Best Christian Fiction Collections & Anthologies Books of 2025

Wilson Cook Avatar
Wilson Cook
Last Updated: Apr 24, 2023

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Christian fiction collections and anthologies books are a great way to explore a variety of stories and themes within the Christian genre. These books typically contain a collection of short stories or novellas written by different authors, allowing readers to experience a range of writing styles and perspectives. They can cover a wide range of topics, from historical fiction to contemporary romance, and are often centered around themes of faith, forgiveness, and redemption. Whether you're a devout Christian or simply enjoy heartwarming stories with a moral message, these collections are a great addition to any bookshelf.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

The Complete Apocrypha: Collection of all the 16 Books Rejected from the Bible Cover #TOP 1
The Complete Apocrypha: Collection of all the 16 Books Rejected from the Bible
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse Cover #TOP 2
Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Bathed in Prayer: Father Tim's Prayers, Sermons, and Reflections from the Mitford Series Cover #TOP 3
Bathed in Prayer: Father Tim's Prayers, Sermons, and Reflections from the Mitford Series
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Christian Fiction Collections & Anthologies Books

#TOP 1

The Complete Apocrypha: Collection of all the 16 Books Rejected from the Bible

Reads, Holy
May 20, 2022
The Complete Apocrypha: Collection of all the 16 Books Rejected from the Bible Cover
The Complete Apocrypha: Collection of all the 16 Books Rejected from the Bible

The Complete Apocrypha is a comprehensive collection of 16 books that were excluded from the Bible. This book includes various ancient texts such as 1 and 2 Esdras, Tobit, Judith, Baruch, and many others. The book is available in both paperback and hardcover formats with high-quality text prints and illustrations. As a roundup review website editor, this book is an excellent addition to any Christian's library. The Complete Apocrypha provides a unique perspective on the Bible's history and offers an in-depth look into the religious texts that were not included in the final version of the Bible.

#TOP 2

Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse

Larsen, Laurie
Budd, Kelsey R
Henderson, Melissa
Miley, Dianne
Sibley, Laurie Ingram
Stallings, Jody
Sinisi, Christina
Wiley, Annette
Apr 2, 2023
Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse Cover
Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse

Charleston Light: Stories Inspired by Sullivan's Island Lighthouse is a collection of faith-filled novellas written by authors from the American Christian Fiction Writers South Carolina Lowcountry Chapter. The stories range from sweet romance to time travel, and from fantasy to a modern retelling of a fairytale. All the tales are inspired by Charleston Light, the lighthouse on the shore of Sullivan's Island, South Carolina. The book's proceeds will be donated to the Sanctuary of Unborn Life in Charleston, a faith-based nonprofit that supports pregnant women and new mothers in need. This book is a unique and heartwarming read that will leave readers feeling uplifted and inspired.

#TOP 3

Bathed in Prayer: Father Tim's Prayers, Sermons, and Reflections from the Mitford Series

Karon, Jan
G.P. Putnam's Sons
Oct 30, 2018
Bathed in Prayer: Father Tim's Prayers, Sermons, and Reflections from the Mitford Series Cover
Bathed in Prayer: Father Tim's Prayers, Sermons, and Reflections from the Mitford Series

Bathed in Prayer is a must-have collection for fans of the New York Times bestselling Mitford series. This book features the prayers, sermons, and inspiration from beloved Father Tim, as well as new essays and reflections on faith from author Jan Karon. The beautifully designed compilation incorporates material from each of the fourteen novels and includes a brand-new essay from the author about her own personal journey in faith. This book is full of advice and inspiration from the characters that fans have followed for years and will become a staple for any Mitford reader.

#TOP 4

Hope Springs Books 1-3: Three Christian Romances in One Collection (Hope Springs Box Sets)

Bodden, Valerie M.
Oct 31, 2019
Hope Springs Books 1-3: Three Christian Romances in One Collection (Hope Springs Box Sets) Cover
Hope Springs Books 1-3: Three Christian Romances in One Collection (Hope Springs Box Sets)

Hope Springs Books 1-3 is a collection of three heartwarming Christian romance novels that will make readers fall in love with the people of Hope Springs. The stories follow three different couples who are faced with difficult decisions and learn to trust in God’s plan for their lives. The characters are well-developed and the stories are filled with faith, forgiveness, and the promise of forever. The book is perfect for readers who enjoy Susan May Warren or Denise Hunter’s work. Overall, this box set is a touching and powerful reminder of the power of love and the hope that comes with a second chance.

#TOP 5

Sisters by the Sea

Wanda E. Brunstetter
Oct 1, 2023

Sisters by the Sea is a heartwarming collection of four Amish romance stories that follow the Lambright sisters as they move from Indiana to a unique tropical Amish community in Sarasota, Florida. Each story is written by a different Brunstetter author, bringing their own unique style to the collection. The stories are filled with romance, faith, and family, making it a delightful read for fans of Amish romance books. Overall, Sisters by the Sea is a well-written and engaging book that showcases the authors' talent in crafting memorable characters and touching stories.

#TOP 6

The Prayer Jars Trilogy: 3 Amish Romances from a New York Times Bestselling Author

Brunstetter, Wanda E.
Barbour Fiction
Jul 1, 2021
The Prayer Jars Trilogy: 3 Amish Romances from a New York Times Bestselling Author Cover
The Prayer Jars Trilogy: 3 Amish Romances from a New York Times Bestselling Author

The Prayer Jars Trilogy by Wanda E. Brunstetter is a collection of three Amish romance books that take readers on a journey of personal reflection. The trilogy follows three young women who find antique jars hidden around an Amish farm, filled with slips of paper containing thoughts, quotes, and prayers by an unknown author. As the jars become a tool to restore a family's faith, the women must confront their own pasts and struggles. Brunstetter's writing accurately portrays the Amish way of life, making the books well-read and trusted by many Amish. Overall, The Prayer Jars Trilogy offers a unique and heartwarming reading experience for fans of the Amish romance genre.

#TOP 7

Love Through the Seasons

Tracie Peterson
Feb 1, 2023
Love Through the Seasons Cover
Love Through the Seasons

Judging by the body of her work over the past 30 years, Tracie Peterson is quite arguably the "Queen of Historical Christian Fiction". Love Through the Seasons, a collection of both old and new stories, showcases Peterson's talent for crafting contemporary romances set in her native state of Kansas. The four short stories are perfect for readers looking for heartwarming Christian romance fiction. Peterson's ability to weave faith and love into each story is remarkable. Overall, Love Through the Seasons is a delightful read that will leave readers feeling warm and fuzzy inside.

#TOP 8

Timeline In My Mind: A collection of poems & short stories

Holland, E.V.
Apr 15, 2023
Timeline In My Mind: A collection of poems & short stories Cover
Timeline In My Mind: A collection of poems & short stories

The book “Timeline In My Mind: A collection of poems & short stories” is a beautiful piece of work that covers everything from the early Renaissance to modern-day events, from Christianity to mental health. The author is a lifelong storyteller who retells iconic swash-buckling fairytales and murder mysteries of a famous detective. The book introduces characters, plots, and poetic devices that will captivate readers for hours. It’s a must-read for anyone who loves Christian Fiction Collections & Anthologies Books and classic literature. Overall, the book is a unique and exceptional masterpiece that will leave readers inspired and entertained.

#TOP 9

He Giveth More Grace: One Hundred Poems by Annie Johnson Flint (Annie Johnson Flint Collection)

Johnson Flint, Annie
Jones, M.P.
Independently published
Nov 14, 2019
He Giveth More Grace: One Hundred Poems by Annie Johnson Flint (Annie Johnson Flint Collection) Cover
He Giveth More Grace: One Hundred Poems by Annie Johnson Flint (Annie Johnson Flint Collection)

He Giveth More Grace: One Hundred Poems by Annie Johnson Flint is a collection of inspirational poetry by one of the greatest hymnwriters, Annie Johnson Flint. Despite being crippled with arthritis for much of her life, Annie left an incredible legacy of writing. Her poems, including the most well-known "He Giveth More Grace," reflect an unwavering faith in God's promises through her trials and a delightful appreciation of God’s creation. This book is a special blessing to those who have recently been bereaved or experiencing difficult trials and will inspire and encourage all believers on their disciple journey. The book is unique for its collection of one hundred poems and its reflection of the author's unwavering faith in God's promises.

#TOP 10

Easter Stories: Classic Tales for the Holy Season

Lewis, C.S.
Tolstoy, Leo
Lagerlöf, Selma
Wilde, Oscar
Goudge, Elizabeth
Gorky, Maxim
Paton, Alan
Thoma, Hans
Trocmé, André
Colum, Padraic
Sawyer, Ruth
Wangerin, Walter
LeBlanc, Miriam
Plough Publishing House
Feb 2, 2015
Easter Stories: Classic Tales for the Holy Season Cover
Easter Stories: Classic Tales for the Holy Season

Easter Stories: Classic Tales for the Holy Season is a remarkable collection of short stories that capture the spirit of Easter in a way that will captivate readers of all ages. The book includes time-honored favorites from world-famous storytellers such as C.S. Lewis, Leo Tolstoy, Selma Lagerlof, Oscar Wilde, Elizabeth Goudge, Maxim Gorky, Ruth Sawyer, and Walter Wangerin – as well as many you’ve never heard before. The stories come from all over the world and represent many genres, such as parables, animal fables, historical fiction, fairy tales, and Christian fantasy. The original woodcuts by Lisa Toth for each tale add to the charm of this thoughtfully curated collection. Overall, this book is an excellent choice for anyone who wants to delve deeper into the true meaning of Easter beyond the usual bunnies and eggs."

Buying Guide Image
Editor's Notes

During our christian fiction collections & anthologies book research, we found 1,200+ christian fiction collections & anthologies book products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 14,993 customer reviews through our big data system to write the christian fiction collections & anthologies books list. We found that most customers choose christian fiction collections & anthologies books with an average price of $15.59.

Written by
Wilson Cook Avatar

Wilson Cook is a talented writer who has an MFA in creative writing from Williams College and has published more than 50 books acquired by hundreds of thousands of people from various countries by now. He is an inveterate reading lover as he has read a vast amount of books since childhood.