Best Cookie Mixes of 2025

"I can't express how much I love this cookie mix! It's super convenient, relatively inexpensive, and the cookies are just delicious. I prefer using real butter for that homemade taste, and adding a dash of vanilla makes them even better. I bake them in mini muffin tins, which is a fun twist! Perfect for last-minute treats or sharing with friends. One package is just right for a small craving – I believe everyone should keep this cookie mix on hand!"

"These are honestly the best peanut butter cookies I’ve ever tasted, and they’re a breeze to whip up! I’m thrilled with my decision to try this cookie mix; in under ten minutes, I had perfect cookies. They are perfectly balanced in flavor – sweet but not too salty. I bought two bags and had to restrain myself from eating more than three at once; they’re that addictive!"

"I’m not much of a baker, but these cookies turned out just like a professional made them! I decided to make smaller cookies and ended up giving some away, and I can't wait to order this mix again!"

"I bought this for my wife because she loves baking, and these cookies taste great! Everybody enjoys them during the holidays. They are easy to bake and mix well. It's a great value for the price."

"I had a craving for a peanut butter cookie, so I opened this product. In just 20 minutes, I took them out of the oven, and they were still tasty the next day. I even had some for breakfast!"

"I've always made peanut butter cookies from scratch, but these are delicious and super quick. I used melted coconut oil, and they turned out great. I only got nine small cookies from the bag, which was less than I expected, but they were so good that I want to try making ice cream sandwiches with them!"

"I enjoy making this for a 97-year-old man living in a nursing home. He loves cookies and his eyes light up when he sees this giant cookie. It mixes up easily, comes with its own disposable pan, and tastes great. I am careful not to overcook it because I like the cookie to be soft rather than crunchy. I will continue to purchase this handy kit."

"So easy to make! The taste is great and it does the job when I want something quick and sweet. The quality is excellent and I really appreciate how convenient this product is."

"I tasted the batter and found it to be overly sweet. I balanced it out by adding salt until it tasted like regular cookie dough. To die for! It’s a shame the mix is a bit unbalanced, but it’s an easy fix. I will definitely purchase again, although the calories are staggering at 140 for 1/9 of the cookie!"

"I found this dough to be fantastic! It mixed easily and cooked perfectly. Those marshmallows were just amazing. Honestly, the dough was so good that I’m lucky some actually made it to the oven. It’s sweet enough that frosting isn't necessary!"

"While I've had sugar cookies that tasted better, I thought these were decent. I swapped out the butter for a quarter cup of oil, and it yielded 18 snack-sized cookies."

"I appreciate the easy preparation. The taste is great and the texture is good."

"I would advise against buying this product. I used them for Christmas and they had an odd, plastic taste and the texture was off. After baking, they tasted stale too."

"I love that I can make two cookies or 20. They really taste like homemade!"

"When I'm craving something, I can easily mix up a batch and enjoy them fresh and hot."

"I find these cookies absolutely delicious! They're definitely the best gluten-free cookies we've ever made, and my husband agrees. We couldn't even tell they were gluten-free. The texture was moist and chewy, and I love that I can customize them with my favorite add-ins like chocolate chips and heath toffee pieces. Chilling the dough for an hour really made a difference!"

"As someone with celiac disease, I've been on the hunt for a cookie that tastes like the real deal since my diagnosis four years ago. I can confidently say that this is the best cookie mix I've tried! I've experimented with homemade versions and other expensive gluten-free mixes, but none compare. The best part is the flexibility to add whatever you want or bake them plain. This mix is well worth the money, easy to prepare, and simply delicious!"

"I've bought these cookies multiple times, and they're always consistently excellent! I have dietary restrictions and use an egg substitute, but even with that, they turn out amazing every time. I highly recommend these cookies to anyone looking for a reliable gluten-free option!"

"My son absolutely loves these cookies! I made him a lemon cake for his birthday, but added these as a backup. To my delight, not only does he enjoy them, but his younger siblings do too. They're essentially peanut butter oatmeal cookies with chocolate chips and candies. They require just one egg, two tablespoons of butter, and half a cup of peanut butter to prepare. I made 18 medium-sized cookies from each bag, and at under $4, it's a fantastic deal for a mix. Plus, with only 14g of carbs per cookie, they fit perfectly into our family's dietary needs. I'm definitely going to buy these regularly!"

"When I first tried making these monster cookies, I used sunflower butter, which didn't turn out quite right because of its oil content. However, the flavor was still fantastic! On my second attempt, I poured off some of the oil from the sunflower butter to get a better consistency, and the cookies looked much improved while retaining their great taste. Honestly, if you didn’t know these cookies were top allergen-free, you’d never guess!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by these cookies! For being a gluten-free product, they were very soft and delicious. They almost made me wonder if they were truly gluten-free. My grandson and daughter, who has Celiac disease, loved them, and my other grandchildren couldn't even tell they were gluten-free. I will definitely be buying these again!"

"My daughter and I absolutely love this cookie mix. It's hard to find in stores, so we’re glad to order it from Amazon. We prepare the mix and keep it in the fridge, allowing us to enjoy a few yummy cookies throughout the week as our special treat. Great quality!"

"I decided to try these after reading the reviews. I planned to make them for Christmas Eve with my daughter for Santa, but I couldn’t resist and made them early. These cookies melt in your mouth! However, I noticed they are cheaper at a local store. I also recommend adding some brown sugar and vanilla bean extract for an extra touch, and definitely refrigerate the dough before baking! I’ll buy again from Amazon if I can’t find them locally!"

"I bought this mix to create cut-out cookies for Christmas. The flavor and texture were excellent. I’d suggest it for anyone looking to save time or needing a simple solution for cookie dough!"

"I've been using this cookie mix for years. It's incredibly easy and flavorful, and I just follow the directions."

"I absolutely love these delicious chocolate chip cookies! I'm thrilled I can still order them because they aren't available in stores anymore."

"I have a cookie reputation to uphold, and this is my go-to mix. I like to add a bit of unsweetened coconut and pecan chips. I've never made a better cookie from scratch!"

"I made cut-out sugar cookies using this mix, and they turned out fantastic. After cutting them and placing them on the baking sheet, I put them in the freezer for 5 minutes before baking to help them keep their shape. I added about 1 1/2 tablespoons of dark cocoa to make them chocolate-flavored. They were delicious, and I would definitely buy this again when I want an easier option than making from scratch."

"After trying countless boxed sugar cookies, I finally found the best! These cookies are nice and chewy with just the right sweetness. I froze the dough for 30 minutes before cutting them out, which helped maintain their shape. I baked my smaller stars for 7 minutes, and they came out perfect! My daughter had a blast making these with me, and I will definitely be buying them again!"

"As someone with celiac disease, I rarely enjoy baked goods, but this gluten-free mix is outstanding for cut-out cookies during Christmas. It works exceptionally well, and surprisingly, the cookies taste even better after a day. I'm not sure if it's the cream cheese frosting, but they get softer without breaking. I buy two boxes because they disappear quickly, and honestly, they taste better than my old recipe from 15 years ago!"