result was perfect! I'll definitely be ordering again."

"I've tried several gluten free cookie mixes, and this one stands out for its ease of preparation and fantastic flavor. I love being able to add my own favorite ingredients, and the cookies always turn out well."

"As someone who's been using this mix for years, I can honestly say it's consistently high quality and delicious. It's a staple in my pantry, and I plan to keep buying it."

"I recently discovered I needed to avoid gluten and was so relieved to find this mix. The cookies are full of flavor and turn out soft, as long as I follow the instructions carefully."

"As someone who bakes a lot during the holidays, I appreciate how simple this mix is to work with and how well the cookies hold their shape for decorating. The flavor really stands out, especially after adding frosting. I always use my favorite icing recipe from Preppy Kitchen."

"My daughter has Celiac Disease, and this is one of the few gluten-free mixes the whole family enjoys. It's now our go-to for holiday cutout cookies—everyone loves the taste!"

"I was surprised by the unique texture and taste thanks to the oat flour. The cookies are soft yet not crumbly, and my husband says they’re his all-time favorite. I like to stock up when it’s on sale since it’s hard to find locally."

"What I really appreciate is being able to make just one or two cookies at a time—no need to bake a whole batch and feel obligated to eat them all. The mix is super versatile; I can tweak the texture by adjusting the oil or butter, and toss in extras like butterscotch chips if I want. Fresh, warm cookies are ready in minutes, so it's perfect for those quick cravings!"

"This cookie mix is a lifesaver for my pantry. It’s incredibly easy and fast to use, and the cookies always turn out reliably delicious. I love that they keep for ages and I can make them without an egg if I just want to snack on the dough. Honestly, the flavor and convenience are top notch."

"I like how straightforward the directions are—just two added ingredients! It’s perfect for whipping up a treat in apartments where kitchen supplies are limited. The cookies have great flavor and the value is awesome for the price. Plus, it’s fun to get creative with add-ins like chocolate chips or a dollop of jam for variety."

"I found these cookies incredibly simple to prepare, and I love how soft and fluffy they turn out. The taste is amazing for the price—definitely a great value!"

"The cookies were delicious and arrived perfectly packaged. I prefer things super sweet, and while these weren't as sweet as I like, they were still very good and high quality, plus easy to bake in about 25 minutes."

"At first, I had doubts after reading some reviews, but after trying them myself, the cookies came out perfect with soft, chewy centers and a strong chocolate flavor. I'm really glad I gave them a chance!"

"I absolutely loved the classic cookie taste of these, and the price was unbeatable. They tasted just like the sugary cookies I used to buy, so I went ahead and ordered more. Way better than store-bought!"

"I was thrilled to discover these cookies as a lower sugar alternative that my whole family actually preferred over regular chocolate chip cookies! I tried to order more, but was disappointed to see they're currently unavailable. Hoping they restock soon!"

"These baked up with a texture more like a muffin or cake, but they were still really tasty—no missing out on sweetness here."

"My granddaughter had a blast making and sharing these cookies with the family. The instructions were very clear and simple for her to follow, even at just 7 years old."

"I grew up loving the Easy Bake Oven, so I was excited to buy this for my niece. The set is adorable and brought her a lot of joy, but I was a bit surprised at the cost for just one use. I wish it lasted longer, but seeing her have fun made it worthwhile."

"The cookies were delicious and enjoyable to make! My daughter thinks these are the best-tasting ones she's made so far."

"I'm thrilled with these cookies for my daughter! They've noticeably increased her milk supply and the taste is absolutely amazing. She loves them!"

"I’ve tried making lactation cookies at home, but these store-bought ones are so delicious that I can’t stop eating them. Even if they didn’t help with milk supply (which they do), I’d still want to eat them all!"

"After several bags, I can say that being consistent with these cookies has helped my milk supply, plus they’re delicious and satisfy my chocolate craving. My only wish is that they were a bit less expensive, and sometimes they arrive a little broken, but the taste makes up for it."