Best Christian Mystery & Suspense Romance Books of 2025

The Shack by Wm. Paul Young is a heart-wrenching novel that deals with the question of where God is in a world filled with pain. The story revolves around Mackenzie Allen Philips, whose youngest daughter is abducted and possibly murdered. Four years later, he receives a mysterious note from God, inviting him back to the shack where his daughter was taken. The answers he finds there will astound and transform him. This book has the potential to become a classic in Christian literature, and it is a must-read for anyone searching for answers in a world of suffering.

The Water Keeper by Charles Martin is a captivating novel about Murphy Shepherd, a man with many secrets who lives alone on an island. After rescuing a woman named Summer from Florida's Intracoastal Waterway, Murph's life takes a dangerous turn as he helps her find her missing daughter, leading him into the dark and dangerous world of modern-day slavery. With the help of unexpected friends, he must race against time to locate the girl before his past consumes him. Martin's poignant prose and multilayered story make The Water Keeper a tender love story and a heartrending search for freedom. This book is a must-read for fans of Charles Martin and contemporary Christian fiction.

At Home in Mitford is the first book in Jan Karon's bestselling series, which takes place in Mitford, America's favorite small town. The novel follows the story of Father Tim, a bachelor rector who longs for something more. When a large dog and an attractive neighbor move in, Father Tim's life takes an unexpected turn. This heartwarming story is a rich comedy about ordinary people and their ordinary lives. The book is a must-read for those who enjoy homespun tales about endearing characters.

The Cartel Deluxe Edition, Part 2: Books 4 and 5 by Ashley & JaQuavis is a gripping addition to the Cartel series. This second deluxe edition includes books four and five, which follow the Diamond family as they navigate murder, deceit, and betrayal in their quest to maintain their position of power. The family faces new challenges and threats, but they are determined to stay on top. The female members of the family step up to lead and establish a new endeavor, but trouble always finds a way into their circle. Overall, this book is a thrilling read that will keep readers on the edge of their seats.

The Record Keeper is the third installment in the Murphy Shepherd series, written by New York Times bestselling author Charles Martin. In this Christian mystery and suspense romance book, Murphy is tested both physically and mentally when his beloved mentor and friend is taken without a trace. With heart-stopping clarity, Martin explores the true cost of leaving the ninety-nine to find the one. The book also includes discussion questions for book clubs. Overall, The Record Keeper is a gripping and thought-provoking read that will keep readers on the edge of their seats until the very end.

The Letter Keeper is the second book in the Murphy Shepherd series by New York Times bestselling author Charles Martin. It is a heart-wrenching story that explores the power of sacrificial love. Murphy Shepherd, a survivor of human trafficking, has dedicated his life to helping others find freedom until his own family is stolen. With more dead ends than leads, Murphy is left questioning everything he thought was true. The novel is part of HarperCollins Christian Pub.'s contemporary Christian fiction books. Overall, The Letter Keeper is a gripping and emotional read that will keep readers on the edge of their seats.

Jonas: A Minnesota Marshalls Novel is a thrilling second book in the epic romantic suspense of the Minnesota Marshalls. The story follows Jonas Marshall, a weatherman who is experimenting with dirigibles in Slovenia when he finds himself in danger. He is joined by Sibba Kovac, a woman searching for her missing grandfather, and together they face a threat of a dirty bomb. The book is full of action, drama, adventure, flawed individuals, and emotional and spiritual challenges. Overall, it is a great addition to the Marshall family romantic adventures and a unique Christian Mystery & Suspense Book.

Robinson Crusoe by Daniel Defoe is a classic tale of a shipwrecked castaway’s survival and eventual triumph over the challenges of nature and his own fears. The story is widely considered to be the first English novel and has remained one of the most read tales in modern literature for almost three centuries. The enduring freshness and immediacy of its style, as well as its status as a prototype for the novel genre, make it a unique and timeless masterpiece of literature.

The Vanishing at Castle Moreau by Jaime Jo Wright is a Christian Mystery & Suspense book that tells the story of two women in different timelines who are tasked with finding the truth behind a century-old curse at Castle Moreau. Daisy François, an orphaned housemaid in 1870, and Cleo Clemmons, a modern-day professional organizer, both face the terrifying consequences of a haunting legend. The author seamlessly weaves together the two timelines, creating a gripping suspense novel that will keep readers on the edge of their seats. Overall, The Vanishing at Castle Moreau is an imaginative and mysterious tale that is sure to captivate readers who enjoy Christian Mystery & Suspense books.

Shattered Whispers is a Christian mystery and suspense book that follows Abby Mendez, an actress who stumbles upon a dead body backstage in her theater. She becomes entangled in a dangerous plot with a script she didn't write. Former Navy SEAL Hunter Bancroft is willing to risk everything to protect Abby and those close to her from the killer. As the truth comes to light, whispers from the past threaten to destroy the new starts both Abby and Hunter desperately seek. Will they be able to catch the culprit before it's too late?